Lock City Pizza

$ • Pizza

About Lock City Pizza

Lock City Pizza has been a favorite for over 40 years, known for its delicious pizza that keeps customers coming back. The crust is nice and thick, with plenty of cheese and a good sauce that is not too sweet. The pepperoni adds a nice spicy kick. While there might be a short wait, the amazing taste makes it worth the visit. It is perfect for grabbing a pie to go and enjoying at home.

Many customers have loved Lock City Pizza for years, with some recalling it as Pontillo’s Pizza. The pizza has a thin crust and is jammed with ingredients. The sauce is appreciated for not being sweet. Some reviews mention that the pizza can sometimes taste too much like oregano, but overall, it remains a favorite. The pizza is known to come out square, which can make it hard to fit in a box, but this has not stopped fans from enjoying it. Many agree that it is the best pizza anywhere, with a consistent taste that never varies. The crust is often praised, though some prefer a crunchier, thinner crust. The mushrooms on the pizza are considered the winner, done perfectly and tasting amazing. The sauce is just right—not too tangy, not too sweet, with perfect saltiness. Leftovers are best left in the box rather than the fridge, as it remains fantastic the next day. Customers appreciate the friendly staff who know them by face, making every visit special. Overall, Lock City Pizza is a great little Lockport gem, highly recommended for its consistent quality and welcoming atmosphere. Many visitors choose to stay and enjoy their pizza at the restaurant while watching the food preparation, confirming it as a place worth returning to.