7 Best Ice Cream Shops near Little York

“Country Flavors offers a delicious selection of hard ice cream, sundaes, shakes, and soft serve including unique flavors like orange and black raspberry. The outdoor seating in a nice country setting adds to the experience. Customers enjoyed options like brownie sundaes and rainbow sherbet.“

“Frosty Caboose serves delicious treats like the salted caramel milkshake, which tastes like a caramel candy mixed with a graham cracker. This affordable spot offers funny and different options, making it a great value for families, with meals starting at $20 for five people.“

“The Little Treat Shoppe in Polkville NY is a cute, mom-owned shop off I-81, offering delicious dairy-free and allergy-friendly ice cream flavors. With quick access from the highway, it's a perfect stop for travelers. The shop provides excellent service, picnic tables, and beautiful flowers. Visitors highly recommend trying their local Gifford's ice cream, with the nutter butter being a top choice for peanut butter enthusiasts. Don't miss this bright yellow shop near exit 10 for a sweet treat experience.“

“Footie's Freez is a popular spot in Cortland known for their delicious ice cream treats. Customers love the changing soft serve flavor of the week and the generous portions. The pulled pork is highly anticipated when the season opens. The friendly staff is always willing to make things right if there's an issue with the order. With a line often stretching to the road, Footie's Freez is an essential stop for ice cream lovers.“

“Super Cream Dairy Bar is a beloved local spot known for its excellent homemade ice cream. The clean and spacious establishment offers a cozy small-town atmosphere, with both indoor and outdoor seating options. The menu features a variety of hard ice cream flavors, including customer favorites like vanilla, mint chip, and coffee. The staff is consistently courteous and helpful, catering to all visitors, including those with dietary restrictions who can enjoy the gluten-free ice cream and cones. Whether you're a longtime regular or a first-time visitor, Super Cream Dairy Bar is sure to impress with its delicious treats and friendly service.“

“Samantha's Treats & Sweets is a charming restaurant that offers a variety of options, including coffee, baked treats, ice cream, and savory dishes. The owners, Samantha and Big Mike, are known for their exceptional hospitality and friendly conversation. Big Mike is particularly recognized for his delicious breakfast sandwiches and his expertise in smoking meats, which can be enjoyed at the restaurant or catered for special events. The coffee, specifically the Dirty Dark Roast, has received high praise. The welcoming atmosphere and delicious food make Samantha's Treats & Sweets an ideal spot for both a quick stop and a leisurely visit.“

“Friendly's is a nostalgic destination for many, offering a comforting dining experience. The Fishimajig, a menu staple for over 40 years, remains a crowd-pleaser. The ice cream selection is a highlight, especially during the winter months. Friendly's is a place where memories are made, evoking feelings of childhood nostalgia. While some may experience slow service, the food is generally good, with a focus on classic American fare. However, there may be occasional issues with order taking, food preparation, and billing. Despite these imperfections, Friendly's remains a beloved institution.“