Binnekill Tavern
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$$ •
About Binnekill Tavern
Binnekill Tavern Reviews
224 ratings
the food was presented well and delicious. the waitstaff were on point.
will choose Binnekill as our new go to restaurant
will choose Binnekill as our new go to restaurant
Best place to celebrate a great settlement in my favor, a very big one! I wanted to eat like 90k oysters, but it is closed!
Still giving it 5 stars, in hopes that the new owners are better than the last ones.
Still giving it 5 stars, in hopes that the new owners are better than the last ones.
Waited for dining on the deck because we had our dog. They said 5 minutes, they would come out to get us, and 15 minutes later we were still waiting with the deck cleared except 1 table. Had to go in and ask again. Was sat right in the sun and after 20 minutes with just water we asked if we could move in the shade. We were told no because they had to hold them in case bigger parties came. He didn't want to get in trouble again. It was 2:30 in the afternoon so it was unlikely...read full review
Binnekill Tavern offers a delightful dining experience with delicious food, excellent service, and a lovely atmosphere. The rustic yet contemporary interior creates a relaxing ambiance. Standout dishes include the smoked trout salad and perfectly cooked steak. The friendly and helpful staff ensure a pleasant experience, assisting with wine selection and checking in throughout the meal. While some guests have experienced delays, the homemade food, including the French onion soup and mulled cider, make it a worthwhile visit. Many visitors appreciate the welcoming atmosphere, with some describing it as a hidden gem. The hanger steak and potatoes are highly praised, and the jumbo chicken wings are considered a great comfort meal. The restaurant is known for its excellent service from attentive waiters and quality dishes like the Catskill trout and haddock. This charming restaurant is a great spot to add to your favorites and return to again.