29 Best Ice Cream Shops near New Windsor

“3 young kids working, we showed up 6 of us as they were closing and they were so sweet and still served us. As someone who works in the food service industry I know how inconvenient and even frustrating that can be at times. But their smiles were genuine. They even served 2 more people that showed up after us. Great service“

“Thanks for “Topping” off our Easter celebration!“

“The best place for ice cream and crepes. The owner and his family are amazing“

“Great ice cream and desserts“

“Good Ice Cream after a hot day at Memorial Field“

“Michael Weir, Kevin and the rest of the staff at Weir's Ice Cream are AWESOME! They went way above and beyond to help me with a special order. Thank you all and please never stop making the best ice cream ever!“

“Great Sorbet, Vegan Ice Cream, Large Variety of Gourmet Ice Cream. Bubble Tea and Espresso Bar. Great Place for a sweet treat!“

“I took my almost 3 year old here with a group of his friends. He's allergic to dairy and egg, so I figured he'd have to go without. But I was pleasantly surprised to see they have dairy free ice cream! The owner even offered to bring out the container for me to read to ingredients, just to be sure. He usually gets left out when it comes to treats with friends. He was so excited to get ice cream like everyone else! Fantastic service and delicious ice cream.“

“The staff were super thoughtful and accommodating of my peanut and nut allergies — they scooped my ice cream with a clean scooper from an unopened tub to avoid cross-contamination. I usually avoid hard ice cream because of the allergy risk so I deeply appreciate the effort they took to make it safe for me! I had the chocolate fudge brownie and it was delicious.“

“Such a nice local ice cream shop! Loved the variety on the menu and they even had a frozen dog treats. Flavors and quality of the ice cream are great. Today I had a coconut Kit Kat that was excellent but they also had some vegan/nondairy options that looked tasty. The outdoor area is nice to sit at and dog-friendly. Also appreciate that this is woman and LGBTQ+ owned.“

“Ordered takeout via seamless 2x. Both times worked out well.
Food delicious and comforting.

First time I had the Jerk Chicken and it was bit dry but it was so well-seasoned. I also got a side of Mac and cheese which was very good too. However, the star of the show was the beef patty in coco bread. So good!

The second time, I got the stew chicken and it did not disappoint either.

Definitely going to order again to try more things (Ox Tails, Salt Fish, etc.)“

“Friendly staff. Made me the new rainbow cookie shake and it’s a 10/10.“

“Love this place! The homemade ice cream is so delicious, and the staff rocks. 🩷“

“ITS ALL JUST SO AMAZING! THEY GIVE OUT SUCH BIG SIZES OF ICE CREAM FOR SUCH AND AFFORDABLE PRICE!“

“My kids love toppings and the girls that work here are always super helpful, overall is a great environment for all family very clean and organized has a customer restroom as well.“

“The employees are very welcoming and friendly. I wish they would have a wider variety of flavors, but it doesn't matter because I love my regular flavor chocolate cake batter! I appreciate that they are conscious of cross contamination with nuts and when informed, they take care of you. Kudos 👏“

“This place is adorable. The people who work there are so nice and the food is delicious! We tried the boba teas, milkshakes and elote loco and loved everything. Can’t wait to go back“

“Best time in forever!! ~Maggie (6)“

“Wonderful ice cream cake!! we ordered for a birthday party, it turned out very nice. Everyone loved it. Mr. Frank is a wonderful person to work with. thank you very much, Frank and team!!“

“After a grueling hike, a cold and refreshing treat is exactly what my friends and I needed! Bozerinos offer various treats: ice cream; soft serve; Italian ice; and milkshakes!

We tried the Lil Blue Panda, which seems to be a mix of cookies-and-cream with another flavor. It was very good and not too sweet.

If you are craving something sweet though, definitely try the Salted Caramel Brownie or the Deep Crunch Apple Pie (I may have spelt this flavor wrong, but if you go, you can probably figure out which Apple Pie flavor I am talking about). Both are guarantee to satisfy any sweet tooth that customers may have.

Of course, you can go for the classical flavors they have there: Birthday Cake; Chocolate Mint Chip; Rocky Road; and many more. Please note it is cash only!“

“Lots of flavors to try, good ice cream and games to occupy the children. Nice quiet Main Street to sit outside.“

“Awesome!!“

“I went to that place I loved the service and the food was very delicious I recommend it“

“I literally can't recommend this place enough! we stayed in cold spring for 4 nights and got food here everyday haha! we tried pretty much everything and EVERYTHING was delicious! freshly cooked, with love! the staff are super friendly and welcoming too. absolutely 5 stars!“

“Very nice ice cream and nice staff ♡“

“Haven't tried the pie yet but got a chocolate pecan pie. The service was warm and knowledgeable and one of the staff was talking about SWEET POTATO PECAN PIE!!

I have to give them props just for that. Park in the back and walk in the door to the right of the one that says 135 &137.“

“The very best treats with such variety to explore! And, so many selections for vegan folks, too!!“

“Was impressed with the quality of danishes, been here a couple weeks in a row, and they seem to be on top of things, so far its been very consistent.“

“Quick drive through service. great food, friendly employees.“