Best Pizza
$ • Pizza
Hours:
52 Main St, New Paltz
(845) 255-1999
Customers' Favorites
Best Pizza Reviews
As a first timer, I definitely wouldn't call it the "best" pizza, but I'd give it a respectable 7.5/10I got the margarita pizza. The pizza was cooked well, the crust was nicely done and the toppings were nice. I did wish there was more cheese on it though, I'm used to a much thicker layer of cheeseThe soft drink offerings kind of sucked though. It's a small selection, and the Pepsi was broken at the timeOverall it was very good, but maybe just not the best
I hate writing bad reviews but I have to say something. This is my second time ordering it. The first time, everything was on point. This time, I ordered for pick up. There was plenty of time to make the food. No rush at all. I ordered a cheese pie (just like the first time) and chicken wings. The wings were so good. I love it, but pizza was burnt. Burnt like burnt burnt. You can tell by looking and tasting it. Like more than half of the pie was burnt both the crust and pizza...read full review
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 12 - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 12 - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 12 - 10PM |
| Thursday | 12 - 10PM |
| Friday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Saturday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Sunday | 12 - 10PM |
People in New Paltz Also Viewed
Love the Pizza but they are often closed when they are advertised as open. Like right now... it's 930... says they are open but the lights are off and no one is there.Pizza is great, but totally undependable with their hours.It seems like they're more interested in leaving early than they are with seeing the business succeed.