50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pleasant Valley

“Warm and friendly place with great Pizza and many other dine in or take out menu options. There's a definite local neighborhood vibe here and the owners and staff make you feel like family. I will be back soon to sample more of that fun “

“I must say coming from Yonkers NY and trying to find a good pizza spot wasnt easy but thankfully we did and this is It!!! Period........ i also catered my daughters graduation party with this spot and EVERYTHING WAS DELISH..... COMING FROM AN ITALIAN HOUSE HOLD ONE BECOMES PICKY AND I GOT TO SAY WITH EMPHASIS THEY ARE GREAT HERE!!!! I HAVE EATEN AT THE SPOT WITH MY HUBBY AND IT WAS GOOD , THE YOUNG LADY KEPT COMING TO US TO MAKE SURE WE WERE GOOD WITH THE FOOD AND DRINKS.. ALL N ALL A GOOD EATS PLACE!!!!“

“Went for pizza. Table service was great. Restaurant is very very clean and atmosphere is nice as well. Young girl, who is our waitress, was extremely personable and attentive. We decided to give this place a try for our pizza because our favorite place has gone downhill considerably. Not disappointed at all will definitely be back. The pizza was very tasty and Hardy. I would just mention that if you like a firm crust, ask them to cook it a little longer. Otherwise perfect. New owner is very nice.“

“It's so difficult because costs are going so crazy, so I can't complain about prices or portion sizes. The one thing that changed, and I don't believe for the better- is when you sat and ordered, you'd get a basket of bread. I know it was a warm split sub roll, but it was really good.The other night we asked for bread- a few times- when it finally arrived it was 2 triangular rolls. I didn't have one, but we were disappointed.There were only 2 waitresses, and no coordination at to who worked where. One should have had one side and the other should have had the other side. Kinda common sense in my book.The food was delicious as always. My one major bone of contention was 2 cooks were not wearing any head covering. One had longish hair, and if I'd found a hair in my food- and seen that? I'd hit the roof. I used to work in food service. Whenever you are near or preparing food you either wear a hairnet or at least a ball cap. Honestly it's a violation. If an inspector saw that? Trouble. Big trouble.“

“Consistently delicious! I purchased a cauliflower crust pizza - it was the absolute best I’ve ever had! It was crispy and full of flavor, evident in the picture attached. Many places fail with the cauliflower crust by letting it get soggy, but not Benny’s! We have previously purchased many different pies - plain, pepperoni, Hawaiian, chicken bacon ranch, buffalo chicken - and all have been absolutely amazing. We have also had their garlic knots, bread sticks and beef patties which are also great every time! Being able to rely on their consistency has been amazing. I will definitely be back for more and recommend to everyone!“

“Nothing like a taste of home. This pizza hits the mark on Detroit style pizza. One of things we’ve been missing since moving to the east coast. We thoroughly enjoyed the pizza here, the service was excellent, and what Detroit pizza place would be complete without Vernor’s. Hudson & Packard has it all.“

“Naples has the BEST pizza and food hands down! The service is great too. I have never had anything but great tasting food from Touch of Naples and I’ve been going there since they opened. Try the salad pizza - it’s amazing! You can’t go wrong with anything you order here.“

“Stopped in after a walk across the Hudson ! What an amazing surprise . The warm welcome, the choices with cocktails and the food are top notch ! Have been looking for a place like this for some time now . Can’t wait to go back . We had the warm olives and we both couldn’t believe how great olives are heated up ! The pizza is absolutely amazing love the crust. The Mac & Cheese was so delicious and comforting omg !! Looking forward to the next time loved it here !“

“I haven’t ordered from TJs in a long time due to my food always being cold when delivered. It hurt because I loveee TJs (esp their cheesecakes, best in Poughkeepsie, better than pastry garden, argue with ya mutha) …. Anyway, I gave TJs another chance last night. Ordered wings (crispy), cheese fries, cheesecake and a large pie (well done)… it was prob one of the first times in a longgg time that my cheese fries didn’t need to be reheated. I put the food inside and chased my delivery driver to give him a bigger tip. I think I was so shocked I forgot to grab my soda from him ? His named was Mark, super nice guy awesome service… the kids and I were so happy. I don’t even write reviews!! If Marks not there I’ll just pick up my order from now on.“

“The pizza was good and I enjoyed it. BUT...I would not sell it as "chopped cheese" it did not taste or remind me of a chopped cheese. Believe me, I was born and raised in the Bronx and know a thing or 2 about chopped cheese. Also, it was a tad shy on the meat(see pic) for the price I paid.“

“Great place. The food is amazing!!! We've eaten here several times and every time the food is outstanding! Their meals and pizzas are delicious and the sushi is fantastic. We had the Spicy Chicken Katsu and Katsu Deluxe the other night, it blew our minds how good it was!! While the bar/restaurant area is very small and gets crowded quickly, they offer a pick up option on the side of the business (this is the way to go).“

“This place is a diamond in the rough! I’ve been going to this plaza for years and it’s hard to believe I just realized recently that this place is awesome. DO NOT SLEEP ON THE CHICKEN & SHRIMP SALAD it’s really good! And the pizza is fire! This place reminds me of pizza places I used to do to as a kid in the city. Wraps and chicken tenders are awesome too!!! AND THEY DELIVER!Kid-friendliness: Brought my 4 kids, there was a handicapped man sitting near us the staff was really cool and accommodating for us and the other familyDietary restrictions: Good place to get really good protein packed salads that last a couple meals. Good for dieting the salads are amazing“

“Dave’s enthusiasm and desire to please was outstanding! Four gray haired sisters, all had delicious meals, one stating that the chicken parm dinner was the best she ever had! Don’t let the physical appearance deter you from trying this place as the food was excellent. Portions were very generous and we enjoyed pizza, 2 chicken parm dinners and 4 salads at an extremely reasonable price!We do not live in the area but would happily return for more of Dave’s delicious food.Parking: No problem parking.“

“You can’t go wrong ordering from Raymee’s.I have ordered a number of different things and I have never been disappointed, their pizza is the best around. Delivery is never a problem and the owner and staff could not be friendlier.I ordered a tray of lasagna recently for a family gathering and my company couldn’t stop raving about how delicious it was and so cheesy.Like the expression, “try it you’ll like it!”. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I discovered Pizzeria Posto about two months ago and I have been faithfully visiting about very two weeks! The art of pizza is executed to perfection. The dough is well balanced with flavor and texture that is just a bit chewy and perfectly crisp. To achieve this is no coincidence and you can see that Postos pizza has been perfected over years of practice. All the various pizzas are all delicious you just need to find your favorite. I learned that the owner grew up in the pizza business and even the cannolis are family recipe for the shells. The focus is on pizza here so if you’re looking for a bar scene and elaborate menu go elsewhere. You go to Pizzeria Posto if you want the very best pizza!“

“I've been here a few times for dinner. It is one of the best Italian restaurants in the area. The food is always very good. The service is excellent. The staff is always polite and friendly. I would definitely recommend eating here if in the area.“

“This is a relaxed family owned and operated local favorite. The owners and their staff always make you feel welcomed and part of their family. The creative menu, weekly specials, and expertly crafted drink specials ensure there's always something interesting for everyone.“

“Today I treated myself to EJ's chicken francaise, which I call the Meggie Cutlets. It was nice, tender, & lemony; delicate, not overpowering. The penne was top notch, though I might have preferred a lighter marinara. Brought home some excellent specialty slices, which I've been ordering for years.“

“So I have had celiac disease for 20 years now and my sister ordered Pizza for our family yesterday. I got a Gluten Free white Pizza with broccoli and it was the best GF pizza I have ever had!!! Can’t wait to visit her again and order pizza?!“

“We had been driving for quite a while and we were too tired to cook so we decided to try Kokopelli's takeout. The Sierra chicken wrap was made with spicy grilled chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo, and melted, fresh mozzarella. It was so moist and delicious with a little bit of a kick. The wrap was stuffed with lots of yummy chicken and I really loved it. The seasoned fries were also great. They were a little cold by the time I got home but I'm betting they're super good hot out of the fryer. I would definitely get this again and it makes me extra happy that it's grilled chicken and not battered and fried. The hubby ordered the Chicken Parmesan with penne pasta, and he thought it was also very good. Two huge pieces of chicken Parmesan with bread, side salad, and penne pasta smothered in sauce was exactly what the doctor ordered to recoup from that long drive. I look forward to trying other things like the wings and the Mexican food. The order was ready by the time I got there and the servers were nice. This is not a fancy place to eat...super casual like a deli but with limited seating.“

“Cute little place for a good Italian meal. We had the shrimp fra diavlo and eggplant and veal parm dinners. Excellent!! It came with a salad. Good bread. Good service. Good prices. Attentive owner. Busy place but not loud. For sure to return soon. Don’t let the unassuming exterior fool you. Definitely give it a try.“

“Hey, what can I say it’s a must stop when I want some good pizza I head Poughkeepsie to Emiliano’s! Slices are big cheese is full of flavor sauce is perfect and they always reheat it the right way! My personal favorite is the broccoli rabe ! It’s definitely one of my top 10 pizza places I’ve ever eaten out of 100s definitely stop in and try it five golden forks @travelingforkBigAng“

“I don't live in the Poughkeepsie area anymore,, but I still think about this place.And it's the first thing that I look forward to when I come back.Wheelchair accessibility: It's easily accessible to handicapped people also.“

“Staff and food are outstanding!The menu is updated regularly and seasonally, so there are new things to try.Cocktails are as good as they get!If weather permits, the patio is an excellent place for a meal and company.I highly recommend trying this place when you're in the area.“

“Phenomenal food, accompanied with phenomenal service. Truly an excellent meal, with each dish given such thought and detail by the chef. The whipped ricotta with the fresh bread is a must try, as are the broccoli raab stuffed meatballs! Scallops and steak were both cooked to perfection. I could go on and on, but just go try for yourself. I can’t wait to go back.“

“Initially disappointed that this student/public dining hall didn't have as many exotic goodies at the ready as a bustling NYC upscale food hall, I stumbled upon one of the most well-balanced Italian combo sandwiches I've ever had. Decent corn chowder helped temper the saltiness of the cured meats.“

“Vera’s Pizza truly sets the bar high, offering arguably the best pizza experience one can find. Not only are their prices astonishingly fair, but they also bring a wave of nostalgia, reminiscent of those cherished pizza parlors from my childhood. Every bite feels like a journey back in time, combining classic flavors with impeccable quality. Highly recommend to anyone looking to relive those golden days or to simply enjoy an exceptional pizza at an unbeatable price!“

“REALLY GOOD pizza and service. It is cheap and tastes AMAZING. They aren't always open when it says they should but it is family owned and they have kids. Tastes way better than the other pizza places around here. Really good people and totally recommend here, you'll love it!“

“Been here a good amount of times this year. Their clams casino pie is delicious. I've also been digging their calzones alot too latley. The family that owns it are very nice and friendly. It's a nice local buisness that I would recommend to everyone. Give them a try next time you are craving Pizza/Italian food !“

“Food: 4.75 Ambiance: 4 Service: 4 The pizza is amazing! Thin crust, crispy, great flavor. 5/5! My husband got the Sabrina sandwich which was off the hook.. Crispy fresh bread, thin chicken cutlets, pesto, balsamic.. *chef's kiss*. Where I went wrong was in ordering the Thai chichen salad. I knew better, but I was in the mood for some fresh greens. Well... The "salad" was 75% noodles and heavily covered in dressing. Stick with the Italian food here, as the name suggests, and you will be happy! The place looks gorgeous on the outside. In the inside, the decor is nice and sophisticated. Deceivingly to the outside, it's got more of a dressed up bar vibe than I expected. The service was friendly and did all things right, though they seemed a bit distracted. I never knew the makers of planet wings could make such great food! I'll definitely be back.“

“This place deserves 5 stars. The staff is super friendly and the food is amazing. They serve mouthwatering authentic Mexican dishes. Their aguas frescas and atole drinks are superb as well. I highly recommend this place, you will not regret it.Starter Suggestions:Agua de Jamaica (hibiscus juice)Horchata (sweet rice milk beverage)Atole - Champurrado (like hot chocolate)Tacos (not the Tex-MEX)Sopes (great breakfast item)Tostadas (crispy corn tortilla with toppings)Tortas (Mexican style sandwich)Tlayudas (Mexican version of a pizza, if you will)Milanesa de pollo (chicken cutlet)“

“So glad brennies is back. The food is amazing .cheese steak sub ,stromboli,salad all awesome perfectly made .when they first opened back up had meat lovers pizza and garlic Parm wings they were the best perfect crispness and sauce was so good won't order from anyone else welcome back guys.“

“I love this place. They have great food and the workers truly go above and beyond to provide great service. I am so excited to order more dishes from this place. They have amazing dishes outside of pizza -- their sandwiches are absolutely divine in my honest opinion-- but their plethora of pizza toppings is truly what makes them stand out as one of the best pizza places in this area.“

“Hidden gem of a restaurant with old school Italian, Pizza and Portuguese food. Everything is made fresh to order. On site bakery with delicious pastries (make sure you call ahead for something specific). I'll definitely be back to dine in person. The owners are very nice people.“

“Country Corners is the perfect place for a quick stop for necessities, awesome breakfast pizza, gourmet pizzas, and a huge array of sandwiches. We recently discovered their catering and WOW! The subs were the best we’ve had. The Italian dish was fresh and delicious. Prices were great, too!!“

“So in love with this place!!! Had a wonderful meal with my husband. The Penne a la Vodka was delicious!! I asked for extra sauce though ...and the Tufruto Ice cream was not too sweet so delicious ,I tasted toasted coconuts on the vanilla side and cherry on the dark chocolate side.. highly recommend that dessert in the pic . Going there again!!! Service amazing also!!!!“

“Ordered online a Classic Pizza with extra sauce and ham.Sooooo good....they are not sparse on the items that top the pizza ...thats for sure. Great pizza....you have a regular customer now and joined the rewards program.Keep up the great work...ty.“

“I have been going here since I was a child, it was the best night when we used to go. We’ve had family reunions and weddings here. The food is amazing, we went regularly like 20 years ago but they knew my family and order. 4 salads and a large pizza. I love this place so much.“

“Great food, great service, great local New York atmosphere. Gluten free options if that is your thing. Strombolis, New York pizza and Sicilian pizza were part of the menu. Good select of great tasting unique brews. German beer. Highly recommend.“

“Got the spinach roll, chicken parm sandwhich, and cheesesteak sandwhich. Ate the spinach roll it was great tried the others and awesome too. Eating them tomorrow. My delivery was much further than they go but brought it out anyway. Very nice on the phone. If im lucky maybe they come out again or ill go out there lol because one of the best around. I think these rolls are homeade or something because they have that look to them. Thank you again the woman was very sweet i forgot your name sorry lol.“

“I ordered one of the Wednesday specials. It was a half tray of eggplant parm with a half tray of pasta, half tray of tossed salad and home made dinner rolls. It was delicious! There were 4 of us and there was plenty of food. What a great deal! I'll be ordering again real soon!“

“Came up to headless horseman and needed a bit to eat. Got slices for everyone and they where great. Super nice under carriage for a thin round pie. Cheese and sauce was top notch. Love pizza and that was a 9.3 rating. The counter people where nice and super quick. Place was packed and seemed well maintained. Will definitely recommend“

“My family and I have been ordering pizza and other meals from TnF for 12+ years , For our daughter's birthday we ordered a large order to delivered at a certain time.Without fail the driver showed up exactly on time, Everything was delicious and the entire order was enjoyed by our family and friends!!“

“We get their food about twice a week. Everything is SO good. Tonight I had the vegetarian hero-excellent! Their sausage is yummy, fettuccine Alfredo is a fave and the brick oven pizza is awesome. Their homemade balsamic dressing alone is worth the trip. VERY nice staff!“

“Giving 5 starts to support a local business even though I’ve never personally tried it. To be honest, every time we wanted to get a pizza from them they were already closed lol. perhaps consider staying open after 7/8pm? We’re sure not the only people who sometime eat dinner at 8:30 or 9:)“

“A fairly new pizza business opened at the Salt Point Market and Cafe, which replaced Pleasant Valley Pizza (which sadly didn't have its own Yelp page). Their main go-to is their pizzas, which include slices with a variety of topics along with whole pies to eat in or take out. Other dishes besides pizzas are provided on the brochure, including sandwiches, pasta, chicken, soups, salads, etc. Tables are provided inside and outside for the confidence of those. The pizzas are big and a little bit on the thick side, which isn't that bad, but can leave a mess. I personally enjoyed it, and can't wait to explore the other choices, which I'm sure Margherita is famous for, hence the name.We were thrilled with the service, as two of the men did their part, and even had a small conversation as well. All of the best for Pizza Margherita!“

“This place is fine. The food and prizes are. Questionable, but the actual games are fine.Vegetarian options: Salad bar?Parking: There was a spot. How else would I leave a reviewKid-friendliness: It's for kids and advertised by kids. YAYWheelchair accessibility: There is a way for wheelchairs to get on the sidewalk. A Ramp.“

“Giacomo's pizza is a good restaurant for Italian food. It truly thrives as a great place to get fresh pizza. I've never once had a old slice from here. It seems like they constantly make fresh pies. And if its a slow day, they don't keep the old pizza sitting behind glass for hours just for customers to glance at and ultimately pass. This is smart. I feel like more pizza places should do this. Throw out old slices that didn't sell during lunch and make a fresh pie that we can all gawk at. It makes a huge difference.“

“I'm on the fence, I've had awful lasagna (brick of mush and sauce) and the most amazing Alfredo. I've found dishes I really like and stick with them. I do really like their grandma pizza. Best to call in your orders rather than go online. They are nice people all in all.“