27 Best Pizza Restaurants near Monticello

“Best meatball I’ve ever eaten!“

“Excellent service and delicious food.“

“Best Kosher breakfast I've had since moving to NY last year. Friendly, fast dine in service.“

“I'm so happy to be the 690th reviewer of this place. My partner and I were driving from New York City back Upstate and we needed a quick place to grab delicious food that wasn't a chain restaurant. We love going to local spots.

We were so lucky to catch this place as it was closing. The pizza is fantastic (I'm writing this review with a slice in my mouth!) and Laz really took great care of us. Not only was he super kind, but his energy was amazing and he really made our night.

Thank you so much for your kindness and hospitality. You gotta check this place out!“

“I recommend Giovanni's. when I was a young child and in to my teenage and young adult years my father use to take me there every week and I enjoyed each time we went their they have the best staff they are friendly and they highly believe in customer service“

“One of the best pizzas I've ever had the pleasure of eating! It's a small and no frills pizza shop with very limited seating. The prices were unbelievably reasonable, a medium cheese pizza was only $13 and it was huge! I highly recommend it and would definitely eat there again when in the area.“

“Great food and prompt service. Highly recommend to try it out. Found the place by chance on Google while looking for kosher food in the area. And so glad we did! My husband enjoyed his Falafel platter , I had a great yummy salad and kids enjoyed pizza. We were served with a smile and kindness. It goes a long way! We are definitely the regular customers now! They also deliver in the area. Thank you for creating tasty kosher options in Monticello.“

“excellent pizza and friendly service.“

“Satisfy your pizza cravings at Main Street Pizza! This cozy spot offers tasty and fresh pies that will delight you any time of the day. Friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere add to the charm. Don't hesitate to stop by and indulge in your favorite slice!(Currently located in Landau's Supermarket, It's around the corner. due to renovation in the Pizza store)“

“Great food excellent service“

“crust is amazing fresh produce and cheese. my husband loved the fish“

“My family visited this place twice while vacationing in the area. The food tasted good. There were no long lines. Preparation didn't take too long. Not crowed (but we came during "slow" hours both times). The only negative thing I can say the tables were dirty and nobody came to clean them and we ended up wiping them with napkins.“

“2024 update! They entirely renovated this place, they added a huge outdoor seating with probably over 100 people can sit. Best Kosher Pizza and good crust.

Really friendly. My slice got burned a little so he gave me another one free of charge. What a mench!“

“very nice people love it.“

“Very friendly service and great food for the price. The knots and Italian hero got rave reviews at home.“

“I can’t say enough about how great Sherri was for my son’s birthday party! She was friendly and helpful throughout the entire process and was attentive to all our needs making it a smooth and effortless party for me to pull off...thank you again to Sherri and all of the other staff at Pizza Hut in Liberty...you made our day!“

“This place is shockingly good and fresh. You do not get that feeling when walking in and i would prefer the staff wear better protective gear in terms of keeping the food clean but everything we ate was clean, fresh and delicious. I’m only taking off points for the appearance of lack of cleanliness even though the food area is quite clean. My advice to ownership is to put more resources into cleaning the dining and bathroom areas on a more consistent basis the way the competition in the area seems to be prioritizing. It could be the difference as to why someone chooses your location over another. But the food is great and fresh.“

“Sherri and Rita are always super friendly and know our drink orders“

“All the food I’ve tried has all been great, smash burgers are rightly raved about, wings are excellent. I’m not a salad person and the Caesar is really good. My father constantly gets the fish and chips. Basically all the food on the menu is worth trying.“

“Best meals. Good prices. It’s a must stop 🛑“

“we ordered 5 pizzas for an impromptu family event. when I tell you every one there said hands down this was the best pizza in the county they were not kidding. their garbage pie was absolutely perfectly made. this is definitely our family's new go to pizza shop.“

“I loved the ice cream.!.!“

“Stopped here for the first time on our way to the Island… very tasty eggplant parm slice and a solid plain slice too. We’ll come back!“

“Their homemade soups are usually fantastic, with excellent wings and enormous delicious pizza slices. Check out my review of the pizza in the comments.“