Bagels Restaurants near Monroe, NY

“We absolutely loved Bagel Boys! My fiancé and I each ordered a BLT on a poppy seed bagel with extra mayo our first visit there, and it was so good that we came back the very next day. We’re honestly debating making it three days in a row.

The sandwich came with a pickle and macaroni salad on the side, which was a huge bonus for a pickle and macaroni salad lover like me. Everything tasted incredibly fresh, and you could tell the ingredients were high quality.

Our 2-year-old also ate a plain bagel with cream cheese, which says a lot because toddlers can be some of the toughest critics. As NYC natives, we’re pretty particular about our bagels, and these exceeded our expectations. We fed all three of us for $18.50!“

“They work so hard and open so early! If you’re around Monroe and need breakfast early this place is consistently the BEST bagels in Orange county. Real bagels!!! Perfectly fresh and delicious. They’ve recently started making garlic herb cream cheese which is my favorite. This place is a must for our family when we get bagels.“

“Thank you, Jessie and crew! The bagels and breakfast sandwiches are DELICIOUS! The wraps and sandwiches are too! You’ve kept me well fed for years on my way to work and AT WORK!“

“Such a great bagel spot! Food is great and reasonably priced. And the staff is on point - they are welcoming and efficient. We were there and a group of 20-30 runners came through all at once. They got through all their orders in lightning speed. Needless to say we were impressed 👏 appreciate you guys for the great food. Will definitely be back when we’re in the area!“

“Delicious!! We were up here on a mini vacation. And anytime we're in New York. Whether it's Manhattan or New York State, I always grab a few bagels to take home and freeze. If you're wondering if you can freeze bread, yes, yes you can. I grabbed a few and so did my friends and we all agree that this was the best bagel we've had in quite some time. Agree that this was the best bagel we've had in quite some time. I am in Philly and they live in South Jersey. If you're in the area, go here, this is a must, grab a bagel or a dozen (I kind of wish I bought more lol).
My go-to is always everything bagel however, I saw an onion pumpernickel, wow just wow is all I can say.“

“Great bagels & veggie cream cheese. Also, coffee is good & prices are reasonable 👍“

“I visit this bagel shop at least 2x a year when I visit..They are a little pricey but I dont mind they have a great bagel and variety..My favorite is their pumpernickel everything bagel. They have great smears or can do the basic egg n cheese, etc. They have coffee no expresso. Regular drinks soda, water and juices.. They also have danishes and other sweet pastries. I never tried their pastries but they look good..Its all about the bagels for me..“

“5 stars! I've been a customer there for 21+ years. GREAT bagels, sandwiches, etc.“

“Like the bagels, but the one person behind the checkout counter very rude.“