Vincenzo's Pizzeria Lakeville
$ • Pizza, ItalianAbout Vincenzo's Pizzeria Lakeville
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Caesar Salad
Bacon Chicken BBQ
Peppers & Onions
Sicilian Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Meat Lovers
Peppers
Lasagna
Rolls
Wings
Recent Reviews
196 ratings
Share your opinion about Vincenzo's Pizzeria Lakeville
New to the area and this pizzeria was suggested to us. We ordered a sheet pizza on July 4th ( which other restaurants sometimes won't do) with a pick up at 3 pm. Walked in at 3:00, pizza was done and piping hot. Everyone at the party devoured the pizza and not one piece left lol. Will definitely order again from this pizzeria!
Had a July 3rd party and ordered some pizza wings and subs. Everything came out wonderful, hot, fresh and delicious. Excellent service.
Best pizza, amazing wings thank you for staying a few minutes late so we could pick up our takeout. Jeremy and Austin just nice as it gets.
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 8PM |
Vincenzo's Pizzeria Lakeville is known for its great pizza, especially its real New York-style crust, which is crispy, chewy, and topped with flavorful sauce. Customers appreciate the $4 cash slices available for lunch, making it a popular choice around Conesus Lake. The menu also features a variety of items such as the meatball hero, which is tasty with excellent bread, and the Caesar salad with good croutons. The chicken fingers are large and served hot and fresh, offering good value for money. The Hawaiian pizza is noted for being very hot and well-made, and the toppings and sauce are generally enjoyed. Some reviews mention that the large pizza is extra extra large, enough to feed a family of 4-6 with two mediums.
While the food quality is praised, the restaurant's atmosphere is often described as lacking charm, feeling more like a gas station eatery or pizza parlor. The staff provide quick service, sometimes wrapping food to go, but the dining room is considered cold and impersonal. Improvements suggested include creating a more pleasant environment and removing political elements like TVs and business cards that distract from the dining experience. Overall, Vincenzo's Pizzeria offers good food, especially pizza and casual fare, with room for atmosphere improvements.