Nick + Stef’s Steakhouse

Name: Nick + Stef’s Steakhouse
Address: 9 Pennsylvania Plaza, New York, New York, 10001, US
Telephone: (212) 563-4444
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.2

$$$$ • Steakhouses, Beer Bar, Cocktail Bar

Hours:
9 Pennsylvania Plaza, New York
(212) 563-4444

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Nick + Stef’s Steakhouse

Nick + Stef's Steakhouse is a popular restaurant in New York City known for its energetic atmosphere and excellent food. It is a great spot to dine before events at Madison Square Garden, whether it's a Knicks game, a concert, or a Rangers game. The food at Nick + Stef's Steakhouse is consistently praised, with the steak being a highlight. Customers have described the food as "amazing" and "very good," with the oysters also noted as fabulous. The service is highly regarded, with staff being welcoming, attentive, and helpful, even during busy times. Guests have appreciated the excellent service, with special mentions of staff members like Georgia and Jerry, who provided attentive care.

While the restaurant can get crowded, especially before events, the overall experience remains excellent. Customers have noted the "class location" and have recommended it to anyone visiting the area. Many reviews highlight the delicious food, including perfectly cooked steak, and the exceptional dessert experience with espresso martinis. The atmosphere is quiet and relaxed at times, making for an enjoyable pre-show dinner. The menu offers a variety of dishes, such as the flat iron steak, Ribeye, and filet, all prepared to order and praised for their quality. The potato wedge fries are especially well-liked, seasoned and cooked just right. The artisanal bread is also a highlight, served hot and worth every dollar, despite being served with salted butter, which some might find less ideal.

Customers have also shared their appreciation for the overall experience, noting that despite minor issues like drinks taking time or feeling cramped, the positive aspects and quality of food outweigh the negatives. The staff's professionalism and attentive service, especially from servers like Steve, contribute to a memorable visit. Many guests express a desire to return, often citing the great food, friendly service, and convenient location as reasons to revisit Nick + Stef's Steakhouse.