50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pittsford

“Everyone has a favorite place to get delicious pizza. I encourage anyone who might be interested in trying a “prize-worthy pizza” to visit Pontillo’s in Bushnell’s Basin.
I gave 5 stars for “Atmosphere”(it is a pick-up only pizza shop)…because the busy crew behind the counter making your delicious order is friendly, entertaining and interesting to watch!
Don’t forget to order boneless wings as well.“

“This is a hidden secret! Home made food and plenty of it. Exceptionally friendly and attentive service. We have tried something different each time we have dined in and everything continues to exceed our expectations. The variety of menu items is amazing and the value you get for the dollar is unbelievable. This is our go to place for a great dining experience.“

“Visited Branca in Pittsford and made reservations for the bar area to take advantage of Happy Hour, which is only available in designated sections. From the moment we were seated, the service was very good. Our server/bartender was especially accommodating and even customized my cocktails to suit my taste.

The food was equally enjoyable. The calamari was good, although I was disappointed that my favourite part — the tentacles — was missing! 😂 The eggplant, pizza, and meatballs were all very good and made for a great Happy Hour spread.

For cocktails, I definitely enjoyed the Mama Picante much more than the Milan Mule. The Mama Picante had more of the flavour and personality I was looking for.

Overall, a very good Happy Hour experience with accommodating service, tasty food, and some excellent cocktails. I'd definitely go back. Saluti.“

“Google must be giving out "local guide" status to anyone because Anthony Viscusi is horribly misinformed and possibly blind. The dough at pontillos is NOT frozen. The staff at pontillos makes the dough fresh every morning. There is an entire room in the corner of the dining area with glass walls where employees make the dough. In fact if you come in early enough, usually just after opening, you can watch them make the dough through the glass for yourself. Please remove Anthony Viscusi from being a local guide as he is obviously a terrible critic.“

“We drive 45 minutes for dinner every couple of weeks or as often as we can and it’s always worth it. There’s nothing bad on the menu. The wings are our favorite, the chicken salad is my 7 year old daughter’s go to. the subs, the cheeseburger plates, the pizza, all the condiments and sauces-just try it all. Do not forget the chocolate chip cookies either!“

“The best pizza I've ever tasted in Rochester and nearby areas. It's worth every penny. You can feel the good quality of the products.Definitely my new favorite pizza spot. Continue with the tremendous service and your good quality products.“

“Great addition to ER, pizza sauce has great flavor and isn't too sweet, boneless wings are huge and tasty, the blue cheese is out of this world amazing 10/10!!“

“super yummy squares - can't wait to come back. best peter around!“

“We tried it for DoorDash dinner tonight, and it was very tasty! Great amount of toppings, and the quality of each ingredient was evident. We look forward to visiting the restaurant in the future. We aren’t able to dine out very often in the evening due to our schedule, so having it delivered was very helpful.“

“Delicious food with reasonable prices, friendly and knowledgeable staff, beautiful interior design!“

“Picked up a delicious pizza tonight, and bought a container of Italian cookies….the BEST I’ve ever had.“

“Absolutely delicious pizza and the nicest person behind the register! My wife and daughter LOVE the pizza, my only hope is they some day carry vegan pizza, so I can love it as much as they does (wink wink)! I pick the pizza up monthly, and it NEVER disappoints the family.“

“I just found the best turkey sub on the face of the Earth“

“Food was good. Had wings and beef on weck. Service was not good. Sat at a booth in the bar area. This was a Saturday at 4pm. Not busy at all. Took 15 minutes for a waitress to even acknowledge us even though there was at least 3-4 that we saw wandering around. Definitely not as good as the original, but hoping they’ll work out some of the kinks.“

“Wow! Had an awesome plate of Chicken Riggies! And the staff are all amazing! Well done Team Capone! 🖤“

“This place is one of my favorite pizza places I just love their pizza it's bomb .com ! The owners are super cool and friendly! keep striving I wanna see you guys doing big things because you deserve it create a pizza ! 5 star pizza in my book!“

“We stopped in last night everyone was so welcoming and nice and the food was great!!! It was hot and fresh and soooo good!! 10 out of 10 for us 😋“

“First time ordering here since we moved to the East side and I have to say it’s the best pizza I’ve had yet! Great for people who like a thinner crust with a healthy amount of sauce. The brick oven crust is SO good. We loved the buffalo chicken pizza, their house wing sauce they use is unique, and it was a nice shake up to traditional buffalo sauce. Also their house red on our pepperoni pizza was fantastic! 😍“

“I love Cam’s! Even though the A/C was down and it was hot inside, Michael was still super friendly and took great care of me. He had such a positive attitude despite working in the heat. Thank you for satisfying this pregnant girl’s pizza craving—it was exactly what I needed. I’ll definitely be back! :)“

“The pizza was delicious, fresh, and ready fast! I was impressed with the young staff. They were enthusiastic, attentive, and hard working. My only regret is that I live 4 hours away in Canada!“

“truly a great pizza spot. super convenient area with lots of parking. the staff is really friendly and welcoming. the pizza is phenomenal! it’s thin crust with lots of toppings and cup and char! this is a great place to stop with the family!“

“nothing there nasty the place is nasty the food is spoiled rat infestation health department has violations food poisoning cases owner is a supposedly a Christan but a compulsive gambler“

“The food was the closest thing to my dear old Italian grandmother's. I commented to our server how the food tasted so authentic and learned the owner/chef is from the same small town in Italy as my grandmother. You could taste it in the food! The service was as good as the food. We left there feeling like we were just at a family dinner. It was our first time here and it's a 1.5 hour drive, but we will be back often. Highly recommend!“

“Two Words…. Absolutely Delish…❣️❣️“

“Food is excellent, service awesome Great place to go! Highly recommend it if you're in the Victor NY area“

“Visited Strangebird today. And the atmosphere is great! Full service bar. Or tables available for larger groups. The food amazing. Our bartender Dee was epic!! Had the smoked pork sandwich with coleslaw on it. A phenomenal pairing Tried the bbq spaghetti which nearly blew me outta my seat!!! The bbq sauce was epic! @strangebird you need to shrink the size of the bbq spaghetti to a fries size and server them with the handhelds in place of French fries with that bbq sauce. Cuz heck yes! That bbq sauce on the side as a dipper 🤩🤩🤩. Great job to the staff. Bigger vehicles might wanna park on the street. If it’s busy, the parking lot is very narrow.“

“This is the best pizza in Western New York. I've been going there for 46 years and never been disappointed! Tony & Mike are amazing and I always look forward to the time w/ them. Prices are beyond reasonable.“

“The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, and the restaurant is very clean. One thing you absolutely have to try is the Crazy Slice of the Week! they always come up with creative combinations that are surprisingly delicious. I was amazed by how good it was. My personal favorite pizza is the Three Meat pizza! Definitely a spot worth visiting if you’re craving quality pizza and great service!“

“We did an honor flight event that sends veterans to to washing DC to see monuments made in their honor. Mozzeroni’s was so generous. They donated pizzas for our event and fed our riders. We are so grateful for their generosity. What great neighbors. The pizza is always fantastic. Thanks again They will always have our business“

“Recently went for a girls dinner and was happy to find many gluten free options clearly labeled on the menu. Staff was very knowledgeable and accommodating. Food and cocktails were delicious. Celiac approved. Will be back.“

“food was delicious. stopped by for brunch. good bloody mary. the granola to yogurt ratio in the parfait coulda been better. needed more granola. they served me fruit with my burger which included moldy blueberries and a banana that had a piece of lettuce on it. there was no lettuce in my meal. 🤢“

“BEST PIZZA ANYWHERE ***** !!! Dave's the best“

“Good food good prices. Pizza was delicious. Buffalo parm wings were amazing. Lady on the phone wasn't very pleasant and hung up as I was saying thanks which was a bit odd but I will be back. Staff when I came in were very friendly. Food is well priced for what you get. Pizza is thin crust if you like it that way. 🙌“

“Incredible food will definitely be back“

“Incredible experience working with Carbone's on our most recent event. We scheduled an order for a 4pm pick-up, and by the time the event start at 4:30pm, the pizza was still as fresh as when we picked it up. Delicious pizza & event greater people.“

“Excellent subs“

“We found a new place to eat. The food is delicious and the staff was very pleasant and knowledgeable about the art in the restaurant. Definitely will be coming back for more strombolis and try other food.“

“whether it's a huge lunch slice or an entire pizza, they are my favorite by far. Family owned and operated, clean, consistent and always fresh!“

“Highly recommend especially chicken tenders, calzones, and of course the beer. Slices always available. Everything made to order. Outdoor seating.“

“Place is amazing, exceptional food and wonderful atmosphere. Would highly recommend.“

“Their pizza is amazing!! Perfect crust and not greasy at all!!!“

“The “Hot Jason” was INCREDIBLE! I have been looking for a chicken and steak sub, and no where does it quite like Rhinos! The sub bread is SO fresh, crispy chicken, and excellent shaved steak. The staff is extremely nice, too! I will be back and couldn’t recommend this place more.“

“Late night arrival into Rochester on a Tuesday evening and I chanced upon Branca Midtown via Resy. We took a chance and I am so so glad we did. This place was divine. The host and the servers were impeccable. Sassy, funny, and attentive to a T, we were incredibly impressed and immediately relaxed with the atmosphere and the people. The ricotta appetizer was incredibly and reminded me of a favorite dish in Florence Italy, and the swordfish was perfection. Drinks were delicious, so thank you to the obviously talented bartender, as those were very much needed after our long drive. We will definitely make a point of stopping back then next time we are in town.“

“Proietti’s has been one of my favorite restaurants since I moved to Webster in 2013! Great food, and amazing staff:)“

“I love Pudgie’s pizza and especially their chicken wings….cooked so nice and crunchy….the customer service was great and it’s nice to dine inside again❤️“

“Best wood fired pizza in Rochester. All fresh ingredients artfully prepared by Freddie himself. It is a must try, you will be hooked. I know I am!! Definitely five ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Service was phenomenal! Everything is homemade including drinks and is so delicious!“

“Ordered the vampire slayer pizza, wings with mild sauce on the side and a garlic knot. Everything was delicious! Perfect pizza crust, delicious pizza and crispy Wings! Garlic knots was a great addition. This is going to be our new pizza place! Cant wait to try other items on the menu!“

“Great thin crust pizza, highly recommend! Can’t wait to try other menu items!“