I don’t mean to be too negative but I just don’t get the current 4.9 rating. The staff and atmosphere is nice. The food both pasta and pizza are just average. We were disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Arianna
Great pasta, great service, took me without a reservation around 530pm on a Friday. And had a great ambience inside.Loved the fettuccine bolognese. And especially loved the wait staff. Very polite and fast.
Ezequiel Luis Menichelli
great place to spend some time with friends in a beautiful part of East Villa, good pizza and great homemade pastas. I will definitely come
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tartufo Pizza, Gnocchi
Grace P.
Would give a 4.5 if I could. Really the only downside is that my group was a bit crowded at our table, we were a group of 5 and seated at a table for 4 which was a bit squished with plates, jackets, and especially as tables around us filled up. The more important part - the food! We shared the penne alla vodka and ravioli and the margarita and the 4 formaggi pizzas. The margarita pizza was your classic good pizza, and the penne vodka was very good as well. The ravioli was my personal favorite, the balsamic drizzle on top really makes the dish. It's been a few weeks since we ate here and I've still been wanting to go back to get it again. Overall would recommend, if you're going at a busy time it's definitely worth making a reservation as it will fill up. A great place to get food before going out, the combination we ordered was perfect (in my opinion) to not be hungry throughout the night but not feel too full.
Brian T.
Tartufo Pizza is OMG delicious. As good as any we have had in Italy. All homemade everything here. Owner Niko has been making pizza for 20 years and it shows! Bravo, hidden gem at St. Marks & Ave A. So good we decided to order the Fettuccine Bolognese and just take leftovers home. So how was the pasta you ask? Don't bother. Breaks the ten out of ten scale! We rarely review but you can't go wrong here.
Jessica Ventura
Amazing food! Best steak gnocchi I have ever tried! Service is great, the ambiance is very chilled. The pomegranate spritz is 100% great! The chef amazing! Definitely will be coming back I recommend you to come here. Oh and let me not forget to mention the Nutella pizza and tiramisu!!
Loved this spot! Highly recommend for a large group dinner - there is a $70 pre-fixe with unlimited wine and beer or $85 one that includes aperol spritzThe music is fun and the atmosphere is super lively! The service was great and the food is delicious. Pre-fixe includes 2 apps, a salad, 2 pizzas & 2 pastas. GF options available as well
It's a decent pizza/pasta spot. The best is the pesto because they use a very fresh pesto and heavily slather it on the pizza. The other pizza was good too. The dough was not the classic neoplotan style pizza and no charred taste but the pizza didn't a huge "flop" factor which was good. The Arrabbiata pasta was average, the sauce was good but Arrabbiata isn't traditionally a challenging sauce to perfect and the pasta itself was giving barilla.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Shubhi M.
It's a decent pizza/pasta spot. The best is the pesto because they use a very fresh pesto and heavily slather it on the pizza. The other pizza was good too. The dough was not the classic neoplotan style pizza and no charred taste but the pizza didn't a huge "flop" factor which was good. The Arrabbiata pasta was average, the sauce was good but Arrabbiata isn't traditionally a challenging sauce to perfect and the pasta itself was giving barilla. Service and ambiance were good
Arlind Komoni
Great food and excellent service. We'll be back soon.
They have nice prices for happy hour. However the food was ehh. I don't think I would come again. You can get much better pizza elsewhere. Also the place is small and cramp.
Wenley M.
Waiters were friendly and attentive. Happy hour deals (food and drink) were worth it. I split one HH pasta and one HH pizza with my friend and it filled us up. The food came out really quickly too. The restaurant is great for friends to get together.
A K
Great food and excellent service. We'll be back soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lee Danilek
Arrived on time for reservation. Had to wait 20min to be seated outside in winter. They said we couldn't order pizza, but we saw pizzas being served to others. Pasta took 1h15m to arrive. Pasta tasty, free
Best pregame spot in St. Marks. Amazing happy hour, amazing food, and amazing service. Last time I went, our waiter was very attentive-- we hadn't even finished our glasses of wine, and he was already giving us another glass without us asking too. 10000/10
I don’t mean to be too negative but I just don’t get the current 4.9 rating. The staff and atmosphere is nice. The food both pasta and pizza are just average. We were disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great pasta, great service, took me without a reservation around 530pm on a Friday. And had a great ambience inside.Loved the fettuccine bolognese. And especially loved the wait staff. Very polite and fast.
great place to spend some time with friends in a beautiful part of East Villa, good pizza and great homemade pastas. I will definitely come
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tartufo Pizza, Gnocchi
Would give a 4.5 if I could. Really the only downside is that my group was a bit crowded at our table, we were a group of 5 and seated at a table for 4 which was a bit squished with plates, jackets, and especially as tables around us filled up. The more important part - the food! We shared the penne alla vodka and ravioli and the margarita and the 4 formaggi pizzas. The margarita pizza was your classic good pizza, and the penne vodka was very good as well. The ravioli was my personal favorite, the balsamic drizzle on top really makes the dish. It's been a few weeks since we ate here and I've still been wanting to go back to get it again. Overall would recommend, if you're going at a busy time it's definitely worth making a reservation as it will fill up. A great place to get food before going out, the combination we ordered was perfect (in my opinion) to not be hungry throughout the night but not feel too full.
Tartufo Pizza is OMG delicious. As good as any we have had in Italy. All homemade everything here. Owner Niko has been making pizza for 20 years and it shows! Bravo, hidden gem at St. Marks & Ave A. So good we decided to order the Fettuccine Bolognese and just take leftovers home. So how was the pasta you ask? Don't bother. Breaks the ten out of ten scale! We rarely review but you can't go wrong here.
Amazing food! Best steak gnocchi I have ever tried! Service is great, the ambiance is very chilled. The pomegranate spritz is 100% great! The chef amazing! Definitely will be coming back I recommend you to come here. Oh and let me not forget to mention the Nutella pizza and tiramisu!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Focaccia Bruschetta, Caeser Salad, Gnocchi, Fried Calamari
Loved this spot! Highly recommend for a large group dinner - there is a $70 pre-fixe with unlimited wine and beer or $85 one that includes aperol spritzThe music is fun and the atmosphere is super lively! The service was great and the food is delicious. Pre-fixe includes 2 apps, a salad, 2 pizzas & 2 pastas. GF options available as well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Focaccia Bruschetta, Caeser Salad, Margherita 12
It's a decent pizza/pasta spot. The best is the pesto because they use a very fresh pesto and heavily slather it on the pizza. The other pizza was good too. The dough was not the classic neoplotan style pizza and no charred taste but the pizza didn't a huge "flop" factor which was good. The Arrabbiata pasta was average, the sauce was good but Arrabbiata isn't traditionally a challenging sauce to perfect and the pasta itself was giving barilla.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
It's a decent pizza/pasta spot. The best is the pesto because they use a very fresh pesto and heavily slather it on the pizza. The other pizza was good too. The dough was not the classic neoplotan style pizza and no charred taste but the pizza didn't a huge "flop" factor which was good. The Arrabbiata pasta was average, the sauce was good but Arrabbiata isn't traditionally a challenging sauce to perfect and the pasta itself was giving barilla. Service and ambiance were good
Great food and excellent service. We'll be back soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
They have nice prices for happy hour. However the food was ehh. I don't think I would come again. You can get much better pizza elsewhere. Also the place is small and cramp.
Waiters were friendly and attentive. Happy hour deals (food and drink) were worth it. I split one HH pasta and one HH pizza with my friend and it filled us up. The food came out really quickly too. The restaurant is great for friends to get together.
Great food and excellent service. We'll be back soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arrived on time for reservation. Had to wait 20min to be seated outside in winter. They said we couldn't order pizza, but we saw pizzas being served to others. Pasta took 1h15m to arrive. Pasta tasty, free
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Meatballs, Fettuccine Bolognese
Best pregame spot in St. Marks. Amazing happy hour, amazing food, and amazing service. Last time I went, our waiter was very attentive-- we hadn't even finished our glasses of wine, and he was already giving us another glass without us asking too. 10000/10