33 Best Italian Restaurants in Rochester

Mamma G's Italian • $$
2133 E Henrietta Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Gnocchi or Ravioli Marinara Sauce
Homemade Spaghetti Meatballs
Chicken or Veal Parmigiana
Gnocchi with Tomato Sauce
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Linguine Alle Vongole
Italian Egg Drop Soup
Chicken Stracciatella
Chocolate Chip Cannoli
Brodetto Fra Diavolo

“I must say! This is by far the absolute BEST Italian Restaurant I have ever had the pleasure to dine at!!! The appetizer was plentiful & delicious-greens & beans & sausage!! One of us had soup & ravioli-perfect!! Two of us had lasagna-the best I ever had!! Seriously! The dessert-amazing. The house red cab wonderful! The gentleman (owner?) very kind, attentive, amazing!! I cannot wait to return!! I would rate it 10 stars. 5 is far too few! Thank you for such a delicious meal on a snowy night!!“

4.8 Superb137 Reviews
Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage Pizza • $
1157 Culver Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Detroit Style Pepperoni Pizza
Mikes Hot Honey Dip Cup
Margherita Sicilian
Mozzarella Fritta
Housemade Sausage
Creamy Gorgonzola
Margherita Pizza
Quattro Formaggi
Marinara Sauce
Green Top DSP

“Mt first time ordering from there and I have to say my family and I are not disappointed the service when I walked in was very friendly and professional and the pizza was amazing especially with the hot honey sauceI will definitely be back to try different “

4.8 Superb92 Reviews
The Pizza Shoppe Pizza • $
1601 Penfield Rd #19, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Mac and Cheese with Prosciutto
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Chicken Cutlet Salad
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Cheesy Garlic Sticks
Cheese & Pepperoni
Eggplant Meatballs
dd's Pizza Slice
Ricotta Gnocchi
Chicken Parm

“Been to the Pizza Shoppe several times in the past month and a half. Let’s start with service. Fast, friendly and fantastic. I got my pizza nice and hot each time and my chocolate chip cookies were to die for. Seriously, maybe the best I have ever had.I have had several different varieties of this Detroit Style Pizza and it is second to none. It is now my go to for Pizza without a doubt.I also love the small pizza shoppe atmosphere not like one these chain pizza shops that has no personality. It was quiet and pleasant to just take a seat and enjoy my pizza. Hoping to try their chicken parmigiana in the near future.I don’t give many 5 star reviews, however this was an easy one to write.Great Job to your team at The Pizza Shoppe.“

4.9 Superb66 Reviews
Capri Wine Bar & Restaurant Italian • $$$
140 East Ave, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Squash Gnocchi with Brussel Sprouts
Pappardelle Bolognese
Truffle Carbonara
Brussels Sprouts
Eggplant Caprese
Eggplant Banjan
Cannoli
Burrata

“Enjoyed an excellent meal last night with my wife. Berry salad was the perfect starter. Lobster ravioli with white wine cream sauce and langoustine lobster tails was scrumptious. I had the cioppino special and the broth was spiced just right for dipping with the garlic bread pieces. Clams, calamari, and mussels were tender and tasty. Salmon was a nice addition.We let our server make several wine choices that we enjoyed. Service was excellent and attentive. Pistachio cake dessert was a nice finish.We will return soon to try the honey lemon scallops and several of the shareables.Highly recommended!“

4.6 Superb77 Reviews
Calabresella's New York Style Deli Deli • $
1386 Buffalo Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Ham and Swiss Cheese
Italian Assorted
Steak and Cheese
Steak Sandwich
Hot Roast Beef
Colon Kicker
Cheesesteak
Meatball
Sausage

“I ordered the Zwiegles Hot Dog special. Buy 5 get 2 free including shipping. Shipping was via FedEx. Delivered just as I was arriving home. Packing was perfect. Hot dogs were cold and I put immediately in my freezer to enjoy all summer long. All the way from Rochester to Henderson, NV. Thanks.“

4.8 Superb80 Reviews
Wildflour Italian • $
620 Winton Rd N, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Pesto Seasonal Special
Rapini and Mushroom Sammy
Bolognese

“The food is outstanding. You can tell they use high quality ingredients and prepare the simple dishes with care. I've had the creative pizzas and salads a few times, and my husband gets the sandwiches. It never disappoints! It's a fast casual experience with a very small dining area, so consider takeout as your best option if you have a larger party. A great addition to the N. Winton Village and the Rochester food scene!“

4.8 Superb57 Reviews
Rocky's Italian • $
190 Jay St, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Side Salad with Bleu Cheese Crumbles
Homemade Ricotta Gnocchi
Ravioli Meatball Sausage
Spaghetti and Meatballs
New England Clam Chowder
Gnocchi with Sausage
Italian Bread Basket
Rigs & Meatballs
Stuffed Shells
Fish and Chips

“True Italian Cuisine that's mouth warming and delicious. I noticed that most customers wipe their plates clean, so not too many doggie bags here.There were six in our party. and we ordered spaghetti & meatballs, a large, delicious bowl of tripe, 2 orders of raviolis and meatballs"and two orders of gnocchi with meatballs. And, some vino, Fiz root beers, ice water. Abd, of course, fresh, delicious home mak we bread for enjoying the delicious sauce served.Bon appetit!“

4.8 Superb49 Reviews
Fiorella Italian • $$
5 Rochester Public Market, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cutlet over Italian Greens-Fantastic
Lemon Cookies and Sweet Cream Gelato
Fried Calamari with Spicy Marinara
Sausage and Polenta Frita
Spaghetti Pomodoro
Honey Bee Pizza
Meatballs

“A great dinner at Fiorella tonight. A cozy spot by the public market, this went under our radar for a long time until some friends recommended we give it a try.The food was incredible (for the most part), as well as the service. We came unbeknownst to us on gnocchi night (Thursdays), and the pizza special was meatball which we had to try. My main, the sausage and polenta, was absolutely delicious. I watched a lot of the chicken cutlet dishes come out while we were waiting and was wondering if I made the wrong choice, but I definitely didn't. Next time I'll definitely give the cutlets a try.Dessert was also killer. The lemon cookies with a scoop of the sweet cream gelato were incredible.One downside and what I am seeing on other reviews that I can corroborate is the Cacio e Pepe was just bland pasta and some cheese. Visually this dish looked amazing so I'm not sure how it missed on flavor so bad. A minor blemish on an overall wonderful dinner.Can't wait to come back here.“

4.6 Superb77 Reviews
Polizzi's Italian • $$
274 N Goodman St #108, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Espresso Pot De Crème
Saganaki Flaming Cheese
Braised Beef Short Rib
Italian Bread Basket
Vegetarian Meatballs
Butterscotch Budini
Polenta Fries
Steak Frites
Cast Iron Cod
Pot De Creme

“This was our first visit and it was fabulous. Everyone we interacted with was friendly and just nice to chat with. Our server, Kathryn, was awesome!! Love her. I had the moussaka and it was wonderful. Great flavor! Hubby had the wolf fish/scallop special. Again, delish. Cocktails were great and we got desserts to go. Highly recommend and we will definitely be back!“

4.6 Superb74 Reviews
The Pizza Stop Pizza • $
131 State St, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Slices Cheese and Cheese Pepperoni
Pepperoni Banana Pepper and White Garlic
Thin Crust Pizza with Cheese 12 Small
New York Style Pizza by the Slice
Extra Parmesan Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Sesame Chicken Slice
Sesame Chicken Pizza
Meatball Parmesan

“First of all, I love their pizza. On my top 3 list. What was so special was that they helped us with my daughter's gender reveal. Also because the owner made the pizza himself for this occasion and used the sauce to make a G for a girl. All the staff came out to help us with this celebration and they were all so kind and thoughtful. They said it was the first time they ever did a gender reveal and on the spot too. Let's not make it the last!“

4.6 Superb57 Reviews
La Famiglia Pizzeria Pizza • $
3208 Latta Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Large Cup and Char Pepperoni and Banana Peppers Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana Dinner with Spaghetti
Pepperoni Pizza
Loaded Calzone
Family Feeder
Steak Bomber
Fish Fry

“A Symphony for the Mouth. The perfect pizza. The best pizza in Rochester. Pizzaiolo and boss Jerry makes culinary works of art the rest of us call "pizzas." I've eaten pizza all over Rochester and hands down La Famiglia is our favorite place to go for pizza...pizza mervigliosa.The thin crust is crispy on the bottom and chewy on the top. The sauce is not overly seasoned nor salty, and you can taste tomato rather than oregano or some other additive. Lots of toppings. Everything just plain works together.Thanks also to "Jean from Long Island" who is a sincere, kind and knowledgable person who served our drinks and pizza. Made this meal a pleasure.Seriously, if you love pizza you have to have it here at La Famiglia. No other pizzeria comes close.“

4.7 Superb41 Reviews
Brook House Italian • $$
920 Elmridge Center Dr, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Linguine with Clam Sauce
Broiled Seafood Platter
Spaghetti Meatballs
Eggplant Parmigiana
Eggplant Casserole
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Chicken Parmigiana
Rigatoni Asiago
Chicken French
Chicken Angelo

“One of our favorites in town - food and service always great! We have many birthdays dinners and family gatherings here. We often cater holidays from here as well! Always a must see around Christmas time as they decorate so beautifully! Thanks Red!“

4.5 Superb85 Reviews

13
Lucano

Lucano Italian • $$$
1815 East Ave, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Salmon Brussels Sprouts and Mashed Potatoes
Tiramisù Zuppa Inglese Profiteroles
Bucatini All'Amatriciana
Light Potato Gnocchi
Veal Medallions
Shrimp Calamari
Veal Marsala
Rack of Lamb
Barramundi
Veal Chop

“Lucano is truly a gem in Rochester, there is nowhere else like it! The service is so warm and friendly and of course the food incredible. They always have a great list of rotating specials, I highly recommend trying the frito misto and barramundi specials if they’re available!“

4.6 Superb53 Reviews
Vern’s American • $$
696 Park Ave, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Lost Meatball Ragu
Braised Lamb Sugo
Bee Sting Pizza
Roasted Garlic
Olive Oil Cake
Chopped Salad
Yellow Pizza
Cloud Gnudi
Panna Cotta

“Please start taking reservations!!! I’ve tried to go 4 different times over the last couple of months now with a wait time of 1.5hrs or more. I love this restaurant and luckily there are good options close by but haven’t even been able to enjoy Vern’s in far too long because of the wait.“

4.5 Superb80 Reviews
Merchants Wood Fired Pizza & Bistro Italian • $$
564 Merchants Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Pasta with Sausage
Wood Fired Pizza
Grilled Ribeye
Chicken Pizza

“I love this cute spot in the Winton area. My friend was running late so I went to the bar and had a great. The bartender was great. She asked if I wanted their special, I can't recall the name of the drink, but it was grapefruit base margarita. It was delicious. My friend got there we sat in their outdoor area. It is a cute setup and a nice evening sitting outside. The waitress ( I didn't catch her name, but I want to assume that she is new at being a server ??) told us the specials and I asked if their chicken Tuscan pasta dish was the same dish that was posted on their FB page yesterday and she said she didn't know because she didn't work that day. I asked for a straw and never received it. She didn't refill our waters when needed, and the biggest thing was when she brought our check with our cards, she was trying to multi-task with having a tray of drinks and trying to put the booklet onto our table, she ending tossing it to our table. I have never gone to a restaurant where they toss anything onto my table. I do hope she was new at being a server and it that never happens again. (The food we ordered was delicious. We had the spring pea and asparagus Risotto, creamy and absolutely tasty. We also ordered the Fungi pizza, if you love mushrooms, this is the pizza you will love. Crust was crispy, and the combination of the ingredients was great!)“

4.6 Superb47 Reviews
Veneto Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta Italian • $$
318 East Ave, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Traditional Margherita Pizza
Rigatoni Bolognese Pasta
Mediterranean Pizza
Chicken Parmigiano
Antipasto for Two
Chicken Marsala
Chicken French
Pizza Rustica
Pasta Rustica
Caesar Salad

“I judge every restaurant by their Caesar salad….they passed the test! Also, HIGHLY recommend the Fig Blossom cocktail. The balance of flavors was perfect. It was very refreshing & laid back. Not overwhelming with sweetness or acidity. Made for a great double date! It’s very busy & noisy, which isn’t my favorite, but it’s clear that they are a hit with locals!“

4.4 Superb136 Reviews
The Pasta Villa Italian • $$
1313 East Ridge Road, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Gnocchi Ala Vodka Sauce
Eggplant Parmigiana
Seafood Fra Diavalo
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Stuffed Mushroom
Chicken Marsala
Veal Saltimbocca
Chicken Piccata
Pasta Anthony

“I've been here many times. Probably the best Italian food anywhere around Rochester. Food is always amazing, I'd recommend the chicken French. Service is fast and always very friendly. It can get busy during the dinner rush but if you get an early dinner you can avoid “

4.4 Superb123 Reviews

18
Ezzy's

Ezzy's American • $
885 Buffalo Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Ham and Cheese Omelette with Hash Browns
Swiss Mushroom Burger
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Fingers
Eggs and Toast
French Toast
Salad

“Found a gem this past weekend! Clean cozy little restaurant on Buffalo Rd. Went for breakfast and it was sooooo good. Typical breakfast menu with a couple of specials including Frittatas. The number one thing that impressed me most was everything was hot. Not warm it was hot, which is not easy to do. Hash browns were crispy, pancakes and French toast were tender, sausage was tasty and not greasy, eggs were hot! The waitress was attentive and friendly and our coffee mugs were never empty. Do yourselves a favor and try Ezzys!“

4.5 Superb49 Reviews
Ciaccia's Delicatessen Deli • $
183 Lee Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Subs

“Awesome food!! Never had a bad meal. Their steak subs are the best!!! Very tender, and an abundance of meat!! Also very accommodating, we work in a surgery center and needed to have our order done by a certain time and they were awesome and pulled it off.“

4.8 Superb19 Reviews
Cristo's Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta Italian • $$
1308 Buffalo Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Margarita Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Rustica Pizza
Pizza Spezial
Bruschetta
Antipasto
Calamari
Cannoli

“My vodka sauce was very spicy but they did do another dish for me without the spice I did appreciate that. It was too noisy but it is a pretty restaurant. the waitress was nice and pleasant but should not lean over customers as a rule when passing things , she seemed to do this a lot especially at one end of the table where someone was sitting and he did not like it. I wanted to give some real feedback but we will be back to try another dish and the pizza“

4.3 Superb166 Reviews
Park Avenue Paninoteca Sandwich Shop • $
370 East Ave, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

One Additional Homemade Meatball
Grilled Chicken Panini
Traditional Arancini
Custom Panini Platter
Grilled Chicken
Side of Rigatoni
The Vincenzo
Italian Mac
Tiramisu
Pannini

“Ok so if I could eat at this restaurant every day I would ! I have lunches catered though them a few times a month & let me tell you the raving that goes on at the office every time they cater! I have used this restaurant before and during Covid and now and their quality never dropped! They are always on time if not early their food is delicious!! The owner is so kind and caring. I love this place its my go to not only for work but also home. I had them cater my daughter’s birthday party, my friends shower and work events !! Honestly probably the best place in town do your self a favor and try them“

4.5 Superb35 Reviews
Cosimos Pizza Italian • $
611 Miracle Mile Dr, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Calzone with Buffalo Chicken
Cheese Pizza

“Don’t be fooled by the mall location. Cosimo’s pizza is seriously the best we’ve had in Rochester. Their pizza has great crust that is light, has perfect “pizza oven crunch” and is flavorful. Their sauce and cheese also have great flavor, and toppings are always fresh and cooked perfectly. The calzones are so filling and to die for. I don’t know why it took us so long to realize we could order full pizzas ahead of time but this is our new pizza night in go-to.“

5 Superb12 Reviews
Pizza Krunch Pizza • $
544 W Main St, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots 6 pcs
Chicken Parm Hero
Traditional Style
Pasta Vodka Sauce
Brooklyn Style
House Salad

“Pizza Krunch is a fantastic new pizzeria. Some of the best Brooklyn-style slices I’ve had since moving to Roc!I tried the Buffalo, BBQ Chicken, and Veggie. All styles were delicious, the dough had a delicious taste and I’m told it’s made in-house. The service was fast and easy, and enjoy the chicken on both the Buffalo and BBQ.Highly recommend this pizza spot, especially if you’re craving a NYC style slice!“

5 Superb12 Reviews
Agatina's Restaurant Italian • $$
2967 Buffalo Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Seafood Fra Diavola
Chicken Parmigiano
Eggplant Vincenzo
Peanut Butter Pie
Veal Saltimbocca
Seafood Alfredo
Haddock French
Chicken French
Surf & Turf
Fettuccine

“Homemade Italian bread warm right out of the oven melted in our mouths. Servings were so large that we all needed containers to take at least half of our meals home. Eight people in our party and not a single complaint. This is a great restaurant with very reasonable prices for the quality and amount of food provided. Very good service.“

4.3 Superb113 Reviews
Bella Pasta Restaurant and Catering Italian • $
2500 Ridgeway Ave, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Bella Pasta Special with Chicken
Chicken French over Pasta
Soup & House Salad
Eggplant Parmesan
Sicilian Calamari
Haddock French
Salad Dressing
Chicken Marsala
French Fries
With Sausage

“Nothing but great food, nice employees, and decent prices at this Italian spot. I genuinely cannot complain at all. The calamari is extremely fresh- crunchy on the outside and not too chewy; add in the marinara on the side is delicious. The dinner portions are very good considering the price; I get at least 2 nights worth of dinners out of one! The Caesar salad dressing is so good- you can tell is homemade which makes it even better. Overall, worth the money every time!“

4.3 Superb98 Reviews
Papa Joe's Italian Eatery Italian • $$
485 Spencerport Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Chicken French with Escarole
New England Clam Chowder
Spaghetti & Meatball
Italian Wedding Soup
Chicken Parmigiano
Carbonara Romana
Chicken Parmesan
Angel Hair Pasta
Italian Bread
Garlic Bread

“Some of the best Italian food around for sit down or take out, they do it right. And that's saying a lot since they are in Gates, NY. If you're an Italian restaurant in Gates, you have to be good and you have to be authentic and this place is just that. Throw a dart at the menu and it's gonna be good and it's really great value for your money. They are priced well below their quality. You can't go wrong here!“

4.3 Superb81 Reviews
ROAM Cafe American • $$
260 Park Ave, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Spinach Fettuccine Fra Diavolo
Buffalo Fried Cauliflower
Steak & Eggs Brunch
Smothered Chicken
Chicken Parmesan
Pesto Chicken
French Fries
Crab Cake
Meatballs
Arancini

“Had an excellent dinner! Two of us had the strip steak special which was huge and cooked perfectly. Sides were good size portions and everything tasted delicious. One had smothered chicken which they said was delicious. We started with the fried calamari which had excellent flavor. Make reservations as it is a very small restaurant and you likely will not be seated without one. We would absolutely go again.“

4.3 Superb77 Reviews
MicGinny's on the River Sports Bar • $$
2246 E River Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Wings for How Many Years You
Boneless Chicken Wings
Rochester Wings
Boneless Wings
Sampler Platter
Fries

“Stopped in after a particularly rough day and Kendra took such good care of me, she completely turned it around. Food was delicious but the conversation took this experience all the way home. She's the definition of above and beyond. Thanks, sis!!“

4.3 Superb71 Reviews

29
Rocco

Rocco Italian • $$$
165 Monroe Ave, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Braised Beef Short Ribs
Linguine Alle Vongole
Butterscotch Budino
Mozzarella Arancini
Grilled Calamari
Pizza Margherita
Peperoni Pizza
Fresh Ricotta
Bread Pudding
Caesar Salad

“Nice atmosphere with friendly staff and owner and welcoming regulars at the bar as you walk in. Good specials and knowledgeable waiter who was their chef before. Food was solid but toast was overcooked and burnt. Serves until 10 so good for a late night dinner.“

4.3 Superb47 Reviews
Brandanis Pizza Pizza • $
1703 Crittenden Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Yellow Hot Peppers & Pepperoni Slice
Pepperoni and Mushrooms Pizza
Sweat and Sour Chicken Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Spinach Artichoke Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Giant Pizza Slice
Chicken Tenders
Pepperoni Pizza

“Hands down my favorite pizza in Rochester. I've tried most single and chain pizza places in the area and I haven't beaten this. I grew up near NYC so I have decently high pizza standards. But it's DELICIOUS. It's only take-out but it's worth “

4.3 Superb45 Reviews
Cerame's Italian Villa Italian • $
3450 Winton Pl, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Linguine with Clam Sauce
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Marsala
Minestrone Soup
Chicken French
Pasta Trio

“Cerame’s was the same old one I grew to like and eventually love.Vegetarian options: A lot of pasta and pizza without meatParking: A lot of spots and a short walk from the parking lot. Also easy to drive next to the building when dropping someone off or picking up take out.Kid-friendliness: A lot of pizza and pasta options on the menu. The kids also have their own menu to choose from if they’re smaller.“

4.3 Superb39 Reviews
Campi's Restaurant American • $
205 Scottsville Rd, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger Everyday Special
Macaroni Salad
Steak Bomber
Cheesesteak
Fries
Sauce
Steak

“This Rochester original has been here for 80 years. The Bomber was huge(Rochester) and definitely delicious. As was the campi plate. For my first time here I'll be taking the 35 minute drive here again. . Plenty of seating and the atmosphere is welcoming..“

4.3 Superb37 Reviews
Captain Tony's Pizza & Pasta Emporium Italian • $
385 Winton Rd N, Rochester

Customers` Favorites

Captain Tony's Pizza
Captain's Classic
Garlic Bread
Deep Dish
Sin Stix

“One of the best pizza places in the area and by far the one with the best deep dish. Consistently solid food every time we order and have never been disappointed in anything we've tried (ever gotten breadsticks from somewhere and been sad they weren't good? you don't have to worry about that here!) Staff is always friendly and always busting their butts to get orders out fast. Just wish we lived closer so I could order more often!Parking: Parking is just off the street and near the back of the building. heads up that the lighting is pretty bad here.“

4.4 Superb18 Reviews
Loading...
map Map