New City Pizza
$ • Pizza
Hours:
218 S Main St, New City
(845) 634-2016
Customers' Favorites
New City Pizza Reviews
Great tasting pizza when it's made right. Some days it's perfect. Other days it's burned. I have even received it with a mushy crust. Their major problem is the inconsistency in the preparation of the product. If they got this under control, they would be 5 stars.
Pizza is fine…a little salty for my taste and VERY expensive! For context, I work all across NYC and never had pizza so expensive as they have here at New City Pizza. $26 for a 10” Medium specialty pie while my favorite pizza place on the Upper East Side of Manhattan has that same pie but a size *Large* for $18! I checked another pizza place in Manhattan just to be sure I wasn’t crazy and again, their Medium pizza was larger (14”) and cheaper $18.50. Their XL 18” is...read full review
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in New City Also Viewed
New City Pizza is probably my favorite pizza in the New York area — the pizza is amazing and it tastes exactly how I remember as a little kid. It has a unique flavor, the slices are a decent size, the crust is tasty and they put lots of cheese and sauce on the regular slices, which is the difference maker in my opinion. A crispy thin crust balanced with toppings.That being said, they are / have become somewhat expensive and sometimes the pizza is a little more well-done than...read full review