Il Pastaio

$$$ • Italian, Bars

About Il Pastaio

Il Pastaio is a popular and delicious spot in the Flatiron area, known for its flavorful pasta dishes. Located inside Eataly NYC, the restaurant offers a great concept where seating is at the bar, allowing guests to watch the chefs prepare fresh pasta right in front of them. The menu includes a variety of options, such as the tonnarelli cacio e pepe, which is the ultimate comfort food with creamy Pecorino cheese and perfectly cooked pasta. Another highlight is the Fresh Tajarin pasta with White Truffles, a seasonal special. The restaurant also features small plates, like the tigelle and the Burrata with Fried Zucchini, all well-presented and fresh. There is a selection of wines, and the knowledgeable staff, including attentive team members like José, is happy to help with wine pairings. While the prices may be slightly high for the portion sizes, the restaurant's ambiance and delicious food make it a great spot to enjoy a meal. Be prepared for a wait on weekends, but weekdays may offer more availability.