16 Best Pubs near Mount Sinai

“Very cool local and place with amazing food and service. I drink coffee and water. I went once and they didn't have coffee and waitress sent her parent to supermarket to get met parents and I was impressed was earlier in the day. Would truly and wholeheartedly recommended Shenanigans Cafe. Everyone there is always laughing and in good mood.“

“I'm giving this place another star just because I read more reviews about it and apparently Tara's makes people happy because it's cheap food that's good. We all need more of that. There's enough $12 frou-frou burger places around here to choke a whale, God knows.“

“So— this place has me perplexed. I feel like John Taffer needs to come here and haul this place and make it what it’s worth. The first thing I asked for when I sat at the bar was a drink menu. The bartender did a ??‍♀️??‍♀️we don’t have one? Idk I’d think a bar on one of the most famous Long Island lakes would be a little more high end. The landscaping and overall care of the building is lacking. Rocks everywhere / Old chairs and cushions kinda thrown in the corner and dirty. Despite many signs asking smokers (and I’m a smoker) to use receptacles. There were cigarette butts lodged in between the deck boards outside. This place has SO MUCH potential. The beach view is beautiful and the set up for the band outside looked really nice m- but we were leaving then. The bathrooms were also filthy. The bartender made me a nice drink, good amount of alcohol and around 10 bucks.But come ON guys. You have so much potential for that place.Overall I would return because of the view and the staff were nice.“

“I'll start off by saying I've come here 3 times in a 10 day span....I'm not proud of it but I am VERY happy to have finally tried this place. Standard pub/American sport bar feel, friendly staff and great food. I didn't even know I liked French dips until I came here. The sampler is great. While it's all your standard apps (wings/mozz sticks/potato skins/onion rings) they're all great. The loaded French dip is 5/5. Very happy to have finally come in here after wanting to try it for so long. They've definitely got themselves a new regular!“

“The food we got was delicious. My wife had the cauliflower crust flatbread, which was a little sweeter than she expected because of the jam on it, but still very good, and I had the fish and chips. The dunks were also very good and the ambiance was a lot of fun. We sat at the high tops in the bar which is more of the loud and a lot going on seeing...because it's a bar of course which is what we wanted that night, however there were much much quieter and low key tables in the back of the restaurant for the sit down eating experience. This one is now added to our regular list of places to go.“

“This was the best first visit at any local bar I have ever had. We were skeptical as this was a small discreet location. The staff and clientele were absolutely wonderful. It was almost comical that they have a sign on the outside about coming there as strangers and leaving as friends but that is exactly the way we felt. Not only did everyone in there seem like they knew each other they quickly scooped us up and included us in everything that was going on. They don't have food but a very nice arrangement with the local businesses so you can have anything you want quickly delivered. They even have private menus just for their establishment. We will 100% be back.“

“So this is a Pub that is Cash Only and it shares the parking lot with neighboring businesses. So parking space might be limited. As you enter, you'll notice that The Bar Area is placed against the wall to the right of the building. There's about 4 beers on tap, with the rest being bottled beer or canned beer. There's no food to pick from in-house except for bar snacks, such as chips and popcorn. But they do outsource food to a local pizzeria, that'll take about 20 minutes to arrive. There's plenty of seating inside for small to midsize groups of people to attend. They offer an ATM, Arcade Games such as Cards and Slots, Candy Machine, Dart Board, Multiple TV's, TouchTunes, and separate restrooms for men and women. It's unique feature is it's walls that are covered with wall art and sports memorabilia. This place has a fun atmosphere about it and is worth checking out.“

“Good down to earth place. Kinda small. Dart board is in front of the door. Needs moved. Drinks are small for the price. And locals have that place locked down for themselves. Not worth the visit. But I'd there's nothing else. Go. Closes at 2 not 4am.“

“This place was well staffed. I went on the night before Thanksgiving and it was packed like most bars are that night. However, unlike most places this place didn't leave anyone unattended. The women behind the bar worked quickly to serve everyone.The food was very good! Much better quality than most bars.The only downside of this place is the filthy women's bathroom with a broken door. It could use some cleaning and fixing up.All in all, a great place with a welcoming atmosphere and a great staff!“

“Had some drinks and met Debbie. Debbie was great but to my dismay we were told we cannot enter the card game prominently displayed across the bar! It should be open to everyone, or left in the back room to be hidden if we are not all welcome to play. Like I always say, never throw away a fish that swam upstream to lay eggs!!!“

“Very calm and chill place to unwind and get to know new people the owner is never there but is a very kind when she does appear in at times but don't take her kindness for weakness or you will be very mistaken on the amount of respect that she has for people as long as they show her respect. It is a very safe spot good environment and professional Security team to keep the safety and security for a place for all to come. I would recommend this to anyone that I meet it has pool,darts, music,and the most respectful bartenders I've met compared to other places that have never had complaints I am a security guard by trade I've been to a lot of different places met a lot of different employees and bartenders and this place hasbartenders better than the rest On long Island.“

“Ate here with family, total 6 adults and a toddler. High chairs were available and there is a private family restroom with a baby changing table. Took a long time to get our food, about 50 minutes starting from sitting down. They did have other larger parties present and it seemed busy. So we spent about a good 2 hrs total. Our waitress was friendly, but we didn't see her too much throughout our dinner. The rest of the staff interaction we had was good, everyone was nice. Everyone liked their food from the potato soup, IPA chicken, steak to New York style cheesecake. I had the chicken pot pie, served with a puff pastry on top and bottom. It was good, everything a chicken pot pie should be, creamy, thick and comforting. Atmosphere was nice. Lots of booth seating and lights. It was still decorated with Christmas decorations in the side corner where we sat.“

“I had lunch on a Monday afternoon. The restaurant was nearly empty as it was the off-season on a very cold day. I chose the table by the window with a view of the street. My waitress, Caitlyn, was excellent. I had the giant pretzel with 3 dips as an appetizer and the fish and chips for the entree. Both were delicious. The shoestring fries were a welcome treat. They have an extensive list of beers on tap. I had the New Belgium Fat Tire Ale, which was very good. Caitlyn timed the courses well yet was not oversolicitous. Portions are generous and I was given to-go containers when requested. Prices are somewhat high, but given the great location, it's understandable. Would definitely return!“

“Went on Thursday night and had a great time! It wasn’t busy but the two workers made sure we felt very welcome! I believe their names were Courtney and Ed, but great drinks and great service! They also just redid the bar and it looks great, much better nice and open space now“