50 Best Bakeries near Pittsford

“Best milk and eggnog there is!“

“The French toast is good here (very nice appearance for the stuffed kind), and so is the overnight oats. It is expensive food, but it is still worth coming over for it. The ingredients seem like good quality. Being able to choose between indoor or outdoor seating is great, too.“

“Have you ever thought "Man, I dislike cupcakes?" Of course not. Go in here and treat yourself. I stopped in for a birthday party prep, and found they had cupcakes with banana in them - now, no one in my family really LIKES banana but me, so I figured "I'll get a couple of those to try". They didn't make it home. The birthday dozen almost didn't either. Not a place for those with weak impulse control... or is it? Seriously great cupcakes.“

“Our family stayed in an airbnb on Averill Ave, just down the street from Cheesy Eddie's, and I picked up a 2lb Key Lime cheesecake to share at our big family New Years get together. MAN did that cheesecake go fast. I only got a tiny slice myself, but it was delicious. I should have gotten several of them.“

“the best doughnuts danish soup hot dog pretzels soooo glad your back my wife got me doughnuts“

“Thank you Amazing Grains for a delicious lunch! I stopped in for a loaf of Salty Bread...left with that and some Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese. Perfect addition to my Chicken Corn Chowder at home! Winter blues just melted away! ❤️“

“Absolutely the best Italian & French bread around. Nice crust & soft delicious inside! Yum 😋“

“Stopped in after work today for lunch. Had the Turkey Ruben and a couple cookies. Absolutely delicious. Can’t wait to try more sandwiches.“

“Best Greek food I've ever eaten“

“We love the fresh variety of mochi donuts and drinks! The mango donut is my favorite. Fun and delicious donuts that have us craving for more!“

“Stopped in today and we picked up a couple of cupcakes! Delicious!!“

“It’s a bakery like no other. I like me self some flavorful bread, not just some boring, plain mouth-frying dough, and this place hits just the spot for me. Flavorful, creative, and yummy bakery stuff, this is the most exciting bakery in town.

Love the beef sausage and the curry beef bread. Croffles are something to remember for years.“

“From time to time work brings me into Rochester. During a trip my co-worker brought me to Georgie’s for an amazing Cubano w/chicharrones. I enjoyed the food and chats with Georgie. Stand-up guy with an amazing café. So glad to see him and his family putting amazing food out after all of these years. You will not be disappointed!“

“Their sponsorship to bring treats a well deserving teachers is much appreciated!“

“Such a cute little bakery, but probably the best dessert I’ve ever had so far! I loved their raspberry cupcakes (which the samples definitely got me) but also their Large Jane’s Delight! We got the mini and tried it while waiting for our cheesecake samplers and ended up getting the Large to take home! I’m not a huge cheesecake person, but the family said it was the best cheesecake they’ve ever had!!“

“Vinny is awesome. What a true pleasure to speak to a man like him. I am SO glad that my wife, daughter and grandkids got to experience what was so much more available to guys like myself years ago. This place is a gem and the food was great. A true unexpected pleasure in this day. Check it out for yourself because good things like this don't last forever. Italian bread is fantastic btw.“

“Absolutely delicious!!! Highly recommend! We will be back 10/10!!!“

“I am way overdue to write this review because I am an enormous fan of Maggie’s delicious cookies—and Maggie herself! She continues to come up with new flavors that never disappoint-this fall the pumpkin, pumpkin coffe cake, and molasses cookies have been amazing! I’m a loyal customer for sure!“

“Oh Sunny Six Grain how I love thee.... My favorite bread of theirs, and the breakfast sandwich is so good even my grumpy 15 year old will get up early for one!“

“The thanksgiving pie was AMAZING.“

“Best cheesecake I’ve ever had in my life it is so so soooooooo good it is almost orgasmic, just thinking about it I am drooling 🤤 a mist try if you are a cheesecake fan ! Also tried the banana bread it is really yummy and those ginger turmeric bar are also really yummy. The bread is different a little like a pumpernickel I really liked it ! Love this place it’s one of the hidden gems of ROC glad we tried it ❤️“

“carbo heaven. wonderful sweet and savory items. i'm thrilled that we're past winter farmer's market. Crust's items are divine!“

“Always very good. Cookies are warm and large when picked up. ( only had one cookie that was cold. Totally worth the money. Cute boxes too!“

“Just received a gift box of Pastel cookies and the couple we have tried so far are delicious. The triple chocolate M&M is a really good chocolate cookie. There was an Egg Nog Snickerdoodle that was SO GOOD if you are a fan of the flavor. Looking forward to working our way through them all over the holidays.“

“Best chocolate babka ever. They do a wonderful job catering too. We used them for my son’s post-wedding breakfast and we heard nothing but great things about the food!“

“I seriously can’t recommend Savoia’s enough! Everything was so delicious and carefully package for my wedding. Everyone is so kind & beyond helpful when planning for your event. Everyone raved how delicious the desserts were. I now found my new favorite spot to get my sweets from!“

“Lily is a wonderful woman, my husband has been helping her with some things around her bakery so he wanted to introduce her to our family which is why we were there. To thank him for his help she is always sending us some of her delicious baked goods. I highly recommend stopping in and checking out what she has.“

“So many vegan and gluten free options. Amazing staff and the molasses cookie was amazing.“

“This woman is Amazing in the cake she made me for my New Year’s Eve reception. She . I sent her a picture and she made me a cake 🎂 of my dream. I literally screamed in excitement when I picked it up. She went way beyond the call of duty. Making me a custom base that lights. She worked in my budget and everyone at my reception loved it so much because how unique it was and wanted her into to order!!!“

“I ordered cookies for my daughter in laws baby shower. The cookies were beautiful and delicious. I sent an inspiration picture and our color scheme and designs were perfectly captured. I would definitely order again!“

“Shelly stepped up to help us when our Graduation dessert was cancelled 2 days ahead of the party by another baker. 48 cup cakes and 2 different kinds of cookies were somehow by magic, presented to us and tied with Shelly's signature tri colored ribbons. Thank you sincerely. 5 stars in my book!“

“My favorite part of kiss me cookie is not only the fact they are right next store to our business but they constantly working on improving their recipes. Right now my favorite cookie by far is the sugar cookie with sprinkles! I’ve had to restrain myself some days cause I just want more!“

“The Yummy Cookie Jar makes fantastic cookies!! And very creative flavors!! I highly recommend!“

“Absolutely delicious pastries! Whenever I visit my family in Ireland, I bring a couple of Jackson's almond paste kuchens. They just love them!“

“Jen and Christine, the owners of Bright Side Sweets, baked a gluten-free wedding cake for our daughter’s wedding. It was absolutely moist and delicious, and also beautifully presented. The customer service they provided was exemplary. I also purchased coffee cake and assorted muffins for other wedding activities. All were appreciated by the bride and groom and our wedding guests. Truth be told, if we hadn’t let folk know that the baked goods were gluten free, no one would have known the difference. Thank you Jen and Christine for making our wedding so special.“

“I thought finding good bakery in Rochester was a myth until I tried this one, like the quest for the grail. Wow. I could tell they knew their stuff when it was put in paper and not plastic. The crunch from the first bite. Amazing. Try it once and you will understand why others that are institutions in Rochester aren’t even mediocre. Tried the seasonal focaccia and kuchen.“

“Brads Cookie Nook has the best cookies. My sister was thrilled to get a special delivery for Christmas in Ohio!“

“An iconic Little Italy Neighborhood business with delicious bread and sweets!“

“My husband and I just received amazing service @ Auntie Anne’s. The gentleman, Jake, behind the counter baked us fresh pretzels upon request (and was KIND about it!). Both Jake & Kayla were very helpful to us and others, and I feel that Jake is an amazing employee & deserves a big fat raise! ? Hubby points out that Kayla & Jake work great together, excellent teammates. Thank you for the wonderful experience, it cheered us up after our not so awesome visit to Dick’s Sporting Goods… ?“

“We ordered a set of 6 through Postmates and unfortunately didn’t get our cookie cutter that we ordered. Postmates has put us through if with supplying documentation l, sending a million pictures, etc… only to say our order isn’t eligible for a refund. On a whim I called in to ask about this and the GM was amazing. She just offered us a cookie cutter. Didn’t make it a hassle, was amazingly friendly, and made me feel a lot less crazy about the situation. 10/10 for crumble cookie 0/10 for Postmates ?“

“Best Bagels in Rochester! Friendly service. 2021 open Christmas Day. Cash or Check only establishment.“

“gluten free apple crumble pie was a hit for Thanksgiving! ordering was super easy, as was pick up!“

“Perfect location for me to grab a bagel sandwich and coffee omw to work!

I love supporting local and their prices are very reasonable.

The drive-thru moves quick.

I do wish they used better quality bacon though. It seems like the very thin, precooked stuff.“

“We purchased several pies for Thanksgiving. The prices were great, the service exceptional but one of the pies won’t be making it too Thanksgiving... because I couldn’t resist the pecan pie. It’s amazing! I will be ordering pies from here every Thanksgiving for now on ❤️“

“Great strombolis; customer service slow to reply when a problem arises (20 weeks in my complaint's case) but they WILL respond to a valid complaint. Patience is definitely a virtue here - I'm thinking they're swamped and/or understaffed (it would explain both their response time AND the mistake that had prompted my complaint).“

“I had the pleasure of coming into Auntie Anne’s and had excellent service by Jen and the rest of the workers. Despite the being super busy true recognized me and that I order pretzels with a food allergy (without butter). They even made the pretzel for me before I even ordered when I was in line waiting! If I could give a higher review I would! The staff in Victor is always very polite, hard working and genuinely amazing! Thank you!

Dietary restrictions: Offer dairy free pretzels! Just ask to order a pretzel, pretzel nuggets, etc just without butter!“