8 Best Italian Restaurants near Jamestown

“Best pizza and wings around!“

“This restaurant was recommended to us by a friend who has family living here and also by two employees at the Lucille Ball museum. We think the recommendation was well made. The service and food are wonderful. Understand this is a local restaurant for the people of the community. And they do a very good job. We had the chicken à la Ava and it was delicious. We chose the Sunday sauce for the pasta and found the sauce to be rich and a little bit on the sweet side. It was very tasty. And we shared our compliments with the chef You couldn’t go wrong to come here. The restaurant decor is very nice and simple. The booth can very comfortably see six people making this a great place to bring your family or a group of friends“

“From the first bite to the last interaction, this place feels like NYC at its finest. The quality, the professionalism, and the depth of flavor are on another level. It’s rare to experience excellence so consistently. Thank you for being such a remarkable company.“

“While in Jamestown to see Nat Comedy Center & Lucy/Desi Museum, we stopped for lunch at The Pub. Excellent service! Great food! 😋 Will def eat here again next time I'm up that way.“

“Delicious real Italian food best I’ve had in Florida so far after moving here, 5 stars!“

“I have to say, this location is way better then the other location, by far despite the area it has been put in, it comes out on top. Food always cooked to perfection, even requested well done and I never seem such a great cheese bread in my life, pepsi is always cold, and the workers are really nice. I remember talking to this one lady about prices, and trying to guess it and we had a little joke going. This is everything a little ceasers should be. Great price, great food, great service.“

“If you're looking for authentic Italian cuisine that feels straight out of Italy, Anthony’s supper club is an absolute gem. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warm smiles, the comforting aroma of fresh herbs, and an atmosphere that perfectly balances rustic charm with modern elegance. We started with the red, white and blue burger — creamy, rich, and perfectly paired with the truffle fries. The sauce was this beautiful balance of heat, richness, and spice that hit every note. The pasta is clearly made fresh daily; the prime rib was tender and flavorful, and the shrimp was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of spice and garlic. The service deserves its own mention — attentive without being overbearing, and the staff truly know their menu. Our server even recommended a lovely pizza that paired beautifully with our main courses. To finish, the pies they served were heavenly — light, airy, and not too sweet — easily one of the best I’ve had outside of Italy. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just craving an exceptional meal, Anthony's Supper Club is the way to go!“

“The visit I had last night was awesome. The server was sweet and had a sense of humor. The company was great and the food was amazing. We all had a form of alfredo. Two of us had the state Gorgonzola alfredo, one had Broccoli alfredo, and the other had chicken Alfredo. The lemonade was yummy and very refreshing. Based on last night's visit I would say it was a great night.“