New American Restaurants near Mattituck, NY

Love Lane Kitchen American • $$
240 Love Ln, Mattituck

Customers` Favorites

Goat Cheese Panini
Sweet Potato Fries
Pastrami on Rye
Baja Fish Tacos
Lemon Ricotta
Breakfast Bowl
Lobster Roll
Garlic Fries
Lamb Burger
Steak Frites

“Front counter seats where great ,pastrami hash browns two over easy .Coffee was great ,service well educated.“

4.4 Superb143 Reviews
Stonewalls New American • $$
967 Reeves Ave, Riverhead - 7.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Atlantic Swordfish Saute Belle
Spinach Pear

“good food and nice atmosphere .“

3.9 Good46 Reviews
Jerry and The Mermaid Seafood • $$
469 E Main St, Riverhead - 8.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jerry's Marinated Angus Cheeseburger Platter
Coconut Shrimp with Honey Aioli
Jerry's Famous Lobster Roll
New England Clam Chowder
Wild Blue Point Oysters
Oysters Rockefeller
Shrimp Scampi Pasta
Oyster Rockefeller
Cold Lobster Roll
Lobster Roll Warm

“Excellent casual seafood spot! Fresh, delicious and great selection! Service was excellent! Staff were outstanding! Loved this place! Well done, Jerry, Nicole et Al!!“

4.6 Superb204 Reviews
Cowfish Seafood • $$$
258 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 7.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

New England Clam Chowder
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Blackened Fish Sandwich
Jumbo Buffalo Shrimp
Reuben Like No Other
Jumbo Diver Scallops
Iron Skillet Cookie
Clam Chowder Soup
Skillet Cornbread
Banana Cream Pie

“Last night at Cowfish Restaurant with my family was truly special. The service was amazing from start to finish. Our waitress, Gabby, was absolutely fantastic attentive, friendly, and made us feel so welcome. I had a small issue with my salad and the manager Jason, came right over to the table. He went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. He was professional, accommodating. Thanks to Gabby and Jason, our evening was the best.!!!! We'll definitely be back!“

4.3 Superb239 Reviews
southold social American • $$$
56125 Main Rd, Southold - 7.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Basque Cheesecake
Payard Chocolate Dome
Watermelon Feta Salad
Chocolate Bar Dessert
Berkshire Pork Chop
Salad and Gnocchi
Grilled Octopus
Steamed Mussels
Smoked Salmon
Caesar Salad

“Great Place Friendly service warm welcome“

4.4 Superb77 Reviews
Stone Creek Inn French • $$$
405 Montauk Hwy, East Quogue - 10.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cabernet Sauvignon
Charcuterie Plate
Tuna Tartar App
Arancini Balls
Striped Bass
Rack of Lamb
Salmon Filet
Duck Breast
Pear Sundae
Lamb Chops

“From the moment you walk in, to the service, drinks, decor and food everything was amazing“

4.4 Superb76 Reviews
The Preston Hotel New American • $$$
428 E Main St, Riverhead - 5.2 miles

“Delicious oyster 🦪 and professional service“

4.5 Superb143 Reviews
Founders Tavern Bar & Grill • $$
55500 NY-25, Southold - 7.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari with House Marinara for Dipping
Marinated Filet Mignon Tips
Side of Sweet Potato Fries
Decent Beer Selection
Pulled Pork Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Baby Back Ribs
Bunless Burger
Fried Shrimp
Tavern Salad

“First time visiting and we look forward to the next! Our server, Andrea was attentive and friendly. My steak was cooked perfectly and exactly what I was looking for. Thank you for a wonderful meal!“

4.6 Superb65 Reviews
The Plaza Café Seafood
61 Hill St, Southampton - 10.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grandma's Chocolate Cake with Creme Anglais and Chocolate Ice Cream
Butter Poached Lobster with Pumpkin Bisque
Plaza's Lobster & Shrimp Shepherd's Pie
Lobster and Shrimp Shepard's Pie
Grilled Mediterranean Octopus
Local Day Boat Sea Scallops
Sauteed Wild Striped Bass
Pumpkin-Lobster Bisque
Seared Local Calamari
Tuna \u0026 Crab Tian

“Amazingly creative seafood and wonderful service made for a great birthday celebration! The lobster and shrimp shepherd’s pie was spectacular! This restaurant is outstanding!“

4.6 Superb61 Reviews
Claude's Restaurant at the Southampton Inn American • $$
91 Hill St, Southampton - 10.31 miles

“Rooms are immaculate and kept up every day. I stay here for business and will only stay here now.“

4.3 Superb65 Reviews
Red Rooster Bistro Bistros • $$$
4805 Depot Ln, Cutchogue - 2.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black Angus Burger Eggplant Clam Soup
Flourless Chocolate Cake Crepes
New England Clam Chowder
Penne Alla Vodka Sauce
Red Rooster Salad
Shopska Salad
Cordon Bleu
Pot Roast
Escargot

“Went there yesterday with four. Hands down to the chef. The clams were awesome. Excellent broth with sausage and jalapeño. Forget about the chicken eggplant and pot roast. A must go. I would eat there every night.“

4.4 Superb110 Reviews
Little Birchwood American • $$
514 Pulaski St, Riverhead - 8.68 miles

“The best service and food“

4.8 Superb16 Reviews
The Dimon Estate American • $$$
370 Manor Ln, Jamesport - 3.56 miles

“enjoyed a delicious dinner, great service by Sandra but did not like the staffs attire. Felt like I was in a barn or stable“

4.3 Superb197 Reviews
The Birchwood of Polish Town Polish • $$
512 Pulaski St, Riverhead - 8.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Giant Chocolate Fountain with Specialty Dessert Station
Smoked Kielbasa and Kraut
Lobster Bisque Bread Bowl
Kielbasa and Sauerkraut
Smoked Kielbasa & Kraut
Chicken Parmigiana
French Onion Soup
Potato Pancakes
Chocolate Cake
Baked Potato

“The best service and food“

4.3 Superb143 Reviews
Barrow Food House American • $$
452 Main Rd, Riverhead - 5.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Horseradish Crusted Roast Beef Sandwich
Fried Chicken Thigh Sandwich
Spaghetti Squash Latkes
Bean & Mushroom Burger
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Roast Pork Sandwich
Breakfast Burrito
Charred Broccoli
Brussels Sprouts
Hand Cut Fries

“Came on the recommendation of Adam at Coffee Pot Cellars. Fabulous lunch! We will definitely be back!“

4.3 Superb136 Reviews
Slo-Jack's Drive-In Fast Food • $
212 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 8.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Double Bacon Cheese Burger and Fries
Shrimp Platter
Fried Chicken
Cheeseburger
Onion Rings
Burritos
Nachos
Fish

“Good food, good prices. I like the tacos and the steak / cesar salad.“

4.2 Good39 Reviews
17

Legends

Legends Fine Dining • $$
835 1st St, New Suffolk - 3.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ale Steamed Wild Maine Mussels with Garlic and Dijon
Roasted Za'Tar Dusted Cauliflower Steak with Hummus
Brownie Sundae with Blackberry Goat Cheese Swirl
Copper Creek Black Angus Grilled NY Strip Steak
Clams or Oysters on the Half Shell
Legends Half Pound Burger
Hawaiian Chicken Salad
Pad Thai with Shrimp
Grilled Skirt Steak
Eggplant Appetizer

“Great food service & amazing Dirty martinis!!!“

4 Good116 Reviews
Seaside Grill Bar & Grill • $$
451 E Main St, Riverhead - 8.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll with Truffle Fries
Lobster Quesadilla
Hawaiian Chicken
Burger
Wings
Fried

“5 stars! We are here on vacation and I LOVE small places like this. It’s right on the water and the food was so good! You can always tell by the French fries lol. Tacos had a great kick, quesadilla was great for my 5 year old, cheesesteak egg rolls awesome and our server Sierra was so sweet and hospitable. It’s a gem of a place and we would definitely go back! Just to know, it is not a full bar but we had mimosas and Stella. It hit the spot for us for sure!“

4 Good50 Reviews
North Fork Table & Inn American
57225 Main Rd, Southold - 7.99 miles

“We walked in and were greeted warmly by the host. We decided to have a drink first at the bar which was empty. Our meal was fantastic food was flavorful and well presented. The dining room is beautiful and relaxing. Our server seemed nervous and not very experienced. But she was very nice. Water service and plates being cleared by bus staff excellent.“

3.8 Good157 Reviews
North Sea Tavern Bar • $$
1271 N Sea Rd, Southampton - 8.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

North Sea Tavern Burger with Side Salad
Oysters on the Half Shell
Fried Pickles
Taco Tuesdays
Nachos
Wings
Fries
Tacos

“Great and fun place! Friendly people and good food“

3.8 Good72 Reviews
La Perla Restaurant Bar Spanish • $$
65 E Main St, Riverhead - 8.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Fries
Beef Tacos

“Service was good, drinks were okay nachos were pretty good but when I ordered pupusas de revueltas and loroco they gave me marinara sauce instead of the salsa Roja. They also didn’t take card (they said their machine wasn’t working) which was fine but would’ve been nice to know beforehand“

3.2 Average43 Reviews