12 Best American Restaurants in Pittsford

“LOVED THE FOOD!! So good and the atmosphere is amazing! Such great service“

“Recently went for a girls dinner and was happy to find many gluten free options clearly labeled on the menu. Staff was very knowledgeable and accommodating. Food and cocktails were delicious. Celiac approved. Will be back.“

“Late-Night Gem: Hungry in Pittsford, NY

After 9:30 PM, finding a spot for a quick and delicious bite can feel like a challenge, but Hungry in Pittsford delivered beyond expectations. I ordered their Hungry Wrap, Italian Sausage, and Platter Combo, and they whipped everything up in no time!

The Platter Combo was a crispy, indulgent medley of fried treats, cooked to perfection and paired with tangy sauces. The Hungry Wrap was a cheesy, flavorful delight—each bite was a symphony of fresh ingredients and bold seasonings. The Italian Sausage was packed with hearty flavors, perfectly balanced by caramelized onions and peppers in a soft, crusty roll.

Every dish was freshly prepared and absolutely delicious. Hungry not only nailed the taste but also the speed—an ideal spot for late-night cravings. If you’re ever in Pittsford and need a quick yet satisfying meal, don’t miss this place.“

“Delicious. Great service. Definitely coming back.“

“showed up for dinner and they aren't open anymore“

“My partner and I had our first date at the EG seven years ago, so in an uncharacteristically sentimental moment, I made reservations for us to eat there this past weekend. (We've eaten there a few times in the interim, but this was our most recent visit, just to clarify.) We've always enjoyed the quality of the service, the overall atmosphere and, until this last visit, the dinner cuisine. The Reader's Digest version: Tasty Old Fashioned cocktail for me, a vodka highball with a barely detectable hint of vodka for her. Very good French Onion soup and good white chicken chili for apps. Our crab cakes were ... fair - not a lot of filler, but a bit bland and underseasoned. Very good carrot cake for dessert, accompanied by very good hot coffee. Now, the cautionary part: If you eat dinner here, I'd strongly suggest you skip the $36 wagyu meatloaf - we agreed it was underseasoned, with an unappetizing texture (dense and chewy, more reminiscent of forcemeat than meatloaf), served with a decent Espagnole sauce that provided badly-needed moisture, and containing a few bits of what I can only surmise was incompletely ground gristle. It really missed the mark, especially at that price, in an otherwise good restaurant. We'll be back, of course - it's not as though this particular meal was the norm in our experience, rather than the exception - but if this was how the wagyu meatloaf is typically prepared and served, it needs work. Our server, Hanna, was professional, efficient and friendly. One other criticism: The dining room chairs are quite short - unless you're a six-footer or taller, prepare for your tabletop to be awkwardly high.“

“Delicious egg nog ice cream! Also love the raspberry/chocolate tarts and s’mores tart! Great customer service and cozy atmosphere!“

“why not?? could be Good If The Version. we. are. on. is.....“

“We make several trips to Tom Wahl’s during the year. Best burgers and fish fry. We have a family tradition of many years to go there on Christmas Eve. Merry Christmas to all at Tom Wahls!“

“We stopped in for lunch today at Fruit &Salad Co. and had a lovely lunch. The food was delicious as was the service! The manager was friendly and available to the customers. They have a wide variety of soups, salads, sandwiches and desserts. The dinner menu look wonderful too. We specifically picked this restaurant for their vegetarian options. If you are looking for a quiet but quaint place to get a bite to eat in the Fairport area don’t hesitate to stop in here. Five stars all the way!“

“During my recent stay at the Hilton Hotel, I had the pleasure of experiencing the bartending services at their stunning garden bar. The ambiance of the tranquil setting was enhanced by the remarkable skills of their bartender, Jeff.Moreover, their ability to engage with guests, and making you feel welcomed. He walked me through his years of experience with the hotel and it was quite comforting.“

“Good burger and great server named Kelly. 😎“