14 Best Pizza Restaurants near Geneseo

“Great fresh food, awesome service. Highly recommend!“

“One of the best pizza places I ever visited (and I’ve been to pizza joints all over NY, New England, the west coast and even the UK). GINORMOUS slices (with generous amount of toppings) for very little money. And absolutely delicious too! Friendly staff and nice atmosphere as well. I have become a semi-regular in the past couple of months.“

“Wegmans has amazing customer service. And ever since I have worked there I have loved it“

“Came here for my daughter’s 8th birthday today and we had the best time! Everyone working was so kind and helpful. A great experience, we will definitely be back!“

“Good Food & Pleasant Atmosphere“

“Finally went today after hearing amazing things about the gluten free menu. It did NOT disappoint! The only thing better than the food was the incredible staff who ensured everything was safe for my celiac girls and made them feel so comfortable and confident ordering! The portions were huge and so delicious- it was hard to believe they were gluten free! If you have the chance, get the cinnamon buns- they are beyond decadent. Yum!“

“I just have to say that the pizza I had tonight was the Best pizza from anywhere I’ve had in quite some time. Thank you very much !! Perfectly cooked !!“

“we drove all the way from conesus bc I lost track of time and everything around closed at 8pm. man o man was this worth the drive! the wings were cooked to perfection and the pizza was amazingly delicious even after the 25 min ride home! you gained a new customers tonight! so worth the drive and the price even left me with gas money lol“

“New to the area and this pizzeria was suggested to us. We ordered a sheet pizza on July 4th ( which other restaurants sometimes won't do) with a pick up at 3 pm. Walked in at 3:00, pizza was done and piping hot. Everyone at the party devoured the pizza and not one piece left lol. Will definitely order again from this pizzeria!“

“Been patronizing this location for about 15 years. The Pizza is Always consistent as it’s the only thing we order. Haven’t tried any of the other menu options but they do look good. Dough is house made which makes it a real pie . The owner is Justin and he’s really nice. If you order the pizza no matter the toppings, you won’t be disappointed. Great flavor and filling. Pricing is avg. nothing out of the ordinary and worth it“

“Had an issue with the Honeoye fall Location tonight put in information they have my pizza delivered to the house, but their computer auto generated it to an old address went back-and-forth with the HFL store telling me I could have a pizza that was 40 minutes old and it was too late for them to make a new one they said my pizza was out for delivery to the wrong address that they had on file but my email says different and then I called the store 40 minutes after my pizza was out for delivery and they told me it was still sitting there. I could come pick it up. I asked them to remake it because I put my information incorrectly. They told me it was not Their problem and it falls on me and that there was nothing they were gonna do other than refund my money which they did.
I immediately called the Avon location and they went above and beyond staying open late past their time of operating hours to make me a fresh pizza as long as I could go there and pick it up. This store has earned a lot of respect from me as a customer they have on location did not have to do what they did but they went the extra mile and they made sure that I was taken care of as a customer. The food was excellent. It was fresh. It was hot, friendly conversation and stayed open past business hours just make sure customer is taken care of. I can’t say enough good things Thank you. To this location and the team members that you have there by far compared to what I’ve been dealing with an HFL, my business will only come to this store going forward“

“Walked here from vitale park. When you walk in, you can see the slices available. There was pepperoni and cheese slices in there. We ordered one cheese slice, one pep slice, mottz sticks, cheese garlic bread, fried dough bites, chicken tenders and fries. The wall paper is literally peeling off the walls at the seams, and curling around. The younger girl that took my order was good at her job. Well when the slices came out, they put cupped pepperoni on plain cheese pizza that wasn’t anywhere near fresh, no one came in after I ordered, so idk if they have a pizza in the back and keep the one up front for looks or what but the pizza was sub par. The mottz sticks taste like they just came out of a freezer, and the fried dough bites were lacking powdered sugar. I’ve had a decent share of good expierences with pizza Paul’s, but this tine wasn’t good.“

“We drove just under 2 hours to Stony Brook State Park, enjoyed the day and then decided to get some food at a local spot on the way home and picked High Banks Tavern. The food was really delicious. I would love to eat here again. Very intimate little place with one server taking care of about 10 tables plus the bar and they had non stop take out orders. Our server (younger gentleman) was calm, friendly, and hustlin! Our entire party of 4 couldn't say enough about the cheese curds, they were some of the best we've ever had, two of us agreed. My chicken sandwich was quite good as well, the rosemary fries get the MVP award tho. I am not much of a potato eater but I love rosemary, so I rolled the dice and I think they might be my new standard for a French fry. I loved them. Crispy, warm, and tasty. HBT is a great little place I'd love to be a local! We also really loved the new establishment next door, If you are local or in the area go check out Lewiston Waffles. We couldn't resist when we saw one walk by the window while waiting for our meal so we made sure to save room. Great experience!“

“had the Philly cheese sub for lunch today and it was delicious. my order got here quick also.“