Italian Restaurants near Fairport

Compane Trattoria Italian • $$
25 Parce Ave, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Oatmeal Cookie Cheesecake
Chicken Parmigiana
High Street Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Caesar Salad
Meatballs
Gnocchi

“Celebrated my sister's birthday last night (party of 10) and our waiter Noah was fantastic. Knew the menu and could answer questions in detail. Great service. Food was prepared as ordered, was hot and tasted fresh. Nice atmosphere. The only concern is with the level of noise. The restaurant was about half full and it was noisy. I didn't see any sound absorption tiles or banners and I would recommend they invest in some.“

3.9 Good76 Reviews
Bocaccini's Italian Bistro Italian • $$
6720 Pittsford Palmyra Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Papa Joe's Special Spaghettini Marinara Instead of Red Sauce One Meatball & One Sausage
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Shrimp & Lobster Risotto
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Salmon Fra Diavolo
Sicilian Calamari
Lasagna Bolognese
Penne Gorgonzola
Chicken Carbonara
Chicken Marsala

“Loved our date night at Bocaccini's. The waitress was incredibly sweet. My husband loved his cocktails. The food was great. Everything tasted fresh and flavored well. I got the Papa Joe special with sausage and meatballs. I'm pretty sure the sausage was a Tony Coretta sausage, which I already loved. My husband got the chicken parm and he was very happy with the amount and the taste. We both shared a tiramisu dessert, and it was light, fluffy, and delicious.The atmosphere was crisp, modern yet comfortable. Everything was clean and tidy.We hope to be back for another date night soon!“

3.8 Good90 Reviews
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Pizza • $$
55 S Main St, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Charlie Pizza
Burger
Fries

“The pizza from here is always great! It arrives hot, and tastes amazing. I love the many options for in store slices as well. Some pizza places only have pepperoni or cheese slices, but this Salvatore’s location seems to have a variety. I wanted to give a shoutout to my delivery driver tonight. He was extremely kind, and you could tell he has a good heart. Only wish I would’ve tipped him more, because now I feel like a jerk. I don’t know his name, but this guy definitely deserves a raise for great friendly service.“

2.5 Average33 Reviews
Mr. Dominic's on Main Italian • $$
1 E Church St, Fairport

“We went to Mr Dominic's to celebrate a friends birthday. The service was great. Our sever was very friendly and made us laugh with her witty comments. I am not a big fan of pasta. So she got me Chicken French with baked potatoes and broccoli. That was great. I also had ordered a cocktail which was also perfectly done. I loved the ambience of this place. It's pretty spacious and welcoming. I'd go back any time! They have this space where celebrations can be hosted. Pretty cool!!!“

0 Na0 Reviews
Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage Pizza • $
1157 Culver Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Detroit Style Pepperoni Pizza
Mikes Hot Honey Dip Cup
Margherita Sicilian
Mozzarella Fritta
Housemade Sausage
Creamy Gorgonzola
Margherita Pizza
Quattro Formaggi
Marinara Sauce
Green Top DSP

“Peels On Wheels does great vegan pizza! The toppings are extremely high quality. I don't remember exactly what it was called, but they had this kind of sundried sweet red bell pepper that was out of this world. I had that New York style with shallots, banana pepper rings, and vegan pepperoni. The owner works in the kitchen alongside his employees and really cares about producing superior pizza. Their pies are so much better than what you'll get ordering from a chain!“

4.8 Superb90 Reviews
The Pizza Shoppe Pizza • $
1601 Penfield Rd #19, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Mac and Cheese with Prosciutto
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Chicken Cutlet Salad
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Cheesy Garlic Sticks
Cheese & Pepperoni
Eggplant Meatballs
dd's Pizza Slice
Ricotta Gnocchi
Chicken Parm

“Been to the Pizza Shoppe several times in the past month and a half. Let’s start with service. Fast, friendly and fantastic. I got my pizza nice and hot each time and my chocolate chip cookies were to die for. Seriously, maybe the best I have ever had.I have had several different varieties of this Detroit Style Pizza and it is second to none. It is now my go to for Pizza without a doubt.I also love the small pizza shoppe atmosphere not like one these chain pizza shops that has no personality. It was quiet and pleasant to just take a seat and enjoy my pizza. Hoping to try their chicken parmigiana in the near future.I don’t give many 5 star reviews, however this was an easy one to write.Great Job to your team at The Pizza Shoppe.“

4.9 Superb66 Reviews
Wildflour Italian • $
620 Winton Rd N, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Pesto Seasonal Special
Rapini and Mushroom Sammy
Bolognese

“The food is outstanding. You can tell they use high quality ingredients and prepare the simple dishes with care. I've had the creative pizzas and salads a few times, and my husband gets the sandwiches. It never disappoints! It's a fast casual experience with a very small dining area, so consider takeout as your best option if you have a larger party. A great addition to the N. Winton Village and the Rochester food scene!“

4.8 Superb57 Reviews
Polizzi's Italian • $$
274 N Goodman St #108, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Espresso Pot De Crème
Saganaki Flaming Cheese
Braised Beef Short Rib
Italian Bread Basket
Vegetarian Meatballs
Butterscotch Budini
Polenta Fries
Steak Frites
Cast Iron Cod
Pot De Creme

“This was our first visit and it was fabulous. Everyone we interacted with was friendly and just nice to chat with. Our server, Kathryn, was awesome!! Love her. I had the moussaka and it was wonderful. Great flavor! Hubby had the wolf fish/scallop special. Again, delish. Cocktails were great and we got desserts to go. Highly recommend and we will definitely be back!“

4.7 Superb75 Reviews
Perlo's Restaurant Italian • $$
202 N Washington St, East Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Pan Seared Tenderloin Medallians
Chicken French with Linguine
White Bean and Sausage Soup
Penne Alla Vodka
Chicken Parmesana
Clams Fradiavolo
Seafood Cioppino
Fried Calamari
Fish and Chips
Chicken Riggies

“Excellent meal last night. We dine here 4-5 times yearly, we enjoy Italian/American and it's always superb. Our meal on Friday during Lent was another winner. The food was absolutely delicious and the portions were very big as always. Our server Samantha was spot on, not only with serving but her suggestion to me was great. My wife had Codfish Picatta and I had the Seafood Chippino. So good, my wife took home 1 whole piece of the two served of Cod and I had plenty of leftovers from a bowl loaded with delicious seafood. Many things make this place a must go; great food, nice atmosphere, big bar, white linen tablecloths and napkins etc. Prices are very reasonable as are drinks. Little thinks like our server taking our leftovers to wrap instead of bringing us containers to do it ourselves and the owner (Donna) being on hand to insure our satisfaction means a lot to us as frequent diners of many establishments and kind of sends Perlo's to the top echelon. I guarantee with their extensive menu, you will not be disappointed.“

4.5 Superb108 Reviews
Proietti's Italian Restaurant & Catering Italian • $$
980 Ridge Rd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

White Pizza with Mozzarella Romano and Garlic
Pizza with Pepperoni and Sausage
Gluten Free Chicken Parmesan
Chicken French
Veal Parmigiana
Fried Calamari
Antipasto

“Title: Taking Toddlers for Italian! While dining with toddlers is always a messy experience my daughter and I were in the mood for our FAVORITE Italian food. Proietti’s is family run and they always make you feel welcome. They hurried our service along to accommodate our little people who were a hit. Multiple patrons said how cute they were and stopped to visit with them. The food is OUTSTANDING! Huge portions and delicious flavors. We called it a night shortly after the 1 year old started sucking spaghetti straight off the table with his face. Needless to say he loved it too.Did I mention they use a paper liner over their white table cloths? Now you know why. As always I can’t wait to go back for more chicken French!!“

4.6 Superb62 Reviews
Loading...
map Map