30 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Paltz

“I love this restaurant, it’s definitely one of my all time favorites. It has amazing flatbread pizza with all the gourmet toppings you can think AND they have a few dinner specials that are absolutely delicious. Lastly, everything is fresh, tasty and not overly priced. If you haven’t been here you are missing out.“

“Beautiful grounds, food and wine were amazing. Highly recommend, best of all, the staff were all super nice. Can’t wait to go back.“

“Best Italian food since I left Long Island. The only Pizza place in New Paltz worth the schlep from Rosendale!“

“I absolutely love their Drive- Thru pizza! Fast and cheap and they have the best pizza in town! Always have great specials and their root beer is amazing!!!“

“The Meatball and Sausage and Peppers heroes are delicious, stop by 2-3x a week. Their pizza is also the best in town in my opinion. Some other places are pretty debatable for the best spot, but it is all preference, can’t go wrong with some of the pizza places in New Paltz.Overall, pretty good.“

“I have celiacs disease so I asked if they had a gf pizza, they were so helpful and the pizza was AMAZING!!!

Kid-friendliness: super nice and friendly towards everyone

Dietary restrictions: They were very careful about not cross contaminating my gluten free pizza!“

“We had a casual rehearsal dinner at Pasquales this evening. They arranged the outdoor patio area for 30 people. All the staff were very attentive and helpful. We had very last minute changes and they were very accommodating. The food was delicious. The price was VERY reasonable. I couldn't recommend it more!! 10/10“

“Always the best pizza in New Paltz but also great burgers, amazing Italian dishes, tasty desserts. LaBella is great for family dinner or date night.

Dietary restrictions: Delicious gluten free pizza

Parking: Handicapped spaces and curb cuts for access“

“Went in early September and got to pick some apples, try their ciders and German some food. It is easy to spend an afternoon here with friends and family.

Super kid friendly space and also super pet friendly. There’s so much space to roam around and lounge.

Pizza was great (better than the other food menus) and the price per bag for apple picking wasn’t so bad.“

“I was just back in Marlboro and stopped in Pizza Town for the first time in 20 years. After all this time I was afraid that I simply “romanticized” this pizza from my childhood and beyond. I was NOT disappointed, this is one of the best pizza I have ever had. The crust is a beautiful crispy golden brown and the cheese is glorious. Consistency is rare anywhere in this world and consistent greatness is even harder to find, well this pizza is it folks!!“

“I have never written a review because the delivery person was awesome. But I am drawn to do so today. He is THEE BEST DELIVERY MAN IN THE WORLD! The delivery is always prompt, hot and delivered with a smile. Way professional!

Wheelchair accessibility: Today was delivery, but I happen to know that the restaurant is accessible to persons with mobility issues.“

“We are from California and got in late and hungry. Ordered a marghertti pizza, Hawaiian regular and gluten free. Everything was delicious. They kept doors open after they closed to fix a pizza order for us. Great customer service.
Everything was so good we ate there again the last night of our vacation.“

“We had the buffalo chicken pizza, ham and pepperoni roll, and the ravioli dinner (yum, with mozzarella cheese and sauce on top). All were excellent. We did a pick-up order, and noticed when we got home that the salad was missing that went with the ravioli dinner. We called, and what seemed like only moments after I put down the phone, the doorbell rang with the salad and bread and apologies delivered -- great service!“

“Have ordered here before multiple times, always fab food, large portions and fast delivery! And they have an offer in atm. Would really recommend.“

“Expensive but good food….“

“the food is great there i tried some of the baked ziti and the wings and my family ordered from there half a tray of seafood too of everything it was to die for even thou i cant eat shrimp and lobster“

“"I recently visited this pizza shop and was blown away by both their classic pizza and the Sicilian. Each slice was a perfect blend of crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and gooey cheese. The Sicilian was especially impressive with its thick, pillowy crust that beautifully balanced the rich toppings. It's clear that they use high-quality ingredients. Both pizzas were simply amazing, and I can't recommend this place enough for any pizza enthusiast looking for a delightful culinary experience!"“

“La Roma is an incredible new restaurant in Ulster Park. The new owners are a local family that completely renovated the space. I highly recommend the grandma's specialty pies, but I've had a few dishes and everything has been top notch. Definitely worth the short trip from Kingston.“

“I took my parents out to the Hudson River Walkway and reached the Historic Hamlet. We got a little hungry and found this very cozy place. The food was awesome for like half of what you’d pay in NYC, and all folks there were super nice. Ate too much but we walked back lol.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly. When we were there, there was a table of teenagers eating. Then the owner’s own (I think) grand children came in lol.“

“Perfectly good pizza. My local pizza place. They sometimes send out mailers with coupons to make it more affordable. I am a little spooked that Google just asked me for this review because they noticed I call this place one week ago! I guess I will store the number and dial rather than hit the number provided in a Google search, now that I know they are capturing that particular bit of info. Hello big brother!!!“

“Regular at Pizza Mia, my favorite slot for a slice on a lunch break in Newburgh. Location is convenient and near places to shop. The creative slices are filling, tasty, and the people here care about their end product. Their service is always above and beyond. 100% recommend stopping in and trying a unique slice that catches your eye. You won’t be disappointed!“

“Highly variable quality. We are local and order takeout here several times a month. The pizza quality varies. On a good day, the pizza is fantastic. Other times the pizza is just ok. Stromboli are always excellent, so sometimes we just order those to avoid risking getting an ok pizza. The salads range from great to fair. Most times the greens are very fresh and dry, other times the salads are soggy and slimy. Lately, salads have been more consistently good. Sometimes the person answering the phone is courteous and responsive. Other times they respond in only one syllable words or incomprehensible grunts. Most times I get home to discover my order was filled correctly. Occasionally my order is incorrect, perhaps as a result of variable phone responsiveness/miscommunication. Wings are always great...really great! When ordering fresh, I expect fresh made food and I don’t mind waiting, but the sliders taste like they sat out for a loooong time. Dry, lack flavor, and unsatisfying. I imagine freshly made sliders are excellent.I like Pasquales and will continue to patronize...because Lillos in Walden is no longer an option. Keep up the good work P...Note: Ca$h only.“

“We had never heard of Paesanos until we moved to Modena. We were happy to find out that the pizza is great, garlic knots are the best, extra crispy wings are amazing and the subs are delicious. Also prices are very reasonable. Only complaint is that they only deliver for cash.“

“My wife and I moved from New Paltz to High Falls recently, and this is the best pizza in the area. Where other pizzas lack toppings and are either over or undercooked consistently, Benny’s is always cooked perfectly with delicious dough, crust and plenty of toppings. Their dough is actually the best I’ve ever had anywhere! There’s no reason to go anywhere but here to get delicious pizza and wings (that’s all we’ve tried so far) - and I’m sure their other food is just as great. We usually cook at home and refrain from ordering out much, but we treat ourselves to a pizza from here more often than we should!

Aside from their food being high quality and delicious, this is the kind of business that you want to see where you live. My wife and I work on weekends, and after work yesterday I needed something from the grocery store, Turns out EVERYTHING is closed by 6 on Sunday. As a small business owner myself, I completely understand that people need time in their lives, but with food and groceries we need some options! I desperately went into Benny’s in search of an ingredient as my last hope, and by a miracle I left with exactly what I needed at better quality than I would have found at the grocery store. I assume it was Benny himself who generously helped me out, but either way, this is what small businesses should be. Wonderful at what they do and also holding the local community together in all kinds of unexpected ways! So happy to have them as my local pizzeria, and so happy to support people who care about their community.“

“Wonderful“

“Just enjoyed one of the most delicious meals of my life! We have been hearing about this restaurant for a few years, but tonight was the first time we visited. It won’t be our last. Every detail of the dining experience was absolutely first rate!“

“Delicious food extremely friendly and fast service“

“I don't normally review pizza places. MY GOD. We ordered a Pepperoni pizza, the Toscos Special Pizza, the 3 chicken tacos, and cheesy bread. Each of these was incredible. All of the ingredients seemed so super fresh. The Toscos Specialty was just so fresh and the balsamic vinegarette as sauce was so perfect the whole pizza was just better with each bite. The chicken tacos were just unbelievable. I really have nothing but good things to say. Really the freshness of all the ingredients was the star here. They did a great job. Thank you!“

“I grew up in NYC and during my teenage years in the 60's discovered middle eastern cuisine. It was the choice for "fast & delicious meals" Now my discovery in Rosendale has presented me the delicious opportunity to learn the exceptional cuisine offered at The Garden House. everything I've eaten is mouth watering wonderful. The community of welcomeness is abundant each time you visit. Enjoy a 5 star meal.“

“We recently moved a few houses down from Paulina’s. Since moving in early March we have ordered once to twice a week. We fell in love with everything we have tried from pizza to garlic knots, to wraps, to pasta! Highly recommend, the staff are very friendly.“