21 Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown

“Ordered Maria’s Rice con Dondulos and Pegnil. Wow! Keep an eye on their Facebook page for this occasional special! It is primo Puerto Rican fare!“

“Cosimo's pizza is on another level as is their service. I just so happened to post my review of their Central Valley location yesterday for National Pizza Day. [Link in the comments]“

“Our family was looking last minute for a place to have a family dinner to celebrate our daughter’s ninth birthday after our original reservation fell through at another place. Pelligrinos is our favorite pizza spot so I called them. It was 5:30PM on a Friday night and I asked if they could accommodate our party of nine at 7:00. They were happy to prepare a table for us! I was shocked. They brought us the most incredible plate antipasto and placed it in front of our daughter and said happy birthday! Then we have the most delicious apps, pizza and an incredible pasta special for dinner. We couldn’t have been happier! They then brought complimentary fried dough for dessert for the table! What an incredible experience! We were so grateful that they not only came to our rescue at that late hour, but they went above and beyond to make sure we had a great night. If you want a five star experience with both food and service, go to Pelligrinos!“

“Firstly, they were open on Labor Day so kudos for that! Secondly, I ordered a large cheese pie tonight it was done right around the time they said it would be, I picked it up and they threw a few zeppole to me on the house to go with it! Staff was friendly, price was good and the pizza was awesome and the zeppole not bad either would def recommend!“

“My first time here and it won’t be my last. I described a salad I was in the mood for and he the owners made exactly that. It was fresh and delicious. I recommend this restaurant and look forward to returning and trying different dishes.“

“I would consider myself a frequent flyer here!
I worked in an Italian restaurant for 20+ years Tony Boffa’s, and I would like to consider this food to be
In great comparison to such a legacy.
Always fresh and delicious.
I would recommend this place to anyone and everyone.“

“It's a pizza parlor so the atmosphere is what you would expect. Small with a few cables but the pizza is very good including the specialty pies.
They are very careful to make the pies precisely the way you order them, The pricing structure varies based on cash or credit“

“best all around“

“Chicken Cutlet Hunt

Brother Bruno’s in Middletown surprised me. I tried their chicken cutlet with mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, American cheese, and a drizzle of oil and vinegar—absolutely amazing. Easily the best cutlet I’ve had so far, scoring a solid 8.9/10. The size was great and the blend of all the flavor were perfect.

The cold cut was excellent, but the pizza, while flavorful, wasn’t the best in Middletown as they promised nonetheless—thin, tasty and appealing . Fries were good too, just needed a touch more salt. A strong contender, but the hunt continues!“

“This is by far my go to when I’m hungry . My family has eaten pizza here , we’ve gotten turkey and cheese hero’s here . Oh my goodness , their calamari and dipping sauce is to die for . They have zeppos , Sicilians , calzones. You can sit down and watch some tv while enjoying a nice cheesy saucy slice of pizza ! It’s a wonderful place that is run but a very nice family.

Parking: There’s a few parking spaces right in front and you can also park on the side . I’ve never had an issue parking and I’ve dined in a few times and I have also taken out too .“

“we were on our honeymoon with my wife and some relatives took us to this place to try the typical Neapolitan pizza and other local specialties..
Having also been in the restaurant business and a pizza chef for many years, I can say that it is not easy to find a pizzeria in America and above all such good pizza, truly heartfelt congratulations..
The staff is very kind and friendly, it feels like family.
Highly recommended for anyone who wants to have a great experience in an American pizzeria.

Parking: Parcheggio ampio e gratuito“

“Good job for driving and fast!!!And good pizza“

“Pizza was Delicious. First spot in the area I went to that had a salad slice.“

“Today was first time we ordered and the food was AMAZING! Very fresh and seasoned perfectly. Cannot wait to order again. Boneless wings, chicken tenders, zucchini fries, bolognese and meatball parmigiana and veggie roll.“

“A very nice place to visit“

“The food is so delicious and the service was excellent.“

“Great place! I like their pizza, and the variety they offer, but their sandwiches are also sublime. (Try their pickled onions!) I recently had their buffalo chicken dip, which came with "pita chips" that actually wound up being slices of fresh pita bread- so good! They never disappoint.“

“I mean it’s little Caesar’s
You know the expectations
But this place is respectful clean and love coming here when I go up state and need some pizza
Show some love if your a local
And
Out of respect give this place a 8.5/10 not cause I hate it
Just cause it’s little Caesars and I gotta be honest with the people“

“Love, love love the pizza - it is the best! Decent, comfortable laid back atmosphere and friendly staff. They used to give large glasses of great wine, though that seems to have changed with the new owners as have a few things that we loved before., now a little less so. But still fabulous pizza.“

“Great atmosphere, best pizza in town. Great customer service.“

“Compared to neighboring places, this beats them hands down. If you plan to eat and it beats other pizzeria options, it’s my number one place to go for pizza and more. The ingredients are fresh and the food tastes absolutely awesome.“