Montauk Bake Shoppe

$$ • Coffee, Tea

29 The Plaza A, Montauk
(631) 668-2439


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Montauk Bake Shoppe

I've never seen worse customer service in my life. I've been a customer for 15 year and will never be back. I paid cash for pastries I would pick up later in the day as I have done many time before when I take day trips to Montauk. The employee failed to tell me the hours posted online were not accurate and that they have been closing early. When I arrived at 5:00pm they were already closed when the website said 8:00pm closing time. I called asking the manager full review

Bugs all over the food. Was going to order crumb cake (they have many flavors; such as blueberry, raspberry chocolate chip) but when it came time to order there were bees literally sitting all over the crumb cake. They are famous for their jelly donuts (which was why we went) but i couldn't stomach getting one with the ampunt of bees and flys flying around. I ordered a black and white cookie, which I know they arent known for, and it was dry.

Probably one of the better places in Montauk to grab coffee and pastries. They open early at 6 am. I went there at about 620 am on a Saturday morning and had my pick of items - great selection of pastries and donuts. Ordered an egg sandwich with cheese which was okay. Coffee was nice (but prefer Hampton Coffee Co. around the corner). Walked outside to a long line that had already formed.

More Reviews(171)


Monday 6AM - 6PM
Tuesday 6AM - 6PM
Wednesday 6AM - 6PM
Thursday 6AM - 6PM
Friday 6AM - 8PM
Saturday 6AM - 8PM
Sunday 6AM - 5PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.