$1.50 Fresh Pizza

Name: $1.50 Fresh Pizza
Address: 143 W 40th St, New York, New York, 10018, US
Telephone: (212) 366-5550
Price range: $
Rating: 4.2

$ • Pizza, Vegetarian

Hours:
143 W 40th St, New York
(212) 366-5550

Menu Order Online

About $1.50 Fresh Pizza

$1.50 Fresh Pizza is a popular and highly recommended spot for quick, affordable, and tasty pizza in the heart of NYC. Despite the modest price, the quality of the pizza remains impressive, with flavorful toppings, crispy crust, and textured centers. Many reviewers mention that the slices are now generously sauced, making them even more satisfying. The pizza is served hot and fresh, and the place offers a fast, in-and-out experience, often with no wait or just a short line, especially on busy evenings.

The menu includes classic options like cheese, pepperoni, and BBQ chicken slices, all at unbeatable prices—sometimes as low as $1.50 per slice, or a couple of slices plus a coke for under $8. Customers appreciate the flavor and freshness, often comparing it favorably to other well-known NYC pizza places. The location is convenient, situated just around the corner from Joe’s Pizza, under scaffolding on 40th street between 7th Ave and Broadway, near Times Square. There are benches inside for eating slices comfortably before heading back out to explore.

While the inside space is limited, and some concerns about hygiene are noted, overall, the reviews highlight the place as a reliable, good-quality pizza option for visitors seeking a quick, budget-friendly bite. Many plan to return for the great taste and value.