“Could not wait to get the fish fry from last year! It was so fresh and beautiful. This year....drastically different. Two pieces of fish, if you can call it that, and big chunk slices of potatoes. I was told this was fish and chips. For normal quality of Main Street, This is a disappointment.“
“We're from NYC area, we eat a lot of Italian, and the food at this place really impressed. Pizzas in the wood oven were terrific (we got three), my linguine with clam sauce was full of clams and a great garlicy sauce. Prices were fair, service was lovely.“
“The owner is very friendly, politely, kind, caring....and funny. They keep to themselves and hard working. Their food is delicious ? they do charcoal hotdogs every Sunday, nothing bets a charcoal hotdogs. We make it a family hotdogs day on Sundays.Kid-friendliness: Love kidsWheelchair accessibility: There is no steps and very easy to get into“
“I really like pizza 151. Their pizza is good, you have to try the sweet sauce. I don't eat meat, but several people have told me their wings are very good. I also really enjoy their friend dough and raspberry chimmies. Give Pizza 151 a try, they might surprise you.Vegetarian options: You can customize any pizza and toppings“
“OMG, are you guys from NYC? I came here three years ago and couldn't find a pizzaria I liked. Matty's Pizza is literally the very best pizza here in Batavia, it tastes like NYC pizza. I tried every pizzeria in Batavia and you guys are the very best here. I mean, I've waited 3 whole years to find a pizzaria that actually tastes good, no lie! Your pizza has good mozzarella cheese and I'm allergic to immitation cheese. Also, the sauce has seasoning on it and that's important. The bottom of the pizza is not burnt nor does it have that nasty residue in the bottom. I didn't struggle eating the pizza either. I just had to take time out writing this well deserved excellent review of you. A diamond in the rough! Will definitely buy again & recommend to anybody I know. Great job!“
“We were never here before. We ordered a sheet pizza to share with family. We thought the sauce had a good balance of acidity in the crust was really good. Usually we don't like really bready crust because it doesn't have a lot of flavor, there's was pretty good.“
“First time visit with a party of eight on a Thursday evening. Four adults and four children. The waitress was attentive, patient and very efficient. She was fantastic with the children.The food was very good! No complaints. We were very pleased. We will definitely return!“
“We stopped at Cinquino's on our way through Batavia tonight and had an excellent dinner experience.They have a large corner table that fit our party of 11 plus a baby with room to spare.We ordered the full sheet pizza with mushroom. It was nice and thick, and very tasty. All 11 of us barely finished the 32 slices.We left a good tip and the total (with tip) was just over $40. Service was quick and helpful, good atmosphere, and the food was excellent. This made a phenomenal option for eating out with a larger group.“