Restaurants near Millbrook

“House of Stefas — A True Treasure in Millbrook
House of Stefas has to be one of the best new restaurants to join the culinary Hall of Fame. Without question, it is one of the finest restaurants to open in a very long time.
They take innovation, creativity, and culinary artistry to an entirely new level. The food is nothing short of fantastic.
The ever-wonderful Melinda and Kevin, behind the bar, make the best martini with a sidecar—the ultimate cocktail! And, of course, there's the Big Guy, Babis, running the front of the house with his irresistible charm, warmth, and impeccable attention to detail. He never misses a beat.
It's this extraordinary team of personalities and talents that makes a truly great restaurant.
And then there are John and Paul—two of the hardest-working restaurant owners I've seen in a very long time. They greet their guests, oversee every detail of the dining room, and somehow manage to run back into the kitchen to prepare these incredible meals—or even wash the dishes when necessary! All the while, they never lose those enormous, welcoming smiles that make everyone who walks through the door feel like family.
What an absolute treasure to have here in Millbrook.
House of Stefas has become my home away from home. I never miss an opportunity to spend time with these wonderful guys, enjoying not only their extraordinary food but also the genuine warmth and spirit they bring to everything they do.
There is something very special about a restaurant where the passion is as authentic as the people behind it.
House of Stefas is exactly that—a genuine love affair with the culinary experience. And Millbrook is incredibly fortunate to have them.
Thank you,
Ford Wallace”

“First time here, for my birthday. It was amazing. From start to finish. The atmosphere, service, food, two thumbs up. Beautiful place with delicious food and friendly staff. Will be back for sure!”

“Unplanned stop ... did not disppoint👍👍👍”

“Very considerate owner. She mixed up our pick up order and drove to Amenia with our order. Food was great and we will go back”

“My husband and I stopped by for a coffee on our way home. The little coffee hut is cute and easy to find. We, apparently, beat the rush as quite the line formed behind us. I got a strawberry oat milk latte and my husband got a whole milk caramel latte.

All I can say is that I wish I lived closer. The drinks were smooth, just the right amount of sweet and might be in my top 3 of all time.

If you're ever in the area, give this little gem a try!”

“Food is amazing. Cute small restaurant. Food is cooked in a wood fired oven. Make sure you have reservations. This was a great find. We get food from there weekly. One of our absolute favorite restaurants.”

“I was referred by my co worker, and this is definitely my new spot! I tried the burger, hot dog and potato salad. My husband enjoyed the hot dog with the works. I can't pick just one to compliment because it was all so well done and delicious. Today had the fish, and boy, I'm still thinking about that fish. Tell a friend, it's worth it for the buck too 🤩”

“The food at Juliens is ALWAYS over the top fresh and delicious !! The arugula fig and prosciutto pizza is amazing! The sushi is so fresh and flavorful! Great place!”

“Took my in-laws out for dinner tonight. Two of us had the Beef Stroganoff.. and two of us had the filet mignon. The food was absolutely delicious, made to perfection, and food prices were fair ! ZERO complaints on the food... But now the bill comes. $14 (x7) for a shot of Don Julio Tequila? I almost fell over. That's simply ridiculous! Every bar/restaurant within a 50 mile radius gets $6-$7 per shot MAX! We're not in NYC .... I learned a valuable lesson tonight..... IF we return to Noochs for dinner, I'll drink water with a splash of lemon....”

“We had an absolutely wonderful birthday dinner here! Everything was delicious, beautifully presented, and the atmosphere made our celebration feel truly special.

The duck salad was unforgettable — honestly one of the most unique and delicious dishes we’ve ever had. Perfectly prepared and full of flavor!

The service was warm and attentive, and the entire evening was simply wonderful. Thank you for making this birthday celebration so memorable. We will definitely be back!”

“Great food and excellent!!! service ~ Thankyou!!!”

“First time there today.. Birria Empanadas were excellent! Chef’s Kiss 😚”

“My best friend, her daughter and I stopped here for a late-ish breakfast today on our way back to Putnam County this morning. We had never been before and this came up while searching for a breakfast spot. Jeanie Bean's certainly lived up to the charming name! Sweet place, really nice, helpful staff. Our order was pancakes, chicken tenders (no, actually cutlets!!) with really great well done fries, and a BLTurkey which I requested on rye. I didn't ask but I am pretty sure that Rye was homemade. Very fresh and thick cut. Many other homemade baked goods blessed the counter, which we sadly didn't try. The teenager drank a monster energy drink while us adults split a can of Arizona iced tea. There is a little set up to help yourselves to silverware/napkins, salt/pep, sauces/ketchup and there are a couple beverage coolers with several options. There is a little coffee bar area and although I didn't get a good look I'm sure there was the option for hot tea as well. I am not quite sure where the int'l inspo comes from (perhaps the family has a British background?) but there are some interesting English teas/treats in the little gift shop area near the front half of the store. Seemed like there were some handmade things, and many cute gifts. The teen and I played a couple rounds on the little wooden tic tac toe game that was on the table. The food was great, atmosphere was fun and friendly. You order up front, grab your table and they call your name and bring out your order. 10/10 would recommend if you happen to be up in the Country! Oh, p.s. there is also an English inspired phone box outside labeled the BOOK BOX full of books to grab / exchange!”

“So happy its “Tis the season””

“Absolutely amazing quality. And the service is impeccable; always. Every time. I’ve been patronizing this restaurant for about one year now on a regular basis and I’ve not had a bad experience yet. Highly recommend!”

“Wonderful restaurant. The food is great and the hospitality is always great.”

“Hubby, 2 grandsons & I had another wonderful, delicious breakfast this morning. Everyone is so friendly, especially with the kids & the food is always delicious. Grandsons were so happy to see 6 airplanes (yes, they counted-lol). Thank you all. See you soon.”

“Breakfast was good this morning. Recommend adding the egg platter to menu. And other choices like pancakes. Also, breakfast potatoes make sense. We’ll be back!”

“Anytime we have houseguests, I make the 30 minute drive to Vitsky. The sourdough bread is so delicious and all of the pastries make me drool just thinking about them. Service is quick and friendly. Can't say enough good things about this hidden gem!”

“The employees at this locations are friendly, polite, and welcoming. The atmosphere is very clean, relaxed, and there are lots of seating options. The menu is HUGE, but the employees let me know that I could sample some things if I was having trouble deciding. I was going to get a smoothie, but I ended up trying a Tropical bowl. It was delicious. I will definitely be back for more!”

“Excellent Ice Cream and Milkshakes but got to get there like 10 mins before they close machines down for a milkshake if you want it. But they will serve you ice cream til last minute of closing”

“Stopped in after driving by because there was not much else in the area we wanted to eat. Dont let this place fool youby beaing attached to a gas station. We had a pleasant surprise! The staff was friendly and the food was super fresh. We just ordered a few appetizers. The chicken wings were so hot when they came out , crispy yet still juicy. We also got the mozzarella sticks which are homemade. The chicken nachos and the garlic parm pretzel were so good also. We will def be back to try some of the meals 😋”

“Just had the most amazing salad! Romana Salad with grilled chicken and balsamic dressing. So good!!!!”

“Delicious creamy pesto chicken with sun dried tomatoes. Large portions and friendly staff. Exceeded my expectations. Also unexpectedly came with fresh garlic knots that were good too. Wife ordered chicken parm which she like too but said the sauce could have used seasoning and tasted like straight tomato sauce.”

“Tlahco Taqueria Pleasant Valley has some really delicious tacos made with fresh ingredients and well-seasoned meat. The soft tortillas, flavorful salsas, and fresh toppings make every bite so good, especially the mango salsa. The service was quick and friendly too. Definitely a great spot for authentic Mexican food!”

“Never disappointed. Fresh and delish every time.”

“Delicious food and lovely owners! I have ordered lunch and dinner as well as catered meals for my staff of 60+ employees. The food is always incredible!”

“This place was amazing. An upscale diner, but a real diner with diner food.. I look forward to going back. I had just gotten back from a cruise so I also got a turkey dinner to go home with. And I had a hamburger there. Absolutely delicious everything.”

“Fireside catered our daughter’s wedding with a BBQ buffet & it was perfect! Food arrived hot & fresh & our servers were very professional. I have been to weddings where they have run out of food-definitely NOT the case with Fireside! Generous portions & we even had leftovers. Highly recommend!”

“We had no idea we were going to someplace so fancy when we navigated here along our road trip. The food is exceptional, and they accommodate many dietary restrictions”