Restaurants in Pittsford

“Would give 6 stars if I could, food is delicious, environment is great. The chicken pita is my favorite item.”

“LOVED THE FOOD!! So good and the atmosphere is amazing! Such great service”

“We hosted our rehearsal dinner at Carmella's, and we couldn't have imagined a better way to kick off our wedding weekend.

The planning process was incredibly smooth, and I always felt like the team understood exactly what I envisioned. Every detail came together effortlessly, which allowed us to simply enjoy the evening with our family and friends.

Our guests are still talking about the food and cocktails! Everything was absolutely delicious, and the hospitality made the night even more special.

Thank you for giving us such a memorable start to our wedding weekend. We can't wait to come back!”

“If you’re looking for me, there’s a solid chance I’m at Collier’s—multiple times a week at this point (it’s fine, I’ve accepted it 😂). Truly one-of-a-kind, the best staff, the coziest atmosphere… it just hits every time. I always leave happier than I walked in, which says a lot before coffee. Thank you for making my mornings feel a little extra special 🤍”

“Great place to grab a brew. Casual atmosphere. We love hanging out on the patio in the Adirondack chairs and by the fire pits.”

“I parked across from the restaurant. I couldn't find it right away. I usually don't ever park at this end of Schoen nor be in this area. I couldn't see the sign right away. But, eventually I saw it.
This place has three steps going down to the restaurant. It isn't ADA compliant.
There is Handicapped parking in the lot.
When I left, most of the spaces were taken, I had run in for take out. This place, only accepts cash and take out is by phone.”

“Great view of Cayuga Lake, laid back atmosphere. Awesome beer selection, fun flights too. Went for pizza and wings tonite, both excellent! Pizza was fresh tasting, excellent sauce, wings were actually crunchy and so so good! Love this place!”

“Great experience for girls night out! We started outside but then when it began to rain we moved inside and the service at both spots was great! Food was delicious, drinks were tasty and loved the atmosphere both outside and inside. Will definitely be back soon!”

“They were great. I needed an order for a bridal shower at a time when they go on summer vacation. They took my order and told how to preserve them for the event. Thank you for taking our order.”

“We make several trips to Tom Wahl’s during the year. Best burgers and fish fry. We have a family tradition of many years to go there on Christmas Eve. Merry Christmas to all at Tom Wahls!”

“The atmosphere was busy, but comfortable. Seems like a hoppin' local place to meet friends for a game or dine with family. I enjoyed a well made classic Reuben on GF bread with homemade chips. Tasty good!”

“We stopped in for lunch today at Fruit &Salad Co. and had a lovely lunch. The food was delicious as was the service! The manager was friendly and available to the customers. They have a wide variety of soups, salads, sandwiches and desserts. The dinner menu look wonderful too. We specifically picked this restaurant for their vegetarian options. If you are looking for a quiet but quaint place to get a bite to eat in the Fairport area don’t hesitate to stop in here. Five stars all the way!”

“Late-Night Gem: Hungry in Pittsford, NY

After 9:30 PM, finding a spot for a quick and delicious bite can feel like a challenge, but Hungry in Pittsford delivered beyond expectations. I ordered their Hungry Wrap, Italian Sausage, and Platter Combo, and they whipped everything up in no time!

The Platter Combo was a crispy, indulgent medley of fried treats, cooked to perfection and paired with tangy sauces. The Hungry Wrap was a cheesy, flavorful delight—each bite was a symphony of fresh ingredients and bold seasonings. The Italian Sausage was packed with hearty flavors, perfectly balanced by caramelized onions and peppers in a soft, crusty roll.

Every dish was freshly prepared and absolutely delicious. Hungry not only nailed the taste but also the speed—an ideal spot for late-night cravings. If you’re ever in Pittsford and need a quick yet satisfying meal, don’t miss this place.”

“Everyone has a favorite place to get delicious pizza. I encourage anyone who might be interested in trying a “prize-worthy pizza” to visit Pontillo’s in Bushnell’s Basin.
I gave 5 stars for “Atmosphere”(it is a pick-up only pizza shop)…because the busy crew behind the counter making your delicious order is friendly, entertaining and interesting to watch!
Don’t forget to order boneless wings as well.”

“Recently went for a girls dinner and was happy to find many gluten free options clearly labeled on the menu. Staff was very knowledgeable and accommodating. Food and cocktails were delicious. Celiac approved. Will be back.”

“Delicious egg nog ice cream! Also love the raspberry/chocolate tarts and s’mores tart! Great customer service and cozy atmosphere!”

“I recommend everything!!”

“Great service and staff! Love the gates location”

“why not?? could be Good If The Version. we. are. on. is.....”

“The guy behind the counter really made my day: Thanks Jordan #Starbucks”

“showed up for dinner and they aren't open anymore”

“A nice lil dive bar in the heart of pittsford. I had Genny cream ale on tap. They brought it in a plastic cup. Staff treated us well. Might have trouble finding it since they have no street sign.”

“this is the best salvatore’s!
menu so big and diverse everyone can have something.
great customer service as soon as i walk in
10/10 :)”

“During my recent stay at the Hilton Hotel, I had the pleasure of experiencing the bartending services at their stunning garden bar. The ambiance of the tranquil setting was enhanced by the remarkable skills of their bartender, Jeff.Moreover, their ability to engage with guests, and making you feel welcomed. He walked me through his years of experience with the hotel and it was quite comforting.”

“Had an excellent dinner at Eerie Grill. The food was outstanding from start to finish, and the service was genuinely great—attentive, friendly, and on point. The carrot cake was the best I've ever had, truly unforgettable. Highly recommend this spot and will definitely be back.”

“Margherita Pizza was good. Coffee was great. Ricotta appetizer was great. Service (Connor) was excellent. We were certainly tended to! Atmosphere is roomy but cozy and not loud at all.

Update, we ate here tonight (a few years after that previous trip) and it was even better. Laura was our waitress and she's a treat! Delmonico steak special was fantastic, with cheesy bacon mashed potatoes. Steak was fatty but it was great fat. Pics to come!”

“We love coming here to sit praise and enjoy the views of the canal. We have ordered many dishes, our favorites are the chicken pitta and tabulee. Everything is fresh and delicious.”

“I more than pleasantly enjoyed my experience at this local restaurant. The environment was friendly helpful and best of all delicious. Personally i ordered the general tsos chicken and it was one of my favorite dishes i’ve had in this area. I loved it so much me and my family came back next week and again very very very delicious. This place has some good quality and i would eat there if im stopping by pittsford or even if you’re a local.”

“My favorite place to go. Fantastic place to meet new people and stumble upon connections you’d never expect.”