John & Tony's Pizzeria
CLOSED$ •
About John & Tony's Pizzeria
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
People in New York Also Viewed
Quantum Leap
Vegetarian, Vegan
Treadwell Park
Bar, American, New American
Ritz Diner
Diner, Vegetarian
John & Tony's Pizzeria might be a hit or miss. Some find it overpriced with lack of seasoning, while others praise it as one of the best plain pies in the neighborhood. The restaurant has a history tied to a previous location, with heroes that don't quite live up to the original John & Tony's. It's worth a try for those seeking a well-done pizza with hot sauce on the side.