17 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mayfield

“absolutely best wings i have ever had and i used to be 435 pounds and have searched throughout the state for good wings and by far the wings honey hot + garlic parm will change your life and they have beer so that’s cool to !“

“Absolutely incredible pizza!! Very accommodating and friendly staff! Not too many good places around anymore and very fortunate to have you guys in range!! We will be coming back again!!“

“The best pizza in our little village!“

“This may be the best pizza I’ve had! Delicious crust/sauce/cheese! Great service! (Five pizza rating) 🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕 Can’t wait to get more and wings and other goodies too!“

“was given a slice of pizza and oh wow I ended up eating 3 slices. hands down the best pizza i have eaten. wish i lived up here i would absolutely eat here will definitely recommend“

“Sunday dinner at Jay's. One server, one chef. Alexa, the server, smiled the entire time. She handled several tables, take out orders, and phone in orders. I had the chicken cordon bleu and my husband had the veal parmesan. Both were excellent.“

“Stopped by to grab some food on our hour ride back home and it was yummy. We had some pizza slices, a chicken sandwich, and a thing of boneless chicken bites. Plenty of places to park as well as spots to sit and eat. Service was pretty quick and the lady was very nice. My husband, kids and I enjoyed it, thank you!“

“We are new to town and we just had a “heart attack” specialty pizza. Hands down the BEST pizza we have ever had. It was perfect! And large portions for a great price! We will definitely be back again.“

“Always the best tasting food time and time again from the pizzas to the wings, garlic knots and more! Always fresh hot and delicious with great customer service!“

“The place looks sketchy, but the food is excellent! I got a small half pepperoni, half cheese. The sauce is REALLY GOOD! I normally request extra sauce, but not here. The cheese they use is fresh and delicious! My husband had 4 pizzerias in NYC so I'm rather a pizza snob. 🤣 Crust is flavorful and cooked perfectly. What's most noteworthy is how well their pizzas reheat! I usually use an air fryer, but I'm in the process of moving and can't access it. I reheated pizza in the microwave (with a moist paper towel). It was so good! My new go-to pizza joint. Highly recommend. Jacqueline is a real sweetie, too.“

“Hands down best food. Pizza- amazing. Wings- amazing. Then tried the chicken Caesar grilled wrap- amazing! Highly recommend!!“

“the best pizza in the town and the great food“

“best pizza and wings in Amsterdam in my opinion! I think their prices are very reasonable as well“

“We recently ordered catering from Romana's for an event, and everything was fantastic! We had the chicken parm with pasta and a garden salad, and it was absolutely delicious. The chicken was perfectly cooked, the sauce was flavorful, and the pasta was just right. The salad was fresh and a great addition to the meal. We ordered a half tray, and it was more than enough for our group of 8 — we even had some leftovers! The pricing was very reasonable for the quality and portion size. Highly recommend Romana’s for catering or takeout!!“

“Visiting Gloversville for work today and I went in search of a pizza place. I turned the corner and there was Bucks Pizza. The two gentlemen there were extremely friendly. The one gentlemen and I had a honest conversation about work and he made me feel better about my day. And that one single slice of pizza was heaven. Thank you folks if I’m ever up that way again, I’m definitely stopping in.“

“Literally every place I've ever ordered pizza from, either major corporations or small ma and pa shop, across 3 states of residence, a dozen more visited and an entirely different country, when I order pineapple, I get skimped on pineapple. This also goes for jalapeno. Which makes me standard order of pepperoni/pineapple/jalapeno an absolute crapshoot of expectations.

However, today I finally got the perfect za. They absolutely demolished this pie with pineapple and jalapenos. I couldn't be happier. My car didn't pass state inspection today and I had to order the parts online because Mavis couldn't get the parts from their vendor, I got 3 hours of sleep and worked a double. Today sucked.

Until I ordered this za because I was feeling too burnt out to cook and didn't have any emergency frozen food.

This pizza is the lost city of Pompeii and the volcano that dressed this pizza spewed pineapple and jalapenos instead of lava.

In the season 3 finale of Digimon when the tamers have to say goodbye to their Digimon partners because Henry's father loaded their Digimon with an unstable program to defeat the D-Reaper, Henry shakes his head, a tear in his eyes, implying he wouldn't forgive his father for essentially sacrificing Terriermon and all the other partner Digimon... If he had been presented with this pizza he would have forgiven his father.

This is the pizza Agent Mulder ate to fuel his Sisyphusian task of working the X-Files.

If I were pizza, this pizza would be my gender goals.

This pizza was Hulk issue #181. Hulk and Wolverine are pineapple and jalapenos. Wendigo is pepperoni, also there.

Is this The One Piece? Idk man

Tl;dr za good“