Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

$$ • Pizza, Italian

91 W Main St, Macedon
(315) 538-0220


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

It took the food 2 hours to get 5 miles, the pizza was burnt, and they forgot part of the order. They were short staffed and continued to make excuses. No refund, just credit. I will not be ordering from them again. If I could give less than 1 star I would.

Generally I really like Salvatore's pizza and was very happy when the Macedon location reopened. But, I will never again waste my money on a Manhattan New York pizza. We ordered it with pepperoni, green peppers and onions. What a disappointment! The pizza took over an hour to be delivered, assume that Sunday football can be blamed for that. But, it was almost cold when it arrived and the crust was over cooked in places. I was shocked to find the green peppers were a full review

This review is for the Salvatores that just opened in the past month. I generally go to Marks in Palmyra. However due to my recent experience at Salvatores...I will likely never go back to Marks again. Salvatores has wings that are bigger and have far better taste. The pizza sauce is not as bland and the regular pepperonis have a bit more zing. And...they got my order perfectly correct 3 times in a row...which is rare at Marks. Please continue to do well!

More Reviews(27)


Monday 11AM - 10PM
Tuesday 11AM - 10PM
Wednesday 11AM - 10PM
Thursday 11AM - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 11PM
Saturday 11AM - 11PM
Sunday 11AM - 10PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.