50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Spencerport

“Great pizza at Great price.“

“The pizza and hot subs are amazing here. The staff very friendly and nice. Specially the Andrew guy at the check-out. Andrew is the reason I'm writing a 5-star reveiw for djs:}“

“My experience is this.

I give Pontillos pizzeria a five star rating because…

Not only do I work there and actually see how the food is made and how chill the atmosphere is there.
My children and I have been ordering a sheet pizza and 50 wings every single Friday for the longest time.
Until we ate at Pontillos, we were ordering from all different places because we couldn’t really find the right place.
This Pontillos actually has some of the best pizza and wings that we’ve had.
And when I say different places, I’m talking all over Rochester, Greece, Gates, Spencerport, etc.
Out of all of that Pontillos is one of the best !!
Absolutely amazing
The people that work there are really nice.
The owner is a really good person and very understanding.

Parking: The parking lot is a decent size definitely enough room for at least 20 cars or so.

Kid-friendliness: Both of my daughters and their friends love the food. There are two TVs so if the kids wanted to watch TV they could.“

“This place is straight ? best subs hands down“

“PLEASE DO NOT FOR ANY REASON STOP SELLING SUBS AT YOUR SPENCERPORT LOCATION. subs are the only thing i order from your restaurant, besides boneless wings. I have stopped going to all other locations because they stop selling subs. I have spent thousands of dollars at your restaurants since i started ordering at your first lyell ave location. I will stop ordering if you get rid of subs.“

“great food, great prices“

“So excellent! From delicious pizza to anything else on menu. Especially the homemade marinara sauce. Hugh portions. The best service and awesome owner Jerry. Cozy and exceptionally clean restaurant. I give it 10 stars! Try chicken parm., enough for 2 people ❤️?????“

“I ordered the Buffalo Bills pizza for the playoff game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. First off, they contacted me when the game was rescheduled and offered accommodations so that I could get the pizza and bake it myself as they weren’t open on Monday when the game would be played. THEN called back again to let me know they were going to open on Monday after all and scheduled a time for me to pick up my pizza. Awesome customer service and only outdone by the delicious pizza!! Fair price as well!! I would highly recommend Savastano’s , give them a try you won’t be disappointed!!! 5 ⭐️’s“

“When I'm in New York this is my go-to pizza shop. I've tried every restaurant that sells pizza in and around Rochester and I keep going back to Carbone's because they make a good-tasting pizza the price is fair and it's always hot and fresh.

Parking: Always a place to park.“

“Always excellent!!!! A true gem in the neighborhood! Doesn’t get any better then this.“

“just have to say Krony s Greek rap is addictive it's chicen it's tender and moist along with its fresh vegetables. We are addicted and we love it thanks Krony s!! The McDade s“

“Amazing food, service and atmosphere! The homemade pasta and pizza was the best we’ve ever had! Highly recommended!“

“Fantastic food and great service. Will definitely be back!“

“First visit to Mac's. It is now our go-to pizza place. The staff was very up-beat and very nice to deal with, plus the pizza is OUTSTANDING.“

“Churchville Pontillos is always our go-to pizza place. They have AMAZING pizza, and are always friendly and accommodating.Tonight, though, they went above and beyond! I asked for a heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day, and not only did they deliver, they even through in a Valentine on the inside of the box! Little things like this show how much they truly care and put their heart into these amazingly delicious pizzas! Not to mention, it was delicious as always!“

“After reading a lot of recent comments I seem to be confused. Since the re-opening of the buffet I've been going with my brother continuously on Fridays. Although sometimes the pizza selection doesn't vary that much outside of cheese and pepperoni on the buffet I've never had a bad experience here. There's a lady whose been working at Pizza hut for almost 30 years and her experience and dedication to your team is obvious. Whenever I walk in and see her I know it'll be a great lunch. My food is always fresh. The employees are generally always nice. I understand sometimes it gets busy and you can get flustered and don't take that personally. You guys rock.“

“we got trottos Last nite ,it was perfect we had 2 large pizza 16 pieces each, 1 with just cheese the other half pepperoni and half mushrooms, it was under 26.00 dollars, best pizza ever“

“great food. my family and I enjoy the subs as well as the pizza!!!“

“We love this place!! The pizza is so good THE BEST in Gates. The delivery is always super quick and food never gets delivered cold. We always pick Caraglio's for UFC nights, would 10/10 recommend this place. They also offer grilled items such as burgers, grilled chicken, etc! The menu is extensive enough to find something for everyone in the family. Thanks Caraglio's for great service and great pizza!“

“specialty pizza was good and good crust. hot and fresh“

“we went in tonight for the first time and got a mixture of food to try and it was amazing. it doesn't smell greasy like alot of pizza shops do. I give the manager 10/10. he rocks! we will definitely be back!“

“They refused to do 1/4 just cheese on our pizza. I requested it for my daughter's who will only eat one piece each. What awful service. It is less work and cost less for you guys to put less pepperoni on my pizza. Lazy and very unprofessional. Pontillos was happy to make it the way we like it and now us and our kids are happy too. You've lost our business and our respect!“

“Perri’s is the best of the local places with the local-style pizza with that brilliant crispy cup pepperoni. The ingredients are quality and it’s reflected in the flavor and the mouth feel. Service has always been good. Ambiance? Cmon, it’s a pizza place. Unless I want a Chicago deep dish, Perri’s is always my spot.“

“Marks brought CCHS Boys Soccer team free pizza during their car wash for cancer research. So nice of the manager to do this and so delicious!! Thank you -Soccer Mom Sykora“

“Food is always excellent it’s nice to have a decent pizza shop in Greece!?“

“Great freshly made pizza. Especially for jamming in the garage. Super nice staff and again, fantastic pizza!

Parking: Small entrance off Chili Ave in between the Colombini’s entrance and the Hair Court entrance.
Looking at Google Maps there looks to be a lot of parking available on both sides and double row in the back,but I only used the front and didn’t pay attention the the rest.“

“Friendly staff, Love the pizza and the wings. Fair prices. 5 stars and true patriots.“

“Pontillo's Hilton totally cares about their customers! Had a glitch in my delivery order tonight and they made it right within 20 minutes! I highly recommend them and definitely give them 5 stars!!??“

“At Spencerport Salvatore’s, you’ll find more than just pizza; it’s a culinary gem (try the plate!). The flavorful dishes, warm atmosphere, and top-notch service set it apart. Whether you’re a local or passing through, Salvatore’s in Spencerport is a must.“

“We are from Baltimore and pasted through Rochester NY. We looked up places to eat and this place popped up. I order a burger and fries and my husband ordered a full rack of ribs. It was absolutely amazing. Ribs were falling off the bone. I ate my whole burger before we decided to take a photo. The lady that took our order (wish I had gotten her name) was great. I will definitely stop in again. Very warm feeling from the staff. It’s was like we have known them forever. Thank you for the hats, amazing food, and service. Amy & Dave from Baltimore. We will be back!!!!

Parking: We can in a semi-truck and was able to park.“

“THE MOST friendly people there, we go often for ice cream but the pizza and garlic parm wings are always perfect 😘🤌🏻

Kid-friendliness: They're always so sweet with my kiddos, such great employees there at Hamlin!“

“Buffet every Thursday is always fresh and delicious! Fast delivery. Kind staff. Nice Local Buisness.“

“Grabbed a sheet pizza, top quality ingredients hit the spot, this place is unique, nobody else makes pizza like this around here. Cup and char pepperoni had a nice touch of spicyness to it, generous toppings. Chicken fingers were also really good. Not your usual buffalo sauce, I really enjoyed it.“

“THE. BEST. PIZZA. IN. ROCHESTER. Its been a lifelong journey trying to find some REAL pizza in Rochester... but after these two angels named Giuseppa and Lucia served me up some authentic Italian pizza, the real pizza found ME! I will never go to another pizzeria in Rochester as long as Sicilian Delight Pizzeria exists up here! Can not recommend enough, this pizza is breathtaking, or as we say... mozzafiato!“

“One of my favorite pizza places with some of the best blue cheese and they are not skimpy with it.This place is more of a takeout then sit down pizza place. There is only two booths inside.It's located in the same building as the bowling alley. Most go!!!“

“My family went to Fazools last night and it was great! Food was delicious and service was prompt, will definitely be back soon!“

“I took my 2yr old nephew and he absolutely loved it..“

“Found my new favorite west side deli!“

“Hands down the best pizza in Chili. I never order from anywhere else.“

“BREAD BOWL SALAD: Fresh, Delicious, and Enormous. Highly recommended!“

“Check it out! Super friendly service where there’s a face that’s not recognized! Check out the Steak Hoagies, Sloppy plates, wings and blue cheese!“

“great quality and customer service. outstanding bread and great place lunch or dinner.“

“Excellent and friendly staff, great food.“

“Husband and I tried Ferraris for lunch today. We got the woodfire wings and the big Lou pizza. It was phenomenal! Wings were the best wings we’ve had and the pizza was amazing! 10/10 recommend! We will be returning!“

“Never any complaints about this place till yesterday. Ordered a combo Large pizza with pepperoni and 24 wings well done with mild sauce plus an additional 12 wings plain. Got the pizza right but got 24 wings country sweet and 12 wings hot. Called right away and talked to manager. He realized the mistake and said they would send out the right wings since no one wanted the wrong ones. 35-40 minutes later they brought the wings. Still wrong. 24 wings in one box and 24 in the other both boxes with sauce. So the order of plain never happened which meant the family members who wanted plain went without. Plus they weren’t well done, kind of rubbery. I didn’t bother to call again. Really disappointed. I have all these wings now that won’t get eaten. I’ll give them another chance though. Normally they’re really good about orders. We’ll see what happens.“

“You just can't beat Caraglio's Pizza. There are many different locations in the Rochester area, so pick the location that is the most conveniently located for you. The many types of pizza, wings and other items provides enough variety that there is something for everyone. Join their rewards program, and take advantage of daily deals. Monster Slices are always a great option.“

“I order from this place a lot and never have any issues. Occasionally they run a little behind but its understandable because they do get busy quite a lot but the wait is worth it since their food is so good! I usually go at night and the crew always seems like they are having fun with what they're doing and they are very friendly towards me sometimes I enjoy coming here for the conversations.“

“Great service and good food , what more could you ask for?“