Barlume Beach Restaurant
$$$$ • MediterraneanAbout Barlume Beach Restaurant
Barlume Beach Restaurant Reviews
52 ratings
Share your opinion about Barlume Beach Restaurant
The restaurant has a lovely, very cozy setting. The food wasn't spectacular, and I felt rushed while eating; I ordered an appetizer, but my main course arrived immediately after—and it was cold because I hadn't wanted it right away, so I sent it back. There isn't much variety in the cocktails. The cart of wine to expensive . Will be better , but for me , i will don’t repeat. There are better restaurants in the area with similar views, a more extensive and varied menu, and...read full review
Excellent food. Wonderful scenery and service
Gorgeous restaurant with food and drinks worth the price!
Stunning views, great service, excellent drinks.
Got the Mezze to share, and a lobster pasta and Cacio Pepe pasta.
All 3 were wow!
Finished off with a coconut espresso martini and a tiramisu.
Yannick/Yanni (apologies if I’m misspelling or if I misheard), our server, was incredibly busy and meticulously attentive to all of his tables. And what a genuinely bright smile!
Favorite part of my...read full review
Stunning views, great service, excellent drinks.
Got the Mezze to share, and a lobster pasta and Cacio Pepe pasta.
All 3 were wow!
Finished off with a coconut espresso martini and a tiramisu.
Yannick/Yanni (apologies if I’m misspelling or if I misheard), our server, was incredibly busy and meticulously attentive to all of his tables. And what a genuinely bright smile!
Favorite part of my...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 5 - 9PM |
| Friday | 5 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 5 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 5 - 9PM |
Barlume Beach Restaurant has a gorgeous setting with stunning views of Montauk Lake and boats passing by. The atmosphere is a vibe, with house music giving major European summer energy, even in the rain. The indoor bar and firepit right by the water are special touches. The food is exceptional and amazing, with the Mezze to share, lobster pasta, Cacio Pepe pasta, coconut espresso martini, and tiramisu all getting high marks. Drinks are delicious, and the cocktails are worth the price for some, though others note there isn't much variety and the wine cart is too expensive. Service is friendly, professional, and efficient, though some feel rushed while eating, with main courses arriving immediately after appetizers and plates left on tables too long when extremely busy. One reviewer would not repeat, noting better restaurants in the area with similar views, a more extensive and varied menu, and reasonable prices. Others call it a favorite part of their Montauk trip and plan to return as regulars.