12 Best Italian Restaurants in Ithaca

“Ordered a supreme last night..it was amazing!!! Will definitely be frequenting this place☺️“

“Lunch buffet is a great choice -healthy and quality food and great service. Life is service!“

“I had the lemon artichoke pasta . It was excellent along with the service !“

“We had an amazing dinner here. Our server was so attentive and professional, the timing of everything was perfect. We ordered two entrees that we were planning to share, and the server had the kitchen split them for us without us asking, which felt really above and beyond. We had a white wine that the server helped us select, the fettuccine with clams, chicken piccata, finishing up with panna cotta and coffee. Each part perfect. We loved the cozy vibe inside as well.“

“This place is amazing , food is great Definitely authentic Italian food . We love it 100% ❤️ The only disappointment is this guy named Steve (sever) he’s so rude. The way he talked to he’s coworkers is unbelievable. No respect at all specially with young people. Hopefully the owners are aware of this guy behavior.“

“We both really enjoyed the pizza. Love the crispy crust too! Toppings were fantastic! We will definitely need to come back! We'll spread the word!!!“

“Thanks. Guys There. Pizza. Is. Os. Good“

“Just went yesterday while in Ithaca. Great pancakes and service!“

“You will not find a better place or nicer people on the commons than this place. One of my fav places !“

“I have visited Ithaca several times and every time I am in town I eat here!!! Prices are modest and the food is delicious!!! Service is friendly and courteous!! Facilities are kept clean and orderly! Plenty parking and plenty to choose from!!! Bring your friends, family and colleagues you will love it!!!“

“Las pizzas más ricas que he probado!“

“Fabulous food, huge portions, reasonably priced, and terrific service!“