15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Millbrook

JULIEN’S Pizza Takeaway • $$
5 Washington Ave, Millbrook

Customers` Favorites

Salmon Poke Bowl
Caprese
Pig

“Great place. The food is amazing!!! We've eaten here several times and every time the food is outstanding! Their meals and pizzas are delicious and the sushi is fantastic. We had the Spicy Chicken Katsu and Katsu Deluxe the other night, it blew our minds how good it was!! While the bar/restaurant area is very small and gets crowded quickly, they offer a pick up option on the side of the business (this is the way to go).“

4.7 Superb37 Reviews
Barbaro Italian • $$$
3279 Franklin Ave, Millbrook

Customers` Favorites

Baked Marinated Olives
Pan Fried Cod Special
Wood Roasted Beets
Chicken Parmigiana
Pistachio Gremolata
Shishito Peppers
Chicken Paillard
Margherita Pizza
Seafood Marinara
Grilled Octopus

“Staff and food are outstanding!The menu is updated regularly and seasonally, so there are new things to try.Cocktails are as good as they get!If weather permits, the patio is an excellent place for a meal and company.I highly recommend trying this place when you're in the area.“

4.2 Good44 Reviews
Cousins Woodfire Pizza Cafe Bakery • $$
1706 1726, State Rte 55, Wingdale - 11.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich

“Why are there two businesses named Cousins within 1 minute drive from each other that aren't affiliated? This is massively confusing and can't be good for business. Only been here once and shelves were kinda bare. Sandwich wasn't terrible. I'd go here again mainly to support the local businesses.“

4.5 Superb47 Reviews
Madison's Pizza & Catering Pizza • $
17 North Ave, Pleasant Valley - 7.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
The Madison Salad
Buffalo Chicken
Includes Salad
Stuffed Pizza
Chicken Caesar
Garlic Bread
Garlic Knots
Vodka Sauce
Meatball

“Warm and friendly place with great Pizza and many other dine in or take out menu options. There's a definite local neighborhood vibe here and the owners and staff make you feel like family. I will be back soon to sample more of that fun “

4.5 Superb44 Reviews
Pomodoro Pizza Cafe Italian • $
3 Maggiacomo Ln, Pleasant Valley - 7.27 miles

Customers` Favorites

Calamari Fra Diavolo Pasta
Veggie Primavera Pasta
Pepperoni Pinwheel
Pasta Carbonara
The Italiana

“Went for pizza. Table service was great. Restaurant is very very clean and atmosphere is nice as well. Young girl, who is our waitress, was extremely personable and attentive. We decided to give this place a try for our pizza because our favorite place has gone downhill considerably. Not disappointed at all will definitely be back. The pizza was very tasty and Hardy. I would just mention that if you like a firm crust, ask them to cook it a little longer. Otherwise perfect. New owner is very nice.“

4.4 Superb53 Reviews
The Lantern Pizza • $
10 Main St, Wassaic - 7.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sesame Honey Sriracha Wings
Rattlesnake Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Green Lantern
Heart Throb
Norma Jean

“I experienced wonderful moments at this place over the course of a month. I used to come to this establishment in the evening to relax after a demanding day spent at the art residency. Amazing people, fantastic food, excellent beer. I hope to return there someday and reconnect with the 'old' friends. Wishing Lantern lots of relaxed evenings. Paul from Czech republic ;-*“

4.4 Superb30 Reviews
Santo Pizzeria & Ristorante Pizza • $
5094 NY-22, Amenia - 8.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Jalapeno Poppers with Sauce
Italian Flag Grandma Pizza
Italian Stuffed Pizza
Grandma Pizza Slice
Chicken Wings

“Stopped in to have a slice when I was grocery shopping. The pizza was really good! Definitely glad I stopped in, will definitely be returning to this pizzeria in the near future.That even let us, at North East Ford, put up our display featuring our $2 inspection sticker coupons. Thank you“

4.4 Superb22 Reviews
Four Brothers Pizza Inn Pizza • $$
1890 US-44, Pleasant Valley - 5.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Greek Salad with Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Meat Lovers
Alla Vodka
Baked Ziti
Carbonara
Meatball

“It's so difficult because costs are going so crazy, so I can't complain about prices or portion sizes. The one thing that changed, and I don't believe for the better- is when you sat and ordered, you'd get a basket of bread. I know it was a warm split sub roll, but it was really good.The other night we asked for bread- a few times- when it finally arrived it was 2 triangular rolls. I didn't have one, but we were disappointed.There were only 2 waitresses, and no coordination at to who worked where. One should have had one side and the other should have had the other side. Kinda common sense in my book.The food was delicious as always. My one major bone of contention was 2 cooks were not wearing any head covering. One had longish hair, and if I'd found a hair in my food- and seen that? I'd hit the roof. I used to work in food service. Whenever you are near or preparing food you either wear a hairnet or at least a ball cap. Honestly it's a violation. If an inspector saw that? Trouble. Big trouble.“

4.1 Good50 Reviews
Il Cuore Pizza NY-82, Stanfordville, NY 12581, United States Pizza •
6090 NY-82, Stanfordville - 5.95 miles

“Giving 5 starts to support a local business even though I’ve never personally tried it. To be honest, every time we wanted to get a pizza from them they were already closed lol. perhaps consider staying open after 7/8pm? We’re sure not the only people who sometime eat dinner at 8:30 or 9:)“

4 Good15 Reviews
PIZZA MARGHERITA SALT POINT Pizza • $$
2517 US-44, Salt Point - 3.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Pan Cheese Pizza

“A fairly new pizza business opened at the Salt Point Market and Cafe, which replaced Pleasant Valley Pizza (which sadly didn't have its own Yelp page). Their main go-to is their pizzas, which include slices with a variety of topics along with whole pies to eat in or take out. Other dishes besides pizzas are provided on the brochure, including sandwiches, pasta, chicken, soups, salads, etc. Tables are provided inside and outside for the confidence of those. The pizzas are big and a little bit on the thick side, which isn't that bad, but can leave a mess. I personally enjoyed it, and can't wait to explore the other choices, which I'm sure Margherita is famous for, hence the name.We were thrilled with the service, as two of the men did their part, and even had a small conversation as well. All of the best for Pizza Margherita!“

4 Good9 Reviews
Four Brothers Pizza Inn Pizza • $$
4957 NY-22, Amenia - 8.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salad Additions
Alla Vodka
Wraps

“Very unexpected. There is a sign in the small building that is called "the grand shack" we wanted to go to the 4 brothers pizza inn, but TBH we could tell if it was open. The snack shack, which I guess is attached to the drive, it was great! I had a great burger, good price. Nice service. Very nice outdoor seating area. A bit quirky.“

3.9 Good46 Reviews
Four Brothers Pizza Inn Pizza • $$
3189 NY-22, Dover Plains - 6.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Old Fashioned Burger
Chicken Casserole
Famous Greek Salad
Traditional Gyro
Crispy Chicken
Fried Chicken

“My family and I love this place. Their pizza is SO delicious and they have a crispy chicken wrap that is the only thing I want to eat while I’m currently pregnant. My husband tried their wrap with greek dressing tonight and the dressing was AMAZING. The people who work there are always so nice. I am shocked there are any negative reviews. Can’t wait to come back soon! ??“

3.8 Good40 Reviews
Benny's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
18 W Rd, Pleasant Valley - 7.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Pepper Roll
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Wings 12
Grilled Chicken
Caesar Salad
Garlic Knots
Meat Calzone

“I'm happy I found this place! Delicious NYC style pizza! We have been ordering the regular cheese pizza but will definitely try the other options there as well in the future. The service is always super friendly and attentive. The location is very central but a little hidden from the main road (jusy around the corner from it) so I found out about this place after someone recommended it. Thank you Benny's!!“

3.8 Good48 Reviews
Fratellos Gourmet Pizza & Cafe Pizza • $
1097 State Rte 55, Lagrangeville - 9.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
White Pizza

“This was our first time eating at Fratello's and it was absolutely delicious!! With so many selections of gourmet toppings on the slices, it was hard to choose so we had 4 different kinds. The service was top notch and the atmosphere very friendly. We live in Red Hook and come out once a week to the area so this will now be a weekly stop. Thank you!!“

3.7 Good23 Reviews
Cousin's Pizza Pizza • $
1815 NY-22, Wingdale - 11.56 miles

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Greek Salad
Meatball

“Good Pizza, Good Camp Fries, Good BBQ Wings. Just Baffled they don't travel 10 minutes to Dover.I did get a little frustrated a couple months ago, when the owner or manager said it doesn't take 10 minutes to go to Dover, as if I was lying.I guess in words of My Cousin Vinny, no pun intended, "the laws of physics must cease to exist in his vehicle". Or Google is lying. Either or, he was wrong!I just feel bad for there delivery driver, and Cousins Pizza. More people would order from them, because the pizza in Dover is Cheeks.?‍♂️Just saying.“

3.6 Good23 Reviews
Loading...
map Map