Ichabod's

15 Irving Pl, New York
(212) 777-5102

Recent Reviews

Steve C 032

I've come here quite often. The first time I came here was in 2013; a few months after they opened. The service wasn't the best at during that time, but's definitely vastly improved and did so quickly. When at our place in Gramercy Park, we always make it a point to come here.

Ryan Jones

Pretty good! Burger was a tiny bit over cooked but otherwise, very good!

Chris S

Had brunch a few times here and loved it (burger), we returned for dinner last night which was phenomenal. One of our new top places to eat.

Nick Chilson

Nice place, fairly small, not too expensive. The food was generally good. I had the eggs under covers, which I wasn't super wild about, but my girlfriend got the country fried chicked with biscuits and gravy which was very good. Seems like they do the more southern inspired dishes the best.

Kevin Marshall

I had a nice brunch with my daughter this past Sunday. I believe I left my credit card there - actually I don't think it was handed back to me when I received my check. In either case, I called the restaurant on my way to the airport and spoke to a man who seemed very harried. He said that he wasn't at the restaurant and would have someone call me back. He quickly hung up on me before I could say thanks, bye, or anything else. I didn't hear back from anyone. My wife then proceeded to call the restaurant the rest of the day (while I was flying) and no one answered the phone. She left a voicemail message and no one called back. I then called the restaurant yesterday and left another voice mail. And again, no one returned my call. I will now have to cancel my credit card. It is a business card so this will cause a lot of disruption and aggravation.

Kevin Marshall

I had a nice brunch with my daughter this past Sunday. I believe I left my credit card there - actually I don't think it was handed back to me when I received my check. In either case, I called the restaurant on my way to the airport and spoke to a man who seemed very harried. He said that he wasn't at the restaurant and would have someone call me back. He quickly hung up on me before I could say thanks, bye, or anything else. I didn't hear back from anyone. My wife then proc

Vanessa Correa

The host was nice even though we didn't have a reservation. Some people didn't show for theirs and he sat us right away. The food was scrumptious and all the wait staff were responsive, fast and professional.

Carlos Robles

The French toast was really good.

Katherine Frankel

This is a delicious little restaurant in every way. Stylish, cosy and welcoming with super friendly and helpful staff and great food. Cool music and ambiance but you can hear yourself talk and really enjoy your time there. Now that we found it we are definitely going back!

Ben L.

First time I came here and it was very cool. The atmosphere was extremely relaxed, bartender as well as waiters were extremely nice and attentive and last but not least the burger I ordered was amazing!!! Thumbs up.

Wayne Mickletz

was greeted with a very arrogant "can I help you" by the manager. The bartender disappeared four times while making my drink; while putting the wrong spirits in the shaker. after disappearing for the fifth time, I disappeared. I had a great time here last year, but never again!

Riti K.

Went here for Sunday brunch with some friends visiting from San Francisco. Food was good, but the service was really bad. Maybe they were short staffed or something (certainly seemed that way to us!), but instead of communicating upfront and apologizing, the wait staff were all cranky and rude. - My friend asked for water without ice, our server said "I'll try, but this [jug he was carrying] has ice" and basically proceeded to pour her cold water with ice. - Plates were slammed on the table. - One of our 4 coffee cups was dirty (with lipstick marks on it) and when we pointed it out to our server, he merely said "oh, that's easily fixed" (no apologies) and then proceeded to replace the cup; meanwhile he had stopped midway filling my cup of coffee and we had to call him back again so that he could fill it. - We asked for hot sauce and reminded the staff 2-3 times, but never actually got it. It clearly wasn't just us having these issues. A family at the next table had repeatedly asked for coffee and been trying to get the wait staff's attention for 10-15 minutes. One of them finally got up and went and got the jug of coffee himself! Of course, when the server saw that, he went up, but instead of apologizing to the family, spoke to them rather sharply. All in all, the food is good and the place is decent, but the poor service really subtracted from the entire experience. I really do think the staff was just overworked though, so hopefully we'll have a better experience in the future!

Beth H.

My favorite restaurant in NYC! The food is always top notch. It's a must go to every trip to nyc. This time we had brunch. I had the pimento cheese burger with egg on an English muffin. It was amazing.

Lindsey F.

Sunday Brunch review: I get it, NYC likes to cram people in super tight and uncomfortably because it's charming or whatever. nah. it was super drafty on an early December morning and my mom had to keep her coat on. nah. turn the heat up, people want to be warm and cozy in winter. the waiter forgot my drink order and i got my food before my drink (Bramble, which was fine at best). nah. i get that this kind of thing happens, but if you've forgotten my order, you should comp my drink. avocado toast was fine. mom's diner breakfast was fine. serviceable, decent ambiance, but I wouldn't go out of my way to try again.

Amy Y.

Surprisingly half empty for Sunday brunch. Very filling and hearty standard brunch items. Recommend for a good brunch fix! Avocado toast jazzed up with cilantro and pickled radish. It works really well! The add crab option was currently unavailable. Cinnamon toast came with three thick slices. The coffee maple syrup was very addicting.

Load More