10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Batavia

“Our first time here on 5/13/24 Restaurant was clean atmosphere was very pleasant the staff was very friendly and very attentive Our food came hot and fresh the portions are huge We drove in from Buffalo and our friends from Rochester What a wonderful experience Looking forward to our next visit“

“Pizza and wings are my comfort food, and Cinquino’s does not disappoint! All of the food we have tried is very good, and the staff is friendly and helpful. A special shout out to Angela, as she always greets me with a smile on her face, and appreciation for my patronage! For my Birthday, I came home to a hidden message, which made my day!!“

“Matt was very helpful on the phone and helped us choose the best option for our food. The pizza was delicious and extremely filling. The 1 large pie 1 topping deal with a soda was worth it and the service was prompt. Overall, very nice place to eat by yourself or with family.“

“We love Ficarella's. I can't recall any time we've had an issue because we keep going back. We got dinner from them 2 times this week and both times our order was 100% correct. Their online ordering is super simple and allows you to make almost any modification you want. They also have a drive up window if you can't/don't want to go inside.“

“One of my favorite spots to eat with friends in Batavia! Great wings! Pizza is excellent! Love their slices! Try the chicken wing dip 😋

Kid-friendliness: Yes kid-friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp near parking lot.“

“Best Pizza around hands down. We've had every slice from every joint around Genesee County. If you haven't tried Mattys, do yourself a favor and order one from them. You won't be disappointed.“

“Wings were spot on! They were fresh and cooked the way I like them. We ate in, and the tables were clean. They had a big open space in the back, which would make more sense to use for dine in customers because it was out of tye direct sunlight. I had to wear my sunglasses through dinner.“

“It's a plain atmosphere with good conversation amongst locals and the interior looks the exact same as it always has. The sauce was delicious, the cheese was stretchy and melty. The crust had a nice crunch yet soft at the same time. The customer service was professional and helpful. My partner asked for extra cheese. If you want to eat the pizza from a Goofy movie, order with extra cheese, it looks the exact same! It's not really a necessity tho. I definitely recommend!“

“I liked everything about this place. The food was awesome and the atmosphere was super cool. On our way from Niagara we found this cool place and had a pit stop for lunch. Kids enjoyed the lunch. We had sphegatti, Alfredo, Lobster soup and Pizza which was customized to our liking as we don't like Beef. Thanks a ton to the person who serviced us. He really was too cool from the time he met us until our billing. He even gave us a chocolate tower cake billed on house. The cake was full of chocolate and delicious. If I have anyone visiting to NY on this way I would surely recommend this place for anyone who wish to have a nice Italian Food“