Made In New York Pizza
421 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(646) 484-6200
Customers' Favorites
Peperonie Pilz White & Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Sausage & Jalapenos Pizza
Garlic Knots with Marinara
Pepperoni Mushroom Pie
Spicy Pepperoni Pizza
Spicy Pepperoni Pie
White Spinach Pizza
Garlic Knots w Sauce
Cheese Pizza Slice
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Round Pies
Cheese Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano.
Pepperoni Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school large pepperoni.
Margherita Pie
Vodka Pie
Gluten Free Pie
Sausage Pepperoni Pie
Sausage Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school sliced, sweet Italian sausage.
Mushroom Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with fresh mushrooms.
Buffalo Chicken Pie
White Spinach Pie
Spinach Mushroom Pie
Sausage Mushroom Pie
BBQ Chicken Pie
Sausage Jalapeno Pie
Pepperoni Mushroom Pie
Square Pies
Spicy Pepperoni Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano topped with spicy cupping pepperoni.
Grandma Pie
Eggplant Pie
White Pie
Classic Sicilian Pie
Upside Down Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano.
Veggie Pie
Sides
5 Garlic Knots w/ Sauce
Pizza Dough
Chicken Roll
Cheese Calzone
Pepperoni Pinwheel
1 Knot
Salads
Cesar Salad
House Salad
Water
Poland Spring
Smart Water
Side Sauces
Ranch
Marinara
Mike's Hot Honey
Balsamic
Golden Italian
BBQ
Desserts
NY Cheesecake
Tiramisu
Cannolis
Chocolate Cake
Sides
5 Garlic Knots w/ Sauce
Pizza Dough
Chicken Roll
Cheese Calzone
Pepperoni Pinwheel
1 Knot
Side Sauces
Ranch
Marinara
Mike's Hot Honey
Balsamic
Golden Italian
BBQ
Round Pies
Cheese Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano.
Pepperoni Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school large pepperoni.
Margherita Pie
Vodka Pie
Gluten Free Pie
Sausage Pepperoni Pie
Sausage Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school sliced, sweet Italian sausage.
Mushroom Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with fresh mushrooms.
Buffalo Chicken Pie
White Spinach Pie
Spinach Mushroom Pie
Sausage Mushroom Pie
BBQ Chicken Pie
Sausage Jalapeno Pie
Pepperoni Mushroom Pie
Square Pies
Spicy Pepperoni Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano topped with spicy cupping pepperoni.
Grandma Pie
Eggplant Pie
White Pie
Classic Sicilian Pie
Upside Down Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano.
Veggie Pie
Desserts
NY Cheesecake
Tiramisu
Cannolis
Chocolate Cake
Salads
Cesar Salad
House Salad
Round Pies
Cheese Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano.
Pepperoni Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school large pepperoni.
Margherita Pie
Vodka Pie
Gluten Free Pie
Sausage Pepperoni Pie
Sausage Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school sliced, sweet Italian sausage.
Mushroom Pie
California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with fresh mushrooms.
Buffalo Chicken Pie
White Spinach Pie
Spinach Mushroom Pie
Sausage Mushroom Pie
BBQ Chicken Pie
Sausage Jalapeno Pie
Pepperoni Mushroom Pie
Square Pies
Spicy Pepperoni Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano topped with spicy cupping pepperoni.
Grandma Pie
Eggplant Pie
White Pie
Classic Sicilian Pie
Upside Down Pie
Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano.
Veggie Pie
Sides
5 Garlic Knots w/ Sauce
Pizza Dough
Chicken Roll
Cheese Calzone
Pepperoni Pinwheel
1 Knot
Salads
Cesar Salad
House Salad
Water
Poland Spring
Smart Water
Fountain Drinks
Fountain Drinks
Side Sauces
Ranch
Marinara
Mike's Hot Honey
Balsamic
Golden Italian
BBQ
Water
Poland Spring
Smart Water
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Stopped in for a pizza on a Saturday night with family. We chose to sit outside. The pizza was fantastic! I loved the crust. The staff was pleasant and I'd go back in a heartbeat!
November 2024
Every pizza tastes fantastic here! My favourite are the vodka and the one with artichokes!
Kid-friendliness: I saw local moms and children stopping by for dinner and sitting the patio area for dinner with kids
Kid-friendliness: I saw local moms and children stopping by for dinner and sitting the patio area for dinner with kids
October 2024
Pretty solid slice shop on the west side! Maybe a little inconsistent in terms of crispness of the crust - my first slice was absolutely perfect but the second one could have done with a bit more time in the oven. Lots of cheese and pretty good toppings though. I’d come back.
October 2024
You May Also Like
Sarabeth's - 423 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
Brunch, American, International, Vegetarian
Joe's Steam Rice Roll - 422 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
Cantonese, Vegetarian
The Wolfe - 425 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
American, Bar, Sports Bar, Cocktail Bar