Carmella's Wine Bar
$$ • Wine Bars, Tapas, New AmericanAbout Carmella's Wine Bar
Customers' Favorites
Malbec Abrasado Mendoza 2023
Shaved Brussels Sprout Salad
Carmella’S Curated Board
Prime Beef Meatballs
Imported Burrata
Sicilian Olives
Carmella's Wine Bar Reviews
94 ratings
Share your opinion about Carmella's Wine Bar
Love this place so much! The atmosphere and staff are out of this world! And, the owner Joe, truly makes you feel that you’re at home! If you haven’t been to Carmella’s, you are seriously missing out. Fantastic. Will be returning as much as I can! :)
Top notch customer service. Amazing wine selections and the food was spectacular. I love the energy and vibe of this place. Entire experience was completely on point!! Will definitely be back!
First time visitor. Carmella’s has such an upscale yet warm and comfortable feel. The wine selection, of course, is amazing, and there are cocktail and nonalcoholic drink options. We had charcuterie (there are gluten free crackers and baguette) and the shaved broccoli salad which I could eat daily.
Hours
| Monday | 4 - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 4 - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Carmella’s Wine Bar is a cozy and inviting spot that offers an exceptional experience for wine and food lovers. The atmosphere is warm and beautiful, making it perfect for a relaxing night out. The wine list is beautifully curated, with options for every palate, and pairs perfectly with the small plates like momma’s meatballs, mortadella sliders, and steak tartare. Many reviews highlight the food as "to die for" and worth the trip, especially recommending the caviar & waffles. The small space has a great vibe, and the staff are attentive, friendly, and genuinely care about guests’ experience. The owner is particularly praised for his kindness and personal touch, often visiting tables and helping guests find the perfect wine. Service is prompt and welcoming, creating a sense of comfort and hospitality that sets Carmella’s apart. Guests appreciate the close-knit team and the effort they put into making each visit special. Whether celebrating or just enjoying a night out, Carmella’s Wine Bar is seen as a new favorite in Rochester, offering a perfect blend of great wine, tasty bites, and warm hospitality.