Pickler Sandwich Shop

216 E 45th St, New York
(646) 869-9026

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Prosciutto Grilled Cheese
French Fries - Small
Tuna Fish Sandwich
Rachel Sandwich
Hot Pastrami
Turkey Club
Pickles
Rachel
Avocado
Reuben

Featured items
French Fries - Small
Thrice-cooked, fried in peanut oil
Egg & Avo
Two Fried Eggs, Pepper Jack, Chipotle Mayo, Avocado, Tomato, Toasted Multigrain.
Breakfast BLT
Two Fried Eggs, Pork Bacon, Cheddar, Garlic Mayo, Tomato, Shredded Iceberg, Toasted Sourdough.
SEC
Two Fried Eggs, Cheddar, Pork Sausage, Toasted Sourdough.
Side of Hash Browns
Two Hash Browns. Fried in Peanut Oil.
French Fries - Large
Thrice-cooked, fried in peanut oil
Black & White Cookie

Breakfast
Breakfast BLT
Two Fried Eggs, Pork Bacon, Cheddar, Garlic Mayo, Tomato, Shredded Iceberg, Toasted Sourdough.
BEC
Two Fried Eggs, Cheddar, Pork Bacon, Toasted Sourdough.
SEC
Two Fried Eggs, Cheddar, Pork Sausage, Toasted Sourdough.
Egg & Avo
Two Fried Eggs, Pepper Jack, Chipotle Mayo, Avocado, Tomato, Toasted Multigrain.
Side of Hash Browns
Two Hash Browns. Fried in Peanut Oil.

Sides
French Fries - Small
Thrice-cooked, fried in peanut oil
French Fries - Large
Thrice-cooked, fried in peanut oil
Black & White Cookie
Chips
Pickles
Cup of Egg Salad
Cup of Tuna Salad
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Tenders fried in peanut oil

Featured items
Chicken Club Sandwich
Roast Chicken / Pork Bacon / Cheddar / Mayo / Avocado / Tomato / Romaine / Sourdough. PRESSED
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Fried Chicken Tenders, Buffalo, Ranch, Shredded Iceberg, Wheat Wrap. Tenders fried in peanut oil.
Turkey Club Sandwich
Smoked Turkey / Pork Bacon / Pepper Jack / Mayo / Avocado / Tomato / Romaine / Sourdough. Pressed.
Reuben Sandwich
Pastrami / Swiss / 1000 Island / Sauerkraut / Rye Bread. Pressed.
Hot Turkey
Smoked Turkey, Pepper Jack, Avocado Mayo, Chipotle Mayo, Pickled Jalapeno, Ciabatta Roll. Pressed.
Caprese Grilled Cheese
Mozzarella / Pesto / Tomato / Balsamic Glaze / Sourdough. Pressed.
Rachel Sandwich
Turkey pastrami / Swiss / 1000 Island / Sauerkraut / Rye Bread. PRESSED
Prosciutto Grilled Cheese
Prosciutto / Mozzarella / Fig Spread / Arugula / Sourdough. Pressed.
Avocado Sandwich
Avocado / Hummus / Tomato / Sprouts / Romaine / Multigrain Bread.
Brie
Prosciutto, Brie, Basil Pesto, Tomato, Balsamic Galze, Toasted Ciabatta.
Hot Pastrami
Pastrami / Swiss / Brown Mustard / Toasted Rye.
Buffalo Grilled Cheese
Fried Chicken Tenders, Buffalo, Ranch, Mozzarella, Sourdough. Tenders fried in peanut oil.
Bacon Cheeseburger
Bacon, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickles.
Veg Burger
Beyond Patty, Seeded Burger Bun. Toppings not included.
Turkey Pesto Burger
Basil pesto, tomato, balsamic glaze.
BBQ Burger
Swiss, Crispy Onions, BBQ Sauce.
French Fries - Large
Thrice-cooked, fried in peanut oil
Tuna Melt
Tuna Salad, Cheddar, Multigrain. Pressed.
Spicy Burger
Chipotle Mayo, Crispy Onions, Grilled Jalapeno.

Classic Sandwiches and Wraps
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Fried Chicken Tenders, Buffalo, Ranch, Shredded Iceberg, Wheat Wrap. Tenders fried in peanut oil.
Rachel Sandwich
Turkey pastrami / Swiss / 1000 Island / Sauerkraut / Rye Bread. PRESSED
Turkey Club Sandwich
Smoked Turkey / Pork Bacon / Pepper Jack / Mayo / Avocado / Tomato / Romaine / Sourdough. Pressed.
Tuna Fish Sandwich
Tuna Salad / Romaine / Tomato / Red Onion / Multigrain
Chicken Club Sandwich
Roast Chicken / Pork Bacon / Cheddar / Mayo / Avocado / Tomato / Romaine / Sourdough. PRESSED
Reuben Sandwich
Pastrami / Swiss / 1000 Island / Sauerkraut / Rye Bread. Pressed.
Prosciutto Grilled Cheese
Prosciutto / Mozzarella / Fig Spread / Arugula / Sourdough. Pressed.
Hot Pastrami
Pastrami / Swiss / Brown Mustard / Toasted Rye.
Buffalo Grilled Cheese
Fried Chicken Tenders, Buffalo, Ranch, Mozzarella, Sourdough. Tenders fried in peanut oil.
BLT Sandwich
Pork Bacon / Mayo / Romaine / Tomato / Toasted Multigrain
Hot Turkey
Smoked Turkey, Pepper Jack, Avocado Mayo, Chipotle Mayo, Pickled Jalapeno, Ciabatta Roll. Pressed.
Brie
Prosciutto, Brie, Basil Pesto, Tomato, Balsamic Galze, Toasted Ciabatta.
Tuna Melt
Tuna Salad, Cheddar, Multigrain. Pressed.
Roast Beef Panini
Roast Beef / Pepper Jack / Mayo / Avocado / Sourdough. Pressed.

Burgers
Bacon Cheeseburger
Bacon, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickles.
Spicy Burger
Chipotle Mayo, Crispy Onions, Grilled Jalapeno.
Turkey Pesto Burger
Basil pesto, tomato, balsamic glaze.
BBQ Burger
Swiss, Crispy Onions, BBQ Sauce.

Vegetarian and Vegan Sandwiches and Wraps
Avocado Sandwich
Avocado / Hummus / Tomato / Sprouts / Romaine / Multigrain Bread.
Caprese Grilled Cheese
Mozzarella / Pesto / Tomato / Balsamic Glaze / Sourdough. Pressed.
Egg Salad Sandwich
Egg Salad / Tomato / Red Onion / Fresh Pepper / Toasted Multigrain
Veg Burger
Beyond Patty, Seeded Burger Bun. Toppings not included.

Sides
French Fries - Small
Thrice-cooked, fried in peanut oil
French Fries - Large
Thrice-cooked, fried in peanut oil
Black & White Cookie
Chips
Pickles
Cup of Egg Salad
Cup of Tuna Salad
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Tenders fried in peanut oil

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+34 photos
Photo credit: google
+33 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Great place to go in if you are trying to order a quick meal. When you walk in,, you go over to these giant kiosks to make your order. The kiosk ordering is a little confusing because there a lot of variation options and you have to scroll past a lot of them to order. I saw a lot of people ordering the buffalo chicken grilled cheese so I thought I would do the same. It was a solid sandwich but not something I would order again because it wasn’t filling enough for me. There are...
August 2025
The order process is on a kiosk only. The sandwich was good. The coffee was horrible. My husband usually will just drink what he has paid for even if its not good- he had to throw this away it was so bad.
June 2025
Great sandwich and pickles for the price. Simple model which is nice. The only thing I didn't love about the place was the lack of human interaction or recommendations - I was a little on the fence about what to order and normally I like to ask the person working there what they recommend and the way this place just isn't really set up for that.
The food was good.
April 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

The Comfort Diner - 214 E 45th St
Diner, Vegetarian
Ben & Jack's Steakhouse - 219 E 44th St
Steak House, Wine Bar, Vegan
Veerays - 213 E 45th St
Indian, Cocktail Bar

Pickler Sandwich Shop

216 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017
(646) 869-9026