9 Best Italian Restaurants near Batavia

Cinquino's Pizza Pizza • $
314 Ellicott St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatballs
Garlic Bread w Cheese
Chicken Parmigiana
Kids Spaghetti
Buffalo Wings
French Fries
Chicken Wing
Cheese Pizza
Large Pizza
Cheesy Tots

“We stopped at Cinquino's on our way through Batavia tonight and had an excellent dinner experience.They have a large corner table that fit our party of 11 plus a baby with room to spare.We ordered the full sheet pizza with mushroom. It was nice and thick, and very tasty. All 11 of us barely finished the 32 slices.We left a good tip and the total (with tip) was just over $40. Service was quick and helpful, good atmosphere, and the food was excellent. This made a phenomenal option for eating out with a larger group.“

4.7 Superb49 Reviews
Settler's Family Restaurant Family • $
353 W Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Hungry Man Breakfast Dine in: Yes Takeout: Yes
With Home Fries
French Toast
Hash Browns
Turkey Club
Greek Salad
Cheesecake
Fish Fry
Pancakes
Soup

“This was my first time here while traveling for work. Everything was excellent from the greeting to the farewell. Atmosphere was that of a popular local diner. Food was a good sized portion, tasted great, and average price. The service was outstanding! Keep up the good work!“

4.5 Superb83 Reviews
Main Street Pizza Company Pizza • $$
206 E Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Fried Mozzarella Wedges
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Veal Parm with Spaghetti
Create-Your-Own Calzone
Dry Rub Chicken Wings
Deep Dish Pizza
Boneless Wings
Antipasto Salad
Stuffed Shells
Grilled Pizza

“Could not wait to get the fish fry from last year! It was so fresh and beautiful. This year....drastically different. Two pieces of fish, if you can call it that, and big chunk slices of potatoes. I was told this was fish and chips. For normal quality of Main Street, This is a disappointment.“

4.4 Superb76 Reviews
Roman's Italian • $
59 Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza of the Month
Chicken Francese
Chicken Parmesan
Grilled Chicken
Stuffed Shells
French Onion
Utica Greens
Bruschetta
Meatball

“We're from NYC area, we eat a lot of Italian, and the food at this place really impressed. Pizzas in the wood oven were terrific (we got three), my linguine with clam sauce was full of clams and a great garlicy sauce. Prices were fair, service was lovely.“

4.3 Superb71 Reviews
T F Brown's Restaurant Italian • $
214 E Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Wings Before
Chicken Wing Dip
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Wings
Beef on Wick
Roast Beef
Nachos
Steak
Salad

“Went here for a birthday party yesterday, my sister rented a room for a couple hours for her son's 1st bday for free. Pizza was alright but the wings were fantastic. I like this place a lot. Nice bathrooms and the bar argreatly! I'm not from the area but I'd definitely come again when I'm in the area. The location on my GPS wasn't exactly correct as the place is kind of hidden. But we made it there. The specials yesterday looked great too.Kid-friendliness: The room rented was big enough for our kiddos to play and we had 7 all together. I do believe there's an arcade here too.“

4 Good51 Reviews
Fortune's Italian Steakhouse American • $$
8315 Park Rd, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Cedar Plank Salmon w Wild Rice Pilaf
Grilled Chicken Basil Alfredo
Prime Rib & Shrimp Cocktail
Seafood Stuffed Haddock
Eggplant Parmigiana
Alfredo Ravioli
Chicken Marsala
Sea Food Medley
Seafood Chowder
Fish and Chips

“Ordered grilled chicken basil Alfredo and filet mignon. Although plentiful and flavorful the chicken strips were too dry. The waiter had no idea how I wanted the steak prepared. I wanted my steak blackened Pittsburg style. The mgr came over to verity my request and mentioned that it would be rare which I understood. Steak was overcooked with little flavor. We also waited more than 20 minutes for our salads. In the meantime a buser came over and asked if we wanted a takeout container for the one roll still in our basket. Weired as they just put it on our table !! Normally, we always enjoyed eating here so this was unexpected. I'm sure having a part time server didn't help. She didn't even know how to open a wine bottle at the other table. When she came back to our table I explained how to open it which she was grateful to hear. Still, we will probably return.“

4 Good140 Reviews
Batavia's Original Pizzeria Pizza • $
500 E Main St, Batavia

Customers` Favorites

Italian Wedding Soup
Italian Meat Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Slice
Boneless Wings
Chicken Wings
Side Salad
Hot Wings

“First time visit with a party of eight on a Thursday evening. Four adults and four children. The waitress was attentive, patient and very efficient. She was fantastic with the children.The food was very good! No complaints. We were very pleased. We will definitely return!“

3.7 Good73 Reviews
Nino's Pizzeria Pizza • $
26 Market St, Attica - 10.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Small Pizza with Cheese
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Onions Meatball
Chicken Finger
Olives Salami
Fish Sandwich
Sub Specials
White Pizza
Stinger Sub
Buffalo Wing

“Pizza and wings looking so good, I couldn't wait to dig in, and had to take pic after ;-)Ordered large pizza special, double wings were med, extra crispy and awesome! Just how I like them. Pizza, nice and cheesy.I ordered ahead and it was ready when I got there.Thank you, Nino's!“

4.1 Good27 Reviews
Rusty Rail Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
49 S Pearl St, Oakfield - 6.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Popcorn

“Our family comes often for bowling and dinner. Staff is very welcoming and friendly. When bowling we never have wait long if there’s any questions, to get shoes or lane assignments or pay our bills. Food is great, portions are good. Specials, menu options, drinks and prices are all listed in the menus. It’s nice to see the updates that have been made to the business since the new owners started.“

3.7 Good11 Reviews
Loading...
map Map