facebook instagram facebook instagram

The Mermaid Inn

CLOSED
$$ •

570 Amsterdam Ave, New York

The Mermaid Inn Reviews

We had 730 reservations on Friday night and were seated immediately. The entire restaurant and bar were packed. This is a lively and loud place, especially so close to happy hour. By 830, the volume lowered to tolerable even tho restaurant still full. The food was excellent as was the service - our waiter was a doll. The simple grilled fish was great - we had cod. The mac’n cheese was delicious. No dessert menu but everyone was served a complimentary little dish of chocolate...read full review

We tried a variety of happy hour dishes, such as clam chowder, and the lobster mac'n cheese. Everything was great, we had excellent service and we enjoyed the vibe. It's too bad the UWS location is closing.

My friend and I enjoyed the most delicious dinner! The service was so quick and the food was delicious. We had 2 different salmon entrees on the menu- hers was the simple fish and mine was the one on kale. So fresh, cooked perfectly and amazing flavor. The Brussels sprouts were also great as was a very generous side salad. The bonus of the chocolate pot de creme was a wonderful final touch by the chef! I highly recommend!

More Reviews(601)

Ratings

View all photos
Updated on: