50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Spencerport

“Finally got to try the fish fry’s that sell out every Friday night. 10 out of 10! Fish was light and fluffy, breading was crunchy/crisp. Generous portions. Reminded me of getting fish fry’s in the good old days with my parents.“

“I had such a wonderful experience thanks to Dzejna. From the moment I arrived, she was incredibly kind, welcoming, and professional. She went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect, and her positive attitude truly made my entire day. It’s rare to come across someone who is not only excellent at their job but also genuinely cares about making customers feel valued and comfortable.

Dzejna’s attention to detail, friendly personality, and outstanding customer service really stood out. She handled everything with confidence and professionalism while making the experience enjoyable from start to finish. Employees like her are a huge asset, and she deserves to be recognized for the amazing work she does. I can’t recommend her enough and look forward to coming back because of the exceptional service she provided. Thank you, Dzejna, for making my day so much better!“

“The cashiers are very friendly and accommodating. The only issue was there were only high tables with the barstool chairs. I wish there was just one regular size table with chairs in the establishment. But this won't stop me from visiting there again.😋“

“The pizza and hot subs are amazing here. The staff very friendly and nice. Specially the Andrew guy at the check-out. Andrew is the reason I'm writing a 5-star reveiw for djs:}“

“The BIG PIZZO!

Just give it a try, the biggest slices, wedges, you have to specify otherwise they cut it into small pieces.
Absolutely awesome pizza. Watching family trying to handle the giant slice.....priceless!“

“I bought some pizzas for my employees a week ago and we all agreed that they have the best pizza on the west side. Fast forward to today, my 4 year old is demanding pizza at a time where all the good pizza places are out of slices. I called and the owner offered to make a mini pizza specifically for her and also refused to let me pay him. Amazing food, amazing service, amazing people. Thank you!“

“A classic Italian family pizza spot that is clearly doing something right.

I ordered a half cheese, half peppers and onions large pizza for a family birthday and it came out smelling exactly like the pizza my mom used to make when we were kids.

Everyone who works there clearly has decades of history between them, communicating in quick glances, jokes about family members, and sharing a warmth that you can only get in a place that is doing something well. Definitely want to try more of their specialty menu at some point and will be back for more.“

“great food, great prices“

“I need to make you aware of a wonderful diamond in the rough on Rochester’s west side. My wife and I visited this quaint Lower Manhattan style eatery with my brother-in-law and his wife. This unassuming place from the outside pleasantly surprises once you enter with its quaint bar area, blacked out ceiling and twin open kitchen stations. First litmus test is the quality of bread with a full complement of spices to prep your own dipping oil. Check! Special of the day, Seared Halibut on a bed of risotto, didn’t disappoint, nor did my samples of homemade Rigatoni à la Bolognese (just like Mom’s Sunday sauce) or the Chicken Milanese! Completed the meal with an ample slice of homemade Ricotta Cheesecake with Berry Compote. The owner checked in with us several times. The table service was perfect. The glass enclosed wine cellar in the middle of the dining area completed an impressive ambience and dining experience. Run don’t walk to this most pleasant gastro treat!“

“The guys running the place are super friendly! The food is absolutely delicious and reasonably priced. 10/10 recommend!“

“I love Carbones. Their pies and wings have never been bad. Plenty of toppings, wings a good size and cooked prfectly. This time I decided to take advantage of their sheet pizza and wings deal. I ordered over the phone, the lady was very nice and had to unfortunately tell me that deal is only honored with a physical copy... it's 2025... the owners need to do away with that. That being said... their sheet pizza is not good. At all. Their dough is super thick, bready and feels store bought. The toppings didnt reach all the way to the crusts on any side so the outside pieces had very little to no toppings. The wings, I split half mild, half garlic parm. I basically just got 50 dry, plain wings. Was very disappointed in the party size preparation and will most certainly not be ordering wings in large quantities or anything bigger than a large pie.“

“Great food, good people keeps you coming back!“

“Ordered a supreme pizza minus black olives. The sauce is on the sweeter side, thin crust and a good amount of toppings. The sausage on the pizza was really good, they said they make it. This was our second time ordering from them and will again!“

“I ordered the Buffalo Bills pizza for the playoff game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. First off, they contacted me when the game was rescheduled and offered accommodations so that I could get the pizza and bake it myself as they weren’t open on Monday when the game would be played. THEN called back again to let me know they were going to open on Monday after all and scheduled a time for me to pick up my pizza. Awesome customer service and only outdone by the delicious pizza!! Fair price as well!! I would highly recommend Savastano’s , give them a try you won’t be disappointed!!! 5 ⭐️’s“

“we went to Krony's today. we enjoyed ourselves. My son enjoyed his side salad and onion rings. My husband ordered the chili and said it was very good. pizza was good as always. A shout out to CHELSEA who was very helpful. The other girls are friendly as well, as is WES. Thank you for all your hard work. Till next time.“

“Check it out! Super friendly service where there’s a face that’s not recognized! Check out the Steak Hoagies, Sloppy plates, wings and blue cheese!“

“Always excellent!!!! A true gem in the neighborhood! Doesn’t get any better then this.“

“Churchville Pontillos is always our go-to pizza place. They have AMAZING pizza, and are always friendly and accommodating.Tonight, though, they went above and beyond! I asked for a heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day, and not only did they deliver, they even through in a Valentine on the inside of the box! Little things like this show how much they truly care and put their heart into these amazingly delicious pizzas! Not to mention, it was delicious as always!“

“The Sicilian pizza is amazing! Best we ever had! The owner is authentic and brings a piece of Sicily here! A must try! Thank you for a slice of Heaven“

“first time getting food. ordered the Hawaiian pizza. the service was great and somehow the pizza was even better. Would say that it's easily the best pizza I've had in brockport. 10/10. would definitely recommend and will be my new go to for pizza for sure!“

“Marks brought CCHS Boys Soccer team free pizza during their car wash for cancer research. So nice of the manager to do this and so delicious!! Thank you -Soccer Mom Sykora“

“Cheese and pepperoni pizza slices were good and the bread on my capicola sub was some of the best I had in a while. The style of the restaurant doesn't really match the small town pizza place vibe, it's more geared towards trying to be a trendy influencer haven. More barbie dream house than pizza shop ambiance.“

“Best gluten free pizza! Great staff & service“

“specialty pizza was good and good crust. hot and fresh“

“We didn’t get a pizza. Just went in to try out the Ice Cream Shoppe that sell Hersheys ice cream.

A lovely young lady named Kayelyn was very helpful as I sampled out a few flavours I hadn’t tried before.

The Salted Caramel Truffle was delicious and the kids portion size was humongous! I am ow experiencing a food coma.

My partner had the Chocolate Chip in Cake Cone and he loved it.

There is plenty of seating.

Lots of free parking is available“

“I was impressed with the quick service, was in and out the door fast even though the place was very busy. Pizza was great and hit the spot, I think the pricing is average nothing extravagant. I will say the wings could use more sauce, I was a bit disappointed that they were dry but I'll just make note to ask for extra sauce next time. I will buy from here again!“

“Pontillo's Hilton totally cares about their customers! Had a glitch in my delivery order tonight and they made it right within 20 minutes! I highly recommend them and definitely give them 5 stars!!??“

“Their specials are phenomenal! No matter how busy the staff is always friendly.“

“Best catering service I've ever experienced“

“Our go to place for pizza and wings! What's underrated is their fries! We always get pizza with wings and fries! Just thinking about it now makes me want to order all of that food! 😂 Do yourself a favor and order from there! Sign up for their rewards acct and you earn points for free large pizzas and stuff!“

“Great freshly made pizza. Especially for jamming in the garage. Super nice staff and again, fantastic pizza!

Parking: Small entrance off Chili Ave in between the Colombini’s entrance and the Hair Court entrance.
Looking at Google Maps there looks to be a lot of parking available on both sides and double row in the back,but I only used the front and didn’t pay attention the the rest.“

“Grabbed a sheet pizza, top quality ingredients hit the spot, this place is unique, nobody else makes pizza like this around here. Cup and char pepperoni had a nice touch of spicyness to it, generous toppings. Chicken fingers were also really good. Not your usual buffalo sauce, I really enjoyed it.“

“This is a great place I definitely recommend trying there wings and waffle fries😮‍💨❤️“

“Huge calzone isn't exactly the most accurate, it's pretty big, but I wouldn't use the word huge. Anyway it was still more than I could finish. Burned on the top and uncooked dough in the middle though. Delivery was pretty punctual.“

“Our entire family’s favorite pizza and the boneless wings are the best around. Always fresh, and prices have stayed consistent for the 15 years we’ve been going there. Owners are good people who give a lot back to their community!“

“it was good service was great“

“Great Pizza! Can’t wait to have it again!“

“Buffet every Thursday is always fresh and delicious! Fast delivery. Kind staff. Nice Local Buisness.“

“Exceeded my expectations. Friendly service and delicious food. Best meal I’ve had in a long time. Check it out!“

“BREAD BOWL SALAD: Fresh, Delicious, and Enormous. Highly recommended!“

“I believe this is the best pizza in Brockport, offering excellent quality and service. The pizza is consistently great, and the quality stands out when compared to other chains in Brockport which aren’t good like Domino's and Perris. I highly recommend visiting this location. I hope you continue to provide customers with such an exceptional experience and high-quality food. If you maintain these standards, customers will certainly take notice, as I did, and your business will thrive. Many businesses in Brockport are struggling due to a lack of focus on quality and customer service, but you’re doing excellent work. Keep it up!“

“Excellent and friendly staff, great food.“

“Great service, yummy pizza. Subs are good calzones are bomb! Also, great workers :)“

“We ordered a steak sub and a meatball sub. On this cold blistery day, both hot subs arrived hot. The steak sub was delicious as was the meatball sub. They didn't skip on the meat. It was seasoned to perfection. My new go to place.“

“This is one of those mom and pop pizzerias that you grow up on, you have family dinners around, you celebrate with. You may have been born in or may have moved to Bergen (as I did) but you quickly realize why the residents are fast to talk about "their local pizza shop." [BONUS] If you have ever had a chance to talk with the owners, they honestly have hearts of gold! Ralph and Rosie's: Good food, good wings, GO BILLS! [try their "plate" it's really good]“

“Man I haven't had Caraglios pizza in forever, I forgot how good it is.
Large pie half pep half shrooms was fantastic. No complaints. The Hilton location was clean and the female worker there was very nice.. definitely will be back. Thanks 😎🤘🏼“

“We ordered a couple of pizzas when our family got together. The pizza was delicious! We liked the combination of the sauce and deliciously light crust. The white veggie pizza was especially delicious. The veggies were sandwiched between the cheese and crust. This was the first time we ordered pizza here. We have had slices before, which were very large and delicious.“