Frosty's Ice Cream

Name: Frosty's Ice Cream
Address: 5500 Broadway, Lancaster, New York, 14086, US
Telephone: (716) 697-1812
Price range: $
Rating: 4.9

$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
5500 Broadway, Lancaster
(716) 697-1812

Menu Order Online

About Frosty's Ice Cream

Frosty's Ice Cream is a long-time local favorite that consistently earns high praise. The distinctive building on Broadway features a convenient play area in front for children, including a couple of wooden trains for the kids to play in. Ordering is a seamless and quick experience: just approach the window to select from a vast array of ice creams, shakes, and other unique specialties like the ice cream nachos, then collect your delicious treat at the opposing window. One of the best surprises is the legendary portion sizes - expect your order to be at least a size larger than what you'd typically receive elsewhere, and you get a good amount. Though the prices are not expensive, Frosty's truly excels in delivering unparalleled quality, unique options, and exceptional value.

The huge selection offers something for everybody, including vegan and non-dairy options, and they're constantly keeping things fresh with new flavors like blueberry cheesecake and strawberry daiquiri. Customers are constantly impressed by the different dessert creations, and the generous scoop sizes are always tasty. The staff is friendly, helpful, and accommodating. Please note this location is cash only but they have an ATM. Whether you're a long-time local or a first-time visitor, Frosty's is a must-visit Lancaster tradition that provides a fun, family-friendly experience for all ages.