50 Best Italian Restaurants in Rochester

1 Mamma G's

4.6 Superb 459 Reviews

2133 East Henrietta Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We are from out of town but visit ROC frequently because our son plays on the Jr. Amerks Juniors/NAHL team. He and some teammates discovered this place and go there for lunch literally every day they have home games. This place is the best-family owned and operated, great food great prices, great service! Tiramisu is my favorite thing in the world and Mamma G’s tiramisu is the best I have ever had. Carlo is the bomb!”

2 Lucano Ristorante

4.7 Superb 210 Reviews

1815 East Avenue, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Our first time here and we will be back. This was one of the best restaurant experiences we have ever had. Thank you for the delicious meal, hospitality and the lovely environment. 🤍”

3 Polizzi's

4.8 Superb 242 Reviews

274 North Goodman Street Suite 108, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“10/10! I was blown away. Absolutely hands down one of Rochester’s best restaurants. Friendly and quick staff and the food… 🤤 oh the food. The food was DELICIOUS! Cooked to perfection, and as 2 chefs on a date who are highly critical of others cooking, we were BOTH impressed. Atmosphere was warm and inviting, and presentation was impeccable. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! I took some pics & vids and have a smaller social media of 22K that i plan on directing to go to this extremely good restaurant if they are in the Rochester area. The cocktails are presented with class and flare as well. If you’re looking for that perfect place for a romantic date night dinner, business meeting or just a foodie… this is a MUST-GO! Thanks to the amazing chef who was so accommodating! We will definitely be back!”

4 Fiorella

4.7 Superb 270 Reviews

5 Rochester Public Market, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Fabulous spot . Great location in Public market. The special pizza was delicious. The other dishes enjoyed by all . Definitely get their crusoy appetizers. Limited wine list. Quaint. Make reservations! ( Note: you get 90 minutes to enjoy your meal to accommodate another reservation)”

5 The Pasta Villa

4.6 Superb 443 Reviews

1313 East Ridge Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I took my elderly mother here for lunch with my 15 year old because she has been craving Italian and it was close to where my mother lives. We couldn't stop talking about how nice of an atmosphere it was!! There was road and parking lot construction and since we weren't use to the area , we didn't know there was a ramp to help my mother, but every staff member was so courteous and friendly helping my mom and my 15 year old get them both in (while I went to park the car). The excellent customer service didn't stop there......... throughout our meal, water was filled up and they especially made sure my mother was comfortable! We were all also impressed how wonderful the food was! We stopped there on a whim, but you definitely have some new customers!”

6 Merchants Wood Fired Pizza & Bistro

4.7 Superb 208 Reviews

564 Merchants Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best food in town! Never a bad meal. Love this place!”

7 Forno Tony

4.8 Superb 137 Reviews

1350 University Avenue, Rochester

“Excellent food and service! New food addiction acquired it’s definitely a must try 🤤 😊”

8 Rocky's

4.7 Superb 212 Reviews

190 Jay Street, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best ravioli in town! My family's been dining there since they opened thank you mark and Andrea for taking me there last Thursday! It was nice to see Lisa too,excellent waitress!”

9 Cristo's Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta

4.6 Superb 383 Reviews

1308 Buffalo Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I need to make you aware of a wonderful diamond in the rough on Rochester’s west side. My wife and I visited this quaint Lower Manhattan style eatery with my brother-in-law and his wife. This unassuming place from the outside pleasantly surprises once you enter with its quaint bar area, blacked out ceiling and twin open kitchen stations. First litmus test is the quality of bread with a full complement of spices to prep your own dipping oil. Check! Special of the day, Seared Halibut on a bed of risotto, didn’t disappoint, nor did my samples of homemade Rigatoni à la Bolognese (just like Mom’s Sunday sauce) or the Chicken Milanese! Completed the meal with an ample slice of homemade Ricotta Cheesecake with Berry Compote. The owner checked in with us several times. The table service was perfect. The glass enclosed wine cellar in the middle of the dining area completed an impressive ambience and dining experience. Run don’t walk to this most pleasant gastro treat!”

10 Branca Midtown

4.4 Superb 290 Reviews

280 East Broad Street, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Late night arrival into Rochester on a Tuesday evening and I chanced upon Branca Midtown via Resy. We took a chance and I am so so glad we did. This place was divine. The host and the servers were impeccable. Sassy, funny, and attentive to a T, we were incredibly impressed and immediately relaxed with the atmosphere and the people. The ricotta appetizer was incredibly and reminded me of a favorite dish in Florence Italy, and the swordfish was perfection. Drinks were delicious, so thank you to the obviously talented bartender, as those were very much needed after our long drive. We will definitely make a point of stopping back then next time we are in town.”

11 Wildflour

4.7 Superb 169 Reviews

620 Winton Road North, Rochester

“Two Words…. Absolutely Delish…❣️❣️”

12 Rocco

4.4 Superb 269 Reviews

165 Monroe Avenue Suite 169, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Good location, cozy interior, with great food choices, reasonable prices & very nice staff. Highly recommend = 2 thumbs up/5 stars”

13 Sagra Italia

4.8 Superb 85 Reviews

155 Saint Paul Street, Rochester

“The food was top notch! And customer service was wonderful!”

14 Fedele's Brook House

4.5 Superb 422 Reviews

920 Elmridge Center Drive, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Ann was an exceptional waitress. We will definitely request her on our next visit. On point with great service.”

15 Roma

4.9 Superb 44 Reviews

321 Exchange Boulevard, Rochester

“The front counter ladies and the folks making the food were awesome I'm just sad I didn't get to take some of their gelato this first time coming but my goodness they all looked so good and the sweet potato casserole gelato was so yummy for a sample taste I felt guilty not getting any after lol please don't change this place”

16 Capone's Italian Eatery Irondequoit

4.5 Superb 132 Reviews

12 Cooper Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“the Philly steak was cheap cheese with green peppers that ruined the taste. the turkey sub little turkey not as good as Wegmans. Caesar salad sub mush salad and ok chicken not worth the money.”

17 Wilshire Restaurant & Catering

4.6 Superb 65 Reviews

1245 Lyell Avenue, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They catered our 100 person baby shower and the food was amazing. The price was great and so easy to order. They let me know exactly what we needed and were so kind and helpful. 100% recommend!!!!”

18 Calabresella's New York Style Deli

4.8 Superb 338 Reviews

1386 Buffalo Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“great food, great people THANKS”

19 Veneto Pizza & Pasta

4.4 Superb 501 Reviews

318 East Avenue, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Thank you, Veneto, for hosting our company holiday party this weekend! The ambience was amazing, food was delicious, and service was wonderful. Coordinating the event was easy, and our team had a really great time! Thank you for a memorable night!”

20 Mr. Dominic's at the Lake

4.4 Superb 354 Reviews

4699 Lake Avenue, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We celebrated a family dinner and was very pleased with the remodel which none of us had been aware of. We had an amazing waitress , food was fantastic.: wine went down well.. and even the bread was delish. We can have a critical family but tonight everyone went home very satisfied . We will be back SOON. Thank you so much.”

21 Papa Joe's Italian Eatery

4.4 Superb 289 Reviews

485 Spencerport Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Your food went way way down the way outside is so long it's ridiculous then the food is cold doesn't taste like it should taste you should get back to cook she had there when you opened the ones who came from fornataros. Got to go food for Thanksgiving no one touched it the the artichoke French looked like chicken nuggets terrible look like it was baked not sauteed the clams casino were as big as to Wegmans water bottle caps I took a picture was going to even send it to them but you know they don't do anything anyways we got 25 clams casino maybe a total of those clams were four clams that's all small they were nobody even ate them I'm going to be calling to take them back but someone said don't bother they don't care about their food coming out they think because they had a name that they were good you got to keep up that good food otherwise people stop coming”

22 Charley Brown's Restaurant

4.4 Superb 184 Reviews

1675 Penfield Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Very good food very friendly makes you like family”

23 Lamplighter Restaurant

4.4 Superb 196 Reviews

831 Fetzner Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We love eating at The Lamplighter Restaurant, Always a great meal & friendly service .”

24 Captain Tony's Pizza & Pasta Emporium

4.4 Superb 136 Reviews

385 Winton Road North, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Very good food and excellent customer service”

25 Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage

4.8 Superb 243 Reviews

1157 Culver Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The best pizza I've ever tasted in Rochester and nearby areas. It's worth every penny. You can feel the good quality of the products.Definitely my new favorite pizza spot. Continue with the tremendous service and your good quality products.”

26 Monroe's at One

4.4 Superb 13 Reviews

1 Bausch and Lomb Place Suite 2, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is a terrific little place. I work in the building so it is very convenient to me. It's classy but not pretentious, service is excellent, and the prices are reasonable. The portions are very generous and everything I've had there has been outstanding. I love bringing guests here for lunch.”

27 Mamma G's Ristorante Italiano Pittsford

4.1 Good 73 Reviews

3349 Monroe Avenue, Rochester

“Had the most delicious lunch there today! Highly recommend the crepe lasagna. It was melt in your mouth amazing. Homemade soups were outstanding. Service was also outstanding. Will be going back!!”

28 Nick's Sea Breeze Inn

4.3 Superb 201 Reviews

4581 Culver Rd, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Absolutely fantastic food, service, quality and the photos on the wall are a whole lifetime! It’s wonderful! ♥️💕”

29 La Luna

4.3 Superb 134 Reviews

60 Browns Race, Rochester

“I had my 50th Birthday party here and the staff was very friendly and helpful the venue was beautiful the food was amazing and everyone had an amazing time. We will definitely hold future events at La Luna. Thank you for everything!!!”

30 Rizzis Restaurant

4.3 Superb 193 Reviews

411 Merchants Road Suite 6702, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Rizzi’s was the perfect place to host my bridal shower. From the moment we arrived, everything felt warm, welcoming, and effortless. We were greeted by the beautiful Tevis, who was behind the bar serving everything herself, which made service fast and seamless. Guests enjoyed bright, fun mimosa options including classic, pomegranate, and pineapple, along with perfectly crafted Bloody Marys garnished with jumbo shrimp, olive and lime skewers, bacon, and celery. The drinks immediately set a fun, celebratory tone and made everyone feel taken care of right away. The ambiance was cozy, intimate, and full of classic Italian charm, creating the perfect setting to celebrate and capture meaningful moments without feeling overwhelming. The food was outstanding. The charcuterie spread was delicious and paired with an olive tapenade I am still craving, along with thoughtfully selected accompaniments. While I chose classic, simple entrées, they truly shined. The rigatoni with red sauce was rich and comforting, the chicken cutlets were perfectly tender, and the seasonal vegetables were fresh and beautifully prepared, all served in generous portions. Everything was flavorful, satisfying, and exactly what you hope for when hosting a special event. The service was impeccable. The staff was attentive, kind, and incredibly accommodating, allowing us to fully enjoy the day without worrying about a thing. What truly stood out was how affordable everything was for the quality, presentation, and level of service. Rizzi’s delivers an elevated experience without feeling overpriced. I am so grateful we chose Rizzi’s for such a special milestone and would highly recommend it for any bridal shower or intimate celebration. 🤍”

31 Giuseppe's

4.3 Superb 227 Reviews

50 Spencerport Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best catering service I've ever experienced”

32 Ricci's Family Restaurant

4.3 Superb 281 Reviews

3166 Latta Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“it was good service was great”

33 Agatina's Restaurant

4.3 Superb 374 Reviews

2967 Buffalo Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing food. Way better than Bella pasta”

34 Bella Pasta Restaurant and Catering

4.3 Superb 425 Reviews

2500 Ridgeway Avenue, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Absolutely one of best Italian restaurants ever frequented. Exceptional”

35 Vern’s

4.5 Superb 221 Reviews

696 Park Avenue, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Service was phenomenal! Everything is homemade including drinks and is so delicious!”

36 Ciaccia's Delicatessen

4.8 Superb 166 Reviews

183 Lee Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I had Ciaccia’s cater a work event today with Boxed lunches to make it easier for those traveling. Boxed lunches isn’t something they typically do, but when I asked if they could, they did not hesitate to say yes! All I can say is they KNOCKED IT OUT OF THE PARK!! You could see the thought and time that was put into making these lunches and everyone was very impressed! Lots of compliments on the tastiness of the food and presentation of the boxes! Extremely happy as always with Ciaccia’s and their team! Highly recommend!!!!”

37 Park Avenue Paninoteca

4.7 Superb 216 Reviews

230 Monroe Avenue, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This place... is special. I just had a fantastic meal and got a chance to chat with one of the partners and someone else working there. I wish I got their names, because they made me feel like I knew them forever and they were just wonderful. anyone should make it a point to head down there, try whatever they recommend, and have a chat!”

38 La Famiglia Pizzeria

4.7 Superb 169 Reviews

3208 Latta Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This restaurant is our absolute favorite, and my wife and I are so happy we discovered it. The pizza and Italian entrees are amazing. Salads are great, too. Everything they serve is super fresh, and their recipes are outstanding. It is an amazing restaurant, and the service by the wait staff is excellent. It's a warm and friendly atmosphere with the best marinara sauce we have found in Rochester!”

39 Fazool's Italian Bistro

4.1 Good 82 Reviews

120 Pixley Road, Rochester

“Great menue choices and lunch and dinner specials home made soups 🍲 and drinks at the bar 🍸 😋 daily lunch and dinner specials home made pasta dinners.😋”

40 Pane Vino on the Avenue

4.2 Good 320 Reviews

3400 Monroe Avenue, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We recently celebrated our anniversary at Pane Vino. They provided us a very quaint seat overlooking the river. They have done a nice job masking the noise level of their beautiful interior that is full of character. We interacted with 4 staff that were all very personable, professional, and efficient. The food was all exceptional and the wine list very nice. We were impressed that the owner checked on us several times, he definitely cares and pays attention to detail. We plan to return here on our next visit to the area.”

41 Gusto

4.7 Superb 127 Reviews

Rochester

• Take-Out

“If this place was outside of the airport I’d be here more often. One of the best Italian cafes in Rochester. Ordered an espresso and the guy asked “tall or short”- last time someone asked me that I was in Italy. Proper coffee and proper service!”

42 The Pizza Stop

4.5 Superb 247 Reviews

131 State Street Suite 133, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Family owned and operated... they always provide great tasting food and always trying out new things and that always taste great. I try to go at least once or twice a week.”

43 Brandanis Pizza

4.5 Superb 212 Reviews

1703 Crittenden Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“whether it's a huge lunch slice or an entire pizza, they are my favorite by far. Family owned and operated, clean, consistent and always fresh!”

44 Ezzy's

4.5 Superb 202 Reviews

885 Buffalo Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Too expensive in the food's not as good as it used to be”

45 Pane Vino On The River

4.1 Good 344 Reviews

175 North Water Street, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had a retirement party for.my sister 5/6/22.The service was top notch,the menu was bold and the kitchen put a nice spin on all they presented.THE OWNER STOPPED AND GREETED THE TABLE.WEwere able to bring in our special dessert's and they didn't push us out the door . Bravo from top to bottom.*****”

46 Cotoletta

4.0 Good 167 Reviews

440 Elmridge Center Drive, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Ordered delivery the other day and had the manicotti. It wasn’t what I ordered, but mistakes happen, especially with delivery service so no big deal. The food was phenomenal and I will DEFINITELY be dining there again.”

47 Rob’s Kabobs

4.6 Superb 90 Reviews

550 Bernard St, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Pollo Guisado was fantastic. Great flavor and value. Will definitely order again and highly recommend.”

48 Tony D's

4.1 Good 569 Reviews

1290 University Avenue, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food and service. Always a fun night.”

49 Amore Italian Restaurant & Lounge

4.0 Good 358 Reviews

1750 East Ave, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food was great. We enjoyed the very relaxing atmosphere without any televisions blaring in the background”

50 Davinci of Greece

4.0 Good 350 Reviews

1558 West Ridge Road, Rochester

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Enjoyed a relaxing, delicious dinner in a quiet atmosphere where we didn’t feel rushed for the table to be turned over! Great atmosphere; servers were attentive; food was good; ambiance was chill!!”