New Mexican Restaurants in New York, NY

The Allerton Rooftop Bar • $$
145 E 39th St, New York

Customers` Favorites

Margarita Frozen de Maracuyá
Fifth Rol Shrimp Teaspura
Bailey's French Toast
Chips and Guacamole
Margherita Pizza
Al Pastor Tacos
Frozen Margarita
Fingers de Pollo
Tacos Al Pastor
Chicken Tacos

“We were in town for a wedding, and this was the place where they hosted a pre-wedding celebration. The atmosphere was exciting, and regardless of the large crowd, the servers did an amazing job. Everyone had such an amazing and memorable time.“

4.1 Good178 Reviews
Calabrije's Upper East Side Cocktail Bar • $$
1619 York Ave, New York

Customers` Favorites

Potato & Chorizo Tacos Order of 2
Chicken Fajita Tacos Order of 2
Chicken Tinga Tacos Order of 2
Chicken Mole Tacos Order of 2
Carnitas Tacos Order of 2
Pineapple-Lime Margherita
Shrimp Tacos Order of 2
Steak Tacos Order of 2
Guacamole & Chips
Birria Tacos

“This place is super cute and the drinks are very good!! Went with my sister for a trifecta kinda day and the margs did not disappoint! We didn’t have the food but the people around us ordered some items and it looked and smelled super great!

The place is pretty small as far as like it’s just the front area but they have a bar style table in the middle and tables on both sides. Music was pretty standard we didn’t go on a brunch day so not sure if it’s more turnt but we had a good time! Yes they have Tajin and they can put that on your rim!

We also went back a second time and go to go drinks and they were delicious there’s like over 15 flavors so that makes it super fun!

I didn’t get much videos but I did get a super cool photo! Try it out affordable prices and great drinks!“

4.7 Superb57 Reviews
La Diagonal Agaveria Mexican • $$
185 St Nicholas Ave, New York

Customers` Favorites

Crab Guacamole with Sliced Radish
La Autentica Margarita
Tuna ¨Al Pastor¨
Chips and Salsa
Salmón Tartar
Queso Fundido
Shrimp Tacos
Tuna Tartar
Quesadillas
Yucca Fries

“The food & drinks were delicious!!!! The service was great!!!! The atmosphere was nice & cozy!!!! I had the jumbo shrimp w/black beans & rice. My husband had the sirloin steak w/potatoes & spinach. We both had Long Island Ice Teas!!!! OMG everything was GREAT!!!! We will definitely go back!!!!🙂“

3.9 Good76 Reviews
Taqueria On Tenth New Mexican Cuisine • $$
313 10th Ave, New York

Customers` Favorites

Orden De Guacamole
Tacos De Carnitas
Tostadas De Tinga
El Pastor Tacos
Cilantro Crush
Avocado Toast
Cheese Fondue
Chips and Dips
Shrimp Salad
Street Tacos

“Great Margs & Tacos, but a bit pricey! The portions were a very good size. Two people could easily be satisfied by splitting the dip platter and 3 Tacos. The Birria Tacos were good but personally thought they could have had a bit more flavor. Al Pastor was tasty and came with a couple extra sauces.

The service was lacking, there was only two tables in the whole restaurant at the time we went and yet my water glass still set empty for most of our visit.

The atmosphere was great. We got a table in the corner facing the street and it was great to be able to people watch while we enjoyed our food.“

4.3 Superb123 Reviews
Empellon Taqueria Waterline Square Mexican • $$$
645 W 59th St, New York

Customers` Favorites

Guacamole and Chips
Fish Tempura Taco
Hamachi Tartare
Nachos
Tacos

“A great evening of food and friends!“

3 Average58 Reviews
Habanero Pibil Mexican • $
710 Broadway, New York

Customers` Favorites

Quesadillas
Burritos
Tacos

“Best Mexican tacos come from this Best Mexican food truck located on corner of Washington Place & Broadway. Freshly made to order and fresh taste including slice of pineapple, pickled onions, home made salsas green mild, hot, very hot. Tender pieces of carnitas, carne asada, chicken — all put together deliciously!“

4.9 Superb33 Reviews
Vallarta Tropical Seafood •
106 Norfolk St, New York

“5/5 stars! Amazing Mexican food and cocktails! Fresh flavors and exceptional service. The shrimp gorditas and aguachile vallarta were outstanding.

Hands down, one good seafood spot! Delicious, authentic dishes, and a cozy atmosphere.“

4.9 Superb15 Reviews
Bobby's Night Out Bar & Grill • $$
Recommended
145 Loisaida Ave, New York

Customers` Favorites

Vegan Chorizo Breakfast Burrito
Grilled Chicken Burrito
Nachos with Chicken
Frozen Marg WW
Steak Tacos
Disco Fries
Wings
Chips

“Went on a Wednesday for happy hour. Margaritas were good, had the wings ($1 wings Wednesday) they were yummy. The music was good, not sure who's Playlist, but it was a good mix. Got there like 6 PM wasn’t much of a crowd but it got filled up pretty fast!“

4.3 Superb82 Reviews
9

Kahlo

Kahlo Mexican • $$$
525 W 29th St, New York

Customers` Favorites

Berkshire Cochinita Pibil
Kahlo & Rivera Guacamole
Yellow Fin Tuna Tostadas
Branzino Manchamanteles
Black Truffle Esquites
Guacamole and Chips
Maine Lobster
Guacamole Dip
Chicken Mole
Flan De Coco

“Ambience is wonderful, service was good, food is good/fine. Nothing wowed me. I think certain dishes would wow if they had more acid? Like some lime juice in the street corn? We had a nice dinner. Both cocktails and mocktails were great. Biggest complaint was I ordered chilean sea bass which comes with kale, and the baby kale clearly wasnt fresh and had many yellowing pieces in it. Other food was fine, just really expect better for this price point.“

4.2 Good205 Reviews
Summer Salt Mexican • $
30 E 23rd St, New York

Customers` Favorites

Crispy White Fish Basa Tacos with Generous Guac Cilantro Pico De Gallo
Pan Seared Adobo Shrimp Burrito
Baja Crispy Fish Burrito
Baja Crispy Fish Bowl
Baja Crispy Fish Taco
Carne Asada Burrito
Pollo Asado Taco
Pollo Asado Bowl
Carne Asada Taco
Baja Fish Bowl

“Amazing spot for lunch a simple frozen marg or paloma. I come here at least once a week. Definitely try a burrito with tater tots. All of them are good, but my fave is the carne asada. Staff is always friendly and attentive. Can be crazy busy if you go between Noon and 2pm on weekdays.“

4.2 Good98 Reviews
Arriba Arriba Mexican • $$
762 9th Ave, New York

Customers` Favorites

Chimichanga with Beans and Rice
Passion Fruit Margherita
Chicken Quesadilla
Chips and Salsa
Grilled Octopus
Chicken Nachos
Enchiladas Mole
Fried Ice Cream
Pollo Al Mole
Rice and Beans

“Great food! we go every time we are in the city.“

4 Good124 Reviews
La CANTINA HEIGHTS Bar & Grill • $$
4460 Broadway, New York

Customers` Favorites

Box 3 Churrasco Grilled Chicken Served w Mashed Potatoes Tostones & Vegetables
Churrasco Yuca Fries Tostones
La Cantina Sampler
Chicken Tacos
Wings

“My favorite place to decompress. Not too crowded, some of the staff are nice and attentive but you have some that appear to not want to serve certain kind of people( I had to ask one of the workers who serves the water, “how come that everytime that I arrive, you never serve me water when I order an alcoholic beverage). He went to tell the female worker to serve the water to me??. That behavior should not be tolerated especially when you are a worker for someone else business and you are behaving in a bias manner. Other than that, the place is a gem and the food is reasonable for the price.“

3 Average35 Reviews