16 Best Italian Restaurants near Waterloo

“This was such a great find after a long day on the fall tours. We were driving to Ithaca and looking for some good food. We were all so pleased surprised. Everything was fresh and delicious and the service was stellar! Mushroom pasta and the fish!!!“

“I've always loved ciccinos, but it seems like they're downsizing.I love me and my boyfriend.Both love their cheeseburg subs and they were all bred in no burger.No tomato, hardly know anything we ate bread.So no, I'm not happy with it, but you guys are the best.And what you do so why downsize?“

“Wait service remains a bit ditsy. Forgot the soup, dropped the dishes on the floor. Food, OK. Brussel sprouts haven't changed in years, still a bit over fried in too much oil. Shortribs, could have used a sharper knife, a bit tough to chew. Though we have dined there a number of times since they opened, Will probably be a good while before we try it again, if we do.“

“Exceptional pasta and food quality. Don't forget to order the focaccia with ricotta for an appetizer. Olive oil cake for dessert is a favorite.

Service was top notch and very attentive. Recommendations spot on.

Parking lot was a little tricky as it was busy and there was limited parking. The bar has a good atmosphere at the front and had live music. Maybe a little loud for an intimate dinner but there's the back dining room which was a perfect for a date night.“

“Definitely my favorite restaurant in Geneva! Always feel welcome and have great meals.“

“Ordered Scallops Alfredo they were terrible. I took it home bc Alfredo sauce had too much parm cheese. I took it home made an au gratin sauce it was fantastic“

“I had a wonderful experience here last week! The owners star & Elizabeth are such lovely people! The food was excellent, the beer was on point, and the servers were terrific. Highly recommend!!“

“Pizza is always hot and on time.....and delicious!“

“Dana hit a Grand Slam with us last night. As always the food was delicious. If you haven’t already had a meal and you’re hungry Dana’s won’t disappoint you. Thank You for the great food and service.“

“We had their pizza by the slice which was very good. We enjoyed a slice of pepperoni, Buffalo chicken wing and my favorite was dill pickle! Staff was friendly.“

“The steak dinner was amazing and great night out, thank you Chuck and staff.“

“I ordered a NY style pizza and a meatball sub. The pizza was very good and yes I mean very good!
The sub had issues, very little sauce and cheese, meatballs were different, kind of like boiled and bland. That is what they looked and tasted like. I apologies because the service was great making it hard to be honest here. Your choice of sub bread was not good either .The prices didn't not match the on line menu. I am giving a 5 for service and the pizza.
I am giving a 2 for the sub, it wasn't the worst sub I have had but no where close to the best as well.“

“We had this pizza tonight in Geneva, New York. It was a 35 minute wait on a Monday night. All 4 of us all thought the dough was really tough. We ordered extra sauce and they did not disappoint; it was really good. We got a 12 cut - pepperoni pizza 🍕 Rating: 6/10“

“This is one of my son’s favorite places to visit in Geneva. Geneva Gelato always has delicious flavors to choose from as well as coffee, tea, and other desserts. Recently, Geneva Gelato hosted my son’s fourth birthday party, and I couldn’t be happier with how it turned out. It was a wonderful venue for family and friends to celebrate. We were able to come a little early to do a little setting up, we were able to bring our own cupcakes, and they even gave goody bags to all the kids who came. The staff was so accommodating and kind; they even joined us in signing Happy Birthday to my son. What a fantastic place! I highly recommend visiting or asking about small events.“

“Lovely restaurant with a terrace overlooking the vineyards and lake. Fast, friendly service.
The menu was a bit surprising - from a winery restaurant, you’d expect something more refined than pizza.
Still, we had a wonderful evening, enjoyed the atmosphere, and the local wine was excellent and reasonably priced.“

“very expensive and horrible service…the waiter had to be told what we needed instead of asking us first,food was COLD not warm but COLD…we were sat down without plates or napkins when given our appetizer and when asked it took almost 15 minutes to recieve them the waiter also never asked how the food was or anything else…FIRST AND LAST TIME GOING HERE!!!!“