16 Handles

170 S Main St, New City
(845) 634-1616

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt
Chocolicious Frozen Yogurt
Yogurt Cup
Waffle Cone

Menu

Soft Serve Classics
Tahitian Vanilla Bean Frozen Yogurt
Our Artisan vanilla soft-serve, made with simple, natural ingredients like real Tahitian vanilla
Vanilla Ice Cream
A classic vanilla flavor perfect for ice cream lovers
Chocolicious Frozen Yogurt
Classic and creamy chocolate frozen yogurt made with real cocoa
Euro Tart Frozen Yogurt
Tart and fresh fro-yo with a classic yogurt taste that balances tart and sweet flavors
Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt
The name says it all-this frozen yogurt flavor is a dessert lover's dream!
Birthday Cake Frozen Yogurt
Our fro-yo take on a classic cake batter ice cream
Peanut Butter Perfection Frozen Yogurt
Calling all peanut butter lovers! Our smooth and creamy Peanut Butter Perfection is made with natural, roasted peanut butter

Specialty Soft-Serve
Orange Dreamsicle Frozen Yogurt
Your childhood favorite ice cream bar magically transformed into a super creamy fro-yo. We make our Creamsicle-inspired flavor with vanilla cream and orange juice.
Pomegranate Tart Frozen Yogurt
Our tart fro-yo base is brought to the next level with a punch of pomegranate
Pistachio Frozen Yogurt
We're nuts about this perfectly pistachio flavor, and you will be too!

Low & No Sugar Added Soft-Serve
Arriba Coffee Frozen Yogurt
Rich, dark roast coffee frozen yogurt made with 100% Arabica coffee beans
Mint Chocolate Chip Frozen Yogurt
Who doesn't love the refreshing combination of mint and real chocolate? Our mint chip flavor is all natural and ultra-flavorful
NSA Strawberry Fields Frozen Yogurt
No sugar added strawberry frozen yogurt with a summery, sweet taste you're sure to love

Vegan (Dairy Free) Soft-Serve & Sorbet
Pomegranate Raspberry Sorbet (V)
This classic superfruit sorbet has been on our menu since opening day!
Oatly Marshmallow Soft Serve (V)
From the campfire to the handles, our dairy-free Marshmallow soft serve is a sweet and toasty late-summer favorite from 16 Handles x Oatly!
Oatly Cinnamon Bun Soft Serve (V)
Like warm, fresh-from-the-oven cinnamon buns on a Sunday morning. All the cinnamon and brown sugar deliciousness, none of the dairy. Available exclusively at 16 Handles!
Rocket Pop Italian Ice
Relive your childhood with our iconic blend of cherry, lemon, and blue raspberry ice! Limited time only to help us celebrate Independence Day!
Tigers Blood Sorbet
Escape into the tropics with the exotic combination of strawberry, watermelon, and coconut flavors.

Smoothies
BFF Smoothie
Made with strawberries and bananas
Surf's Up Smoothie
Made with strawberries and pineapple
Acai Elixir Smoothie
Made with strawberries, blueberries, and acai berries with guarana
Tropic Thunder Smoothie
Made with pineapple and mango
Brr Berry Smoothie
Made with strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries

Milkshakes
Vanilla Milkshake
Made with premium vanilla syrup
Chocolate Milkshake
Made with Ghirardelli chocolate sauce
Cookies & Cream Milkshake
Made with crushed Oreos

Bottled Beverages
Water Bottle (16.9 oz)
Please note: brand my vary by location

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
Photo credit: google
+92 photos
Photo credit: nextdoor
+91 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Great place to go with friends amd family.

They have new flavors every once and a while and they give you taste testers to make sure you like what you're getting.

They are super friendly and nice.

I'd even go here for a cute date.

Check it out and, enjoy!
November 2025
This 16 Handles location is the perfect spot for a sweet treat! The variety of frozen yogurt flavors and toppings is endless, allowing you to customize your dessert exactly how you like it. The staff is always friendly and the store is clean and welcoming. Whether you’re craving something fruity or indulgent, there’s a flavor and combination for everyone. A must-visit for frozen yogurt lovers!
September 2024
Great ice cream spot!! Such delicious and fresh ice cream/ froyo. They have a huge topping selection. So many great toppings to choose from. They had some vegan flavors which was a nice addition. The costumer service was great. They were really helpful. Really a great place for a quick treat.

Vegetarian options: They had a couple vegan flavors to choose from.

Parking: Nice sized parking lot makes parking a breeze.

Kid-friendliness:...
July 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Kumo Sushi and Lounge New City - 170 S Main St
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Salad
The Official Cake Lady - 191 S Main St
Bakery, Custom Cakes
Sazon Y Pilon Kitchen & Bar - 191 S Main St
Mediterranean, Latin American, Spanish, Dominican, Puerto Rican

16 Handles

170 S Main St, New City, NY 10956
(845) 634-1616