12 Best American Restaurants in Fairport

McArdle's Restaurant American • $$
1355 Fairport Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Bourbon BBQ Bacon Burger Onion Rings
Pot Roast Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Charleston Crab and Scallop Soup
Pecan Encrusted Chicken Salad
Beer Battered Fish Fry
Fried Fish Sandwich
Buffalo Pierogies
Pot Roast Poutine
French Onion Soup
Pot Roast Dinner

“If you're looking for Great food and Excellent Service in the Rochester N.Y. Area. Be sure to check out McArtle's, a family owned restaurant in the Fairborn area. They make excellent cocktails and we enjoyed a delicious dinner of Prime Rib and Beef tenderloins with bay scallops. The service is great and John the owner, personally delivered our food and did a follow up to make sure everything was first rate. They have a robot server named "Rosie" that assists the servers by bringing your food to the table for your server to serve you. This works great as it allows the server to spend more time serving the customers and avoids those large trays that clutter up the aisle ways in some restaurants. It's also a great conversation piece and it shows off the food as it passes your table. Everything looks great. The prime rib was cooked perfectly and the beef tenderloin was so tender you didn't need a knife. The Chicken French was also very good. The Haddock was perfectly cooked and they went the extra mile to handle our special carrots request. Our party of seven were very pleased. The also have excellent menu items for the Vegan members of the family The tall wooden booths give you the" Irish Tavern "feel while allowing you to be able to carry on a conversation at your table. The portions are generous and fairly priced. We didn't try dessert as we were comfortably full. But the desserts that went by looked yummy. Service was great, they make you feel welcome And want you to come back. (You can join their loyalty program for additional savings.) The restaurant is very accessible allowing seniors to get in easily.“

4.4 Superb83 Reviews
Durf's Family Restaurant American • $
150 N Main St Suite 4, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fried Steak and Eggs and Toast
Eggs Benedict with Hash Browns
Home Made Corned Beef Hash
Cinnamon Roll French Toast
Lemon Blueberry Pancakes
Sweet Potato Pancakes
A Customized Whammy
Biscuits and Gravy
Strawberry Waffle
Breakfast Burrito

“This was our first time here. The staff were quick to seat us and very friendly. The food was great! Best clam chowder I have ever had. We like finding small mom and pop places to eat. This is one we will definitely come back. Also the price was really good.“

4.7 Superb65 Reviews
Donnelly's Public House Bar & Grill • $
1 Water St, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Don Cubano Sandwich
Boneless Wings
Grilled Wings
Chicken Wings
French Fries
Caesar Salad
Fish Fry
Rueben
House

“Donnelly's is a classic Irish pub - friendly but low key, you can sit at the bar and chat or snag a table in the corner for privacy. The beer selection is excellent with a good rotation, and the food is also very good. This is my go-to place in Fairport!“

4.5 Superb81 Reviews

4
B-Side

B-Side Bar • $$
5 Liftbridge Ln E, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Steakhouse Burger and Onion Rings
Sunrise Burger
Cheeseburger
House Salad

“The staff were friendly and helpful. I ate before I left, but the food others were getting looked and smelled delicious. They let my cousins put on a birthday bash for my cousin who passed away and all word his shirts to support him. Will return.“

4.7 Superb34 Reviews
Fairport Village Inn American • $
103 N Main St, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Fries with Cheddar Cheese and Bacon
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Wings in Kenny Sauce
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Chicken Quesadilla
Prime Rib Sandwich
Fvi Chicken Wings
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken French

“I stopped by this place with family while we were walking on the canal. It's a very short detour from the Canal towpath, and has outdoor seating, which is great in the summer. Tons of options, and very fair pricing. I got a sandwich, my wife got a salad, and my son got the chicken fingers. Each item was delicious. We will definitely be back.“

4.3 Superb65 Reviews
Tom Wahl's Fairport Hamburger • $
1333 Fairport Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger and Fries
Hollywood Burger
Haddock and Chips
White Hot Junker
Chicken Tenders
Junker Plate
Whale Burger
Onion Rings
Hamburger
Fish Frys

“My husband and I went for a Friday fish fry. At 530 it was busy but the food came out quickly. I had the fish sandwich. I like a beer batter fish more but this was very good. I wouldn’t hesitate to get it again. Of course the root beer is wonderful.“

4.2 Good60 Reviews
Fairport Brewing Company Brewery • $$
99 S Main St, Fairport

“Hands down best beer in Fairport. Not only is the beer great, but the variety of beverage choices is endless with new beers coming out frequently. Every so often, I try something new. For example, last month I had their mead (their ginger mead) and it was fantastic. Also, I love the environment. The Fairport location is quaint inside and when weather permits, the outside patio is awesome (fire pits, live music, burgers and dogs, and beer).“

4.1 Good34 Reviews
Mulconry's Irish Pub and Restaurant Bar • $$
17 Liftbridge Ln E, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Fried Loaded Mashed Potatoes
Fantastic Fish and Chips
Guinness Irish Stew
Corned Beef Poutine
Bangers and Mash
Loaded Pub Salad
Chicken Fingers
Reuben Sandwich
Shepherd's Pie
Pretzel Sticks

“It's ok. I've lived in Ireland 7 years and it's not quite the same. The Guinness stew was good, but salty and didn't come with much soda bread. The portion was generous. My friends enjoyed the fish and chips. It could be great with a little work, so I deducted a star.“

4 Good87 Reviews
DiBella's Subs Sandwich Shop • $$
6720 Pittsford Palmyra Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Old Fashion Sub
Grandma DiBella
Spicy Mustard
Uncle Louie
Roast Beef
Godfather
Tuna Sub
Dagwood
Turkey

“DiBella's is consistently fast, fresh, and interesting to eat. There runs a risk with subs, that the flavors are boring, or the sub is dry, or the company goes for the easy layup and saves money scrimping on say, pickles. DiBella's does none of these things - a 10 inch sub feels like more than I SHOULD eat in one sitting, and often makes two meals (except when I just keep eating, because it tastes good). Nice decor and friendly staff too, makes this my go to for subs.“

3.9 Good56 Reviews
Applebee's Grill + Bar American • $
585 Moseley Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Sirloin Steak Broccoli and French Fries
Bourbon Street Chicken and Shrimp
Loaded Waffle Fries with Cheese
Hand-Battered Fish and Chips
Whisky Bacon Burger
Fiesta Lime Chicken
Boneless Wings
Baby Back Ribs
Artichoke Dip
Caesar Salad

“Absolutely had an awesome time! Staff was so easygoing and attentive. My mom was with us, and they gave her a great table near exists and bathroom ( she has mobility issues). Great woth food allergies and food was fast coming out even though it was steady flow for customersKid-friendliness: Fun decor, tvs to keep occupied, awesome kids packs of coloring and mini games.Parking: Although it is in a busy plaza, the parking was great, we didn't have a bad spot to choose.Wheelchair accessibility: Although we did not have a wheelchair it was very accommodating to the walker we had with us. Door ways are Ada accessible and they wait staff told us the best places to sit that did not contain any stairs.Dietary restrictions: Dairy and pepper allergies had no issues“

3.7 Good57 Reviews
Argyle Grill At Eagle Vale American • $$
4344 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Wings

“Had a really fun visit to The Argyle last night to see my friend's band! The service was really on point and our bartender was so kind! The food came quickly, too. My quesadilla was huge and so delicious and I can't wait to finish it for lunch today! Would definitely go back to enjoy one of their many TVs for a football game with a good dinner ?“

3.6 Good33 Reviews
Shorts Bar & Grill Bar • $
35 N Main St, Fairport

Customers` Favorites

Bang Bang Chicken Tacos
Grilled Chicken Breast
The Barge Plate

“Cool place, bartender let me taste the sours variety before ordering one so i could make an educatedchoice. Let me charge phone behind bar, and used wifi to work on laptop. Ate FREE popcorn, had a shot of Tullamore Dew with some of the locals in honor of late St. Pats, played a song on jukebox that was my band and not with flow of background music, no one complained. Talked to some of the local crowd in there and all were friendly as well, especially to my rambling @**. Thanks for welcoming a vagabond needing face time, and to just get out for a night and see people, into your whimsically decorated, fun, watering hole.I bet this place bops for karaoke on weekends, little raised stage area and open floor plan with room for potential dancing.Bathrooms clean, extra credit.Designated smoking area attached so can bring drinks out. Not heated though.Tolerant staff and locals- especially to my off beat chatty personality and crazy life story. Watched out for my drink, safe place for women!Darts and pool. Jukebox if you wanna hear something. No deck of playing cards behind the bar though, bring your own if you will want or need one for any reason ;-PParking: Looked messy outside (beer bottles/broken glass) but was the day after St. Patty's, so still commendable in my eyes (having worked in the industry a number of years).“

3.5 Good38 Reviews
Loading...
map Map