John's Of Arthur Ave
$ • Pizza, Italian, VegetarianAbout John's Of Arthur Ave
Customers' Favorites
John's Of Arthur Ave Reviews
Share your opinion about John's Of Arthur Ave
It was my first time coming here and I loved it! I got a plain slice and it was larger than any slice I’ve ever gotten and also for a good price. Besides that, the cheese and sauce were flavorful and the crust underneath has a great crisp with each bite. It’s my new fav place to grab a slice
I order from John's of Arthur Ave in Middletown NY often. I've always had a great experience. However, yesterday (7/10/26) I ordered 2 large pizzas. I was so excited to share with out of state family the great NY pizza! I will say delivery was as promised, the pizza was hot. Sadly, both pizzas were burned and dry. Needless to say, no one was satisfied and most of the pizza ended up in the garbage.
Like I stated above, I've never had a bad experience, but this one has me hesitant...read full review
Finally found a shop which will custom make my pizza for my digestive disability!
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 10PM |
John's of Arthur Avenue is a highly-recommended spot for delicious food, especially for those traveling from Long Island to Pennsylvania. The pizzas are a standout, featuring a 'Thin & Crispy crust' option that many customers describe as perfection. The large pepperoni pie is a favorite, with its thin crust, plenty of toppings, and cheese, making it a great representation of typical New York style pizza. Customers have enjoyed the wings, and many note the attention and care from the staff, making them feel welcomed right away. The Monday/Tuesday special remains a popular choice for a quick and affordable meal. The food is not only visually appealing but also tastes amazing, with fresh ingredients and generous portions. The variety of items available, including sandwiches and buffalo chicken dip served with fresh pita bread, ensures there is something for everyone. Whether someone is in the mood for pizza, meatballs, or a salad, John's offers a true authentic NY pizza experience that never disappoints.