13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mayfield

“Awesome pizza and calzones!“

“AMAZING FOOD!! QUICK SERVICE!! YUMMY ICE CREAM!! 💥💥💥💥💥“

“absolutely best wings i have ever had and i used to be 435 pounds and have searched throughout the state for good wings and by far the wings honey hot + garlic parm will change your life and they have beer so that’s cool to !“

“was given a slice of pizza and oh wow I ended up eating 3 slices. hands down the best pizza i have eaten. wish i lived up here i would absolutely eat here will definitely recommend“

“The best pizza, hands down!! Worth a trip to Broadalbin for!“

“The best pizza in our little village!“

“This may be the best pizza I’ve had! Delicious crust/sauce/cheese! Great service! (Five pizza rating) 🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕 Can’t wait to get more and wings and other goodies too!“

“We are new to town and we just had a “heart attack” specialty pizza. Hands down the BEST pizza we have ever had. It was perfect! And large portions for a great price! We will definitely be back again.“

“The food is great and staff is always friendly.“

“The calzone that I had there yesterday was the best calzone I ever had. It was very tasty and I will definitely go again.“

“Sunday dinner at Jay's. One server, one chef. Alexa, the server, smiled the entire time. She handled several tables, take out orders, and phone in orders. I had the chicken cordon bleu and my husband had the veal parmesan. Both were excellent.“

“I ordered two large pizzas, a white pizza with broccoli and a cheese pizza,. Added a salad and garlic knots. Everything was fabulous! Order taker was pleasant and delivery was swift! I had guests that had pizza from here and they loved it! (Especially the white pizza with broccoli!)“