23 Best American Restaurants in Middletown

“Review of The Americana Diner

I ain't never been inside, but I’ve had the takeout plenty of times. It’s a lil' pricey, but the food’s straight. Just don’t be lazy with your order—if you want it hot, cold, or with extra sauce, say it. Otherwise, you might get some wild surprise that ain't it.

Now, listen, that strawberry shortcake? That joint slaps. I’m not even a dessert guy, but that right there? Fire. If it’s your first time, let ‘em know and they’ll treat you like you’re family.

Overall, I’m giving it 4/5. They hit you with extra sauces, napkins, and utensils like they actually care, which is a rare W.

stars – Customize it how you want and you good to go.“

“We found this brewery on our trip home off of Route 17. It is such a great Brewery! The place is very cool! It has a ton of indoor seating, a large outdoor beer garden, and a game room! My son loved it! The food was really, really good, the pumpkin beer was tasty, and the bartender/owner was welcoming! If we are ever in Middletown again, we will be back! So far Middletown breweries are 2 for 2! Equilibrium is great too!“

“We have eaten here many times and love it so much! The ingredients are super fresh, the flavors and combinations are expertly put together, and the owner is a true showman who clearly loves the food and sharing it with the community. The danish dog is my favorite, and my husband loves the Italian sausage with onions. Even the basic chili dog is better than average, and his inventive sauces add so much flavor to the dogs that they can’t be replicated anywhere else. The building is small and it’s crowded and dingy and sometimes smoky inside, but we truly feel that it adds to the charm and makes the experience even more unique. Just go - you’ll be so glad you did!“

“My experience was phenomenal. Will go again.“

“A welcome addition to Hudson Valley NY menu changes just enough to keep it interesting and the food is always prepared and presented correctly wait staff are congenial and helpful if needed interesting and eye appealing inside with plenty of room for all diners“

“This is such a great spot!!“

“Tasty draft beer and the wings are DELICIOUS“

“One of my favorite places to eat“

“Ordered Maria’s Rice con Dondulos and Pegnil. Wow! Keep an eye on their Facebook page for this occasional special! It is primo Puerto Rican fare!“

“Thank you for recognizing our veterans! Texas Roadhouse is my husband’s favorite place but, it has definitely become even more special to us! He is a US Army veteran…“

“Excellent service delicious food very clean!!“

“Amazing. A must try. I could spend the day eating and everything in the menu.“

“As a vendor, I have had the pleasure of decorating and doing balloon arches at this establishment. The main dining room is beautiful, the staff is always pleasant and so accommodating, and the food is delicious!“

“Best pizza ever Frank is always smiling 😃“

“Recently we reviewed service from a young man Monty.Monty was polite, courteous n made us comfortable by meeting our needs.Monty is an asset to Chills. Go Monty!“

“Great food and the staff is awesome!“

“Fabulous choice for all meals. We had lunch. There were so many options! Something for everyone. Ice teas, coffee, craft beer, wine, and so much more. You cannot go wrong here. I had a fried chicken sandwich on sourdough with avacado, jalapeños, arugula, and hot honey. Wish I lived in this area and could visit more. Tons of daily specials!“

“When you first walk in, the decor is very chic and modern. The bar and wait staff were excellent, the menu was very diverse and the food was exceptional! Starting with appetizers and mixed drinks, I highly recommend the empanadas (cheese, chicken and beef). All of our drinks during the evening were not shy on the alcohol and were expertly mixed. The entrees were delicious... In particular the spaghetti and meatballs was out of this world. I would go as far as saying they were the best meatballs I have had... unbelievably flavorful, light and airy. Desserts were another win... The creme brulee was spot on and I could eat the bread pudding every day. Overall , it was an outstanding dining experience and I highly recommend the establishment!“

“Nice place for breakfast. It would be even nicer if the waitresses didnt steal your change. I never pay cash because if I pay cash unless its exact amount I can forget about getting back any coin change. They round it off to the nearest dollar always to their benefit. Apparently the patrons there dont tip very well so they take matters in their own hands....it is called petty larceny....good food though“

“we were on our honeymoon with my wife and some relatives took us to this place to try the typical Neapolitan pizza and other local specialties..
Having also been in the restaurant business and a pizza chef for many years, I can say that it is not easy to find a pizzeria in America and above all such good pizza, truly heartfelt congratulations..
The staff is very kind and friendly, it feels like family.
Highly recommended for anyone who wants to have a great experience in an American pizzeria.

Parking: Parcheggio ampio e gratuito“

“I have Celiac Dz. they have an awesome selection for gluten-free. never disappointed. I would highly recommend it. Good value for the money though not a cheap place to eat.“

“Today is my mom’s birthday and she chose to come to Red Lobster for lunch. We were greeted by Tania as our server! She gave us by far the best service we have ever received. Her smile was warm and welcoming. She was attentive and personable. She was just the besttt ! We will definitely be back ❤️❤️❤️“

“We’ve had dinner here a few times & each time everything has been great! Whenever we want to have a diner food experience where everyone can get what they want instead of choosing an Italian restaurant, Chinese, etc this is our go to! Last night was a great experience as well! It’s really like an upscale diner for sure! We’ve never had cocktails here (yet!) but the bar is huge & beautiful!“